Mafia #45: Cabin Fever...The Play
- Thread starter jpappy789
- Start date
- Status
Speaking of nothing solid where are your theories RB? Typically your are right out there bringing people out in the forefront and trying to root out the evils. This time around you are laying back and letting your accomplices do your work for you. Yes you are posting but your posts are pretty useless to the Town and are very non-committal. Surely you must have some thoughts in that evil brain of yours. You must have some suspects...I'd like to see some real posts from you. Why has your game changed so much this time around...You and I both know why and the Town will soon find out if they come to their senses.
Perhaps you have an accomplice on your mind. The many site issues caused you to hit the multi-quote on Ogre's post. Nice one. Did the many site issues cause you to hit Cat too?
DD, sorry to see ya go...hope everything is ok with ya 
Dawg, yes you make some good points there about RB and makes one think. Problem is it is also a nice way to "set someone up". I will have to see a bit more before deciding myself. A third thing here to think about maybe you are both a team one madman, trying to distance.
I really am not seeing what you are all talking about with Ogre personally...maybe I've been out of the game to long, but I am not getting a odd feeling from him right now.
Coler, you have me a bit nervous though..not saying much (I know I don't have room to talk this round), but the post about having a list and not saying who bothered me then you post the list but leave out reasons for it?? This makes me wonder most about you.
Dawg, yes you make some good points there about RB and makes one think. Problem is it is also a nice way to "set someone up". I will have to see a bit more before deciding myself. A third thing here to think about maybe you are both a team one madman, trying to distance.
I really am not seeing what you are all talking about with Ogre personally...maybe I've been out of the game to long, but I am not getting a odd feeling from him right now.
Coler, you have me a bit nervous though..not saying much (I know I don't have room to talk this round), but the post about having a list and not saying who bothered me then you post the list but leave out reasons for it?? This makes me wonder most about you.
Well that sucks. It severly limits how much I can participate because I am on base at 6am and off at 5pm. So as you can see I miss an entire day of important time.
I have to vote now so. I vote to banish noodles. I just have a funny feeling about her. She is always on and seems to jump on board with people very easily. But Im at a terrible disadvantage because I cant see what is going to happen tomorrow. And if I dont vote I will UD which would be uber lame.
Okay, I am finally done going back through all the posts....sadly, it didn't help as much as I would hope. All I managed to conclude is that noods clearly has too much free time as she posts at least twice as often as everyone else! (j/k...I like how you are so active!)
Here is where I am at right now:
I disagree that the madman would "lay low". I think the madman would (hopefully) be intelligent enough to post often enough so that they don't appear to be suspicious. Not posting doesn't help them blend in. Furthermore, I think having such an important role would make them more interested in the game, keep more tabs on it, and much more likely to chime in. Therefore, I am (for now) ruling out both Lady G and Eddie, because their posts are too infrequent.
On the flip side, posting too often would make one suspicious, in the center of attention, and would increase their chances of slipping up. So, I am ruling out Noodles. However, I still have my suspicions because maybe she just always posts this often and she is good at not changing her gameplay. She also hasn't given me any other reasons to be suspicious of her.
Nothing appears suspect about either Dawg or Ogre...for now. But I want to reread the posts again tomorrow before making my final call.
I have mixed feelings on lucky... Is his confusion just a coverup? For now, I am going to believe he is really just a confused newb...and I think the madman would pay more careful attention to the rules where they are so involved. It also may imply that he doesn't have an accomplice to help him.
That leaves me with: Rb, Rich and Coler.
Rb- Has given us little in the way of theories or help. He also was encouraging people to shift their votes around, and "pair up" before last nightfall, which leaves me feeling uneasy.
Coler- Has had pretty random behavior that I find suspect. However, his posting amount to me is borderline "too few"...but I am thinking he may at least be an accomplice.
Rich- We have deduced in all liklihood that at least one noob is evil, so naturally given that I am a noob and the above reason for ruling out lucky, I would have to suspect Rich. Furthermore, he recently suggested that my supposed quietness was suspect, despite the fact that there are people who have posted far less than I. This was after the conclusions were made about at least one newb being involved, so I suspect he wants to sway people towards me for being that person, and away from himself.
Of my three top suspects, I am still unsure of which I will vote for, but it will probably be one of those three.
Here is where I am at right now:
I disagree that the madman would "lay low". I think the madman would (hopefully) be intelligent enough to post often enough so that they don't appear to be suspicious. Not posting doesn't help them blend in. Furthermore, I think having such an important role would make them more interested in the game, keep more tabs on it, and much more likely to chime in. Therefore, I am (for now) ruling out both Lady G and Eddie, because their posts are too infrequent.
On the flip side, posting too often would make one suspicious, in the center of attention, and would increase their chances of slipping up. So, I am ruling out Noodles. However, I still have my suspicions because maybe she just always posts this often and she is good at not changing her gameplay. She also hasn't given me any other reasons to be suspicious of her.
Nothing appears suspect about either Dawg or Ogre...for now. But I want to reread the posts again tomorrow before making my final call.
I have mixed feelings on lucky... Is his confusion just a coverup? For now, I am going to believe he is really just a confused newb...and I think the madman would pay more careful attention to the rules where they are so involved. It also may imply that he doesn't have an accomplice to help him.
That leaves me with: Rb, Rich and Coler.
Rb- Has given us little in the way of theories or help. He also was encouraging people to shift their votes around, and "pair up" before last nightfall, which leaves me feeling uneasy.
Coler- Has had pretty random behavior that I find suspect. However, his posting amount to me is borderline "too few"...but I am thinking he may at least be an accomplice.
Rich- We have deduced in all liklihood that at least one noob is evil, so naturally given that I am a noob and the above reason for ruling out lucky, I would have to suspect Rich. Furthermore, he recently suggested that my supposed quietness was suspect, despite the fact that there are people who have posted far less than I. This was after the conclusions were made about at least one newb being involved, so I suspect he wants to sway people towards me for being that person, and away from himself.
Of my three top suspects, I am still unsure of which I will vote for, but it will probably be one of those three.
Not laying low at all...you might want to check the post counts before you say I am laying low. Any game that starts on a weekday wth mumerous newbies has a slow kick off. And yes, the site down time has had a big affect on that.
Toss in the two UDs, one being the Doc, and things went bad on night one.
I believe the catfish murder was a pure stab in the dark (pun intended) by the madman. A very Lucky one. Even if he culd pass on tidbits of info that would be wrong, good info being passed on has been lost.
You ask my thoughts? not much more to go on other than the exchange on day one with noodles/cat and a bit of opi.
Noodles is one of the better players left, and tops my list right now, followed by Ogre. Ogre seems to be indirectly hinting to get looked at.
Ice also mentioned the many day one excuses on why folks would not be posting a lot. Not all of them could be true. Which puts Coler as #3 on my list.
You shouldn't feel uneasy about that at all. With so many single votes cast on people...it was bound to turn into a random pick by the Mod. Day ones are tough enough in themselves without the town laying in confusion and letting the Mod determine the banish.
hhhmmm, do we have a communicating team amongst us? How would they know what to do unless you are communicating?
I vote to banish Ogre There, now it is bolded. (cant figure it out on the BBerry)
While I am at work I will have the ability to check on the game periodically but I fear once I get home I will not be able to change my vote. (I am having major computer issues at home and cannot access the site at all. I can go anywhere/everywhere else but not here?!?! Perhaps one if you comp. gurus can advise me I can fix it?)
Dawg seems to be building quite a case against RB and with Ogre's message to him above makes me really nervous. You may just have something there Dawg.
Opi - in response to your comment about me posting alot, without taking the time to go back and find the quote; yes, I guess I do post alot! I just looked at the post count! :lipssealedsmilie: It has been mentioned in a previous game as well. I guess I just really enjoy playing and having an office job at a PC all day has its advantages -provided I dont get fired for it!
Now in regards to my vote, I was attempting to multiquote Ogre and Rich last night when I got kicked off the site. I will attempt to go back later and accomplish it. There seems to be distancing going on, howver wit hthe above communication between Ogre, Opi and RB I am having doubts about Rich......
I must get to work now. More later...
Jpap, can we get a vote count please?
- Status
