OgreMkV
Father of Earth's Next Emperor
I retract my vote for LadyG and vote to banish RB... Dawg, if you're wrong, you're tops on my list.
Mafia #45: Cabin Fever...The Play
- Thread starter jpappy789
- Start date
- Status
So here's a list of players from my point of view: Unconfirmed are in RED; Unknown Blue
RB - Madman? (Unconfirmed)
Ice - Innocent (Confirmed)
Noods - Mafia Don - Innocent (Confirmed)
DD - Innocent (Confirmed)
Dawg - Innocent? (Unconfirmed)
Virt - Doctor - Innocent (Confirmed)
Ogre - Belhop - Innocent? (Unconfirmed)
Cat - Bartender - Innocent (Confirmed)
Opi - Unknown
Coler - Innocent (Confirmed)
Lucky - Unknown (Suspected innocent due to RB's vote)
Eddie - Unknown
LG - Accomplice? (Unconfirmed)
Rich - Unknown
So that leaves Opi, Eddie and Rich of which one is an accomplice. I think the DET should investigate one of those 3 and if I had to pick one I would say Eddie seems most suspicious of the 3. Anyone have any opinions on Opi, Eddie and Rich? Feel free to give comments on the Unconfirmed people on the list as well but don't expect me to change my opinion.
The good news is there are 8 current players. 5 innocent and 3 evil. The bad news is if we screw up tonight and lynch an innocent we lose. If you're not willing to vote RB I would suggest a vote for LG instead. This may be our last chance as a Town to get this right.
RB - Madman? (Unconfirmed)
Ice - Innocent (Confirmed)
Noods - Mafia Don - Innocent (Confirmed)
DD - Innocent (Confirmed)
Dawg - Innocent? (Unconfirmed)
Virt - Doctor - Innocent (Confirmed)
Ogre - Belhop - Innocent? (Unconfirmed)
Cat - Bartender - Innocent (Confirmed)
Opi - Unknown
Coler - Innocent (Confirmed)
Lucky - Unknown (Suspected innocent due to RB's vote)
Eddie - Unknown
LG - Accomplice? (Unconfirmed)
Rich - Unknown
So that leaves Opi, Eddie and Rich of which one is an accomplice. I think the DET should investigate one of those 3 and if I had to pick one I would say Eddie seems most suspicious of the 3. Anyone have any opinions on Opi, Eddie and Rich? Feel free to give comments on the Unconfirmed people on the list as well but don't expect me to change my opinion.
The good news is there are 8 current players. 5 innocent and 3 evil. The bad news is if we screw up tonight and lynch an innocent we lose. If you're not willing to vote RB I would suggest a vote for LG instead. This may be our last chance as a Town to get this right.
Sorry for not being around much yesterday. I did keep my eye on the board during break from my D&D game, but there didn't seem to be too much going on, so I didn't find it imperative to post.
After the last nightfall, I decided it would be best to toss out all my previous notions, and start again...
To me, it seems there are two teams forming: Ogre and Dawg, and Rb and LG. And the rest of us are being pulled in both directions.
Ogre's explanation of his previous conclusions (finally) because of the list make sense, in a way. It explains why he acted the way he did, and why he switched. I am still a bit pissed about the voting switching, and I don't think he handled the whole thing to the best of his abilities. However, I do believe he is sincere. That is a pretty ridiculous and confusing story to make up, and I don't think the madman would try to pull something like that, which could easily backfire. Furthermore, the posts by jpap mentioning that he may have made some errors, etc...have confirmed my position on Ogre.
That being said, here are my positions on everyone:
Ogre: I think Ogre is innocent, and is being sincere in his posts. I had originally believed him to be sincere, and I never had any suspicions about him until he did the vote swap on me. However, I see his reasoning now; so he is once against innocent. I believe he is the bellhop.
Dawg: I also believe Dawg is innocent. Dawg has never given me any reason for suspicion. I also suspect that Dawg is the detective.
Lucky: I once again believe in Lucky's innocence. I really believe he was just a confused newb. His posts about not knowing who to believe sound like a very sincere innocent to me- since I was feeling exactly the same way right after nightfall before I started rethinking this.
I am unsure of both Rich & Eddie. I think one of them has to be the accomplice. Rich has been both more helpful and less defensive, so I am leaning toward Rich being innocent and Eddie being the accomplice.
Given my belief in Dawg's innocence, and Ogre's list...I would have to suspect Lady G as an accomplice. And I clearly ruled her out too quickly, originally, due to her lack of posting.
Rb: I originally had suspicions about Rb. And they continue to grow. While he posts often, his posts aren't very helpful or full of theories. And he doesn't seem to be trying to solve this at all. Also, given my above beliefs listed above, Rb is the obvious choice.
Therefore, I vote to banish Rb!
After the last nightfall, I decided it would be best to toss out all my previous notions, and start again...
To me, it seems there are two teams forming: Ogre and Dawg, and Rb and LG. And the rest of us are being pulled in both directions.
Ogre's explanation of his previous conclusions (finally) because of the list make sense, in a way. It explains why he acted the way he did, and why he switched. I am still a bit pissed about the voting switching, and I don't think he handled the whole thing to the best of his abilities. However, I do believe he is sincere. That is a pretty ridiculous and confusing story to make up, and I don't think the madman would try to pull something like that, which could easily backfire. Furthermore, the posts by jpap mentioning that he may have made some errors, etc...have confirmed my position on Ogre.
That being said, here are my positions on everyone:
Ogre: I think Ogre is innocent, and is being sincere in his posts. I had originally believed him to be sincere, and I never had any suspicions about him until he did the vote swap on me. However, I see his reasoning now; so he is once against innocent. I believe he is the bellhop.
Dawg: I also believe Dawg is innocent. Dawg has never given me any reason for suspicion. I also suspect that Dawg is the detective.
Lucky: I once again believe in Lucky's innocence. I really believe he was just a confused newb. His posts about not knowing who to believe sound like a very sincere innocent to me- since I was feeling exactly the same way right after nightfall before I started rethinking this.
I am unsure of both Rich & Eddie. I think one of them has to be the accomplice. Rich has been both more helpful and less defensive, so I am leaning toward Rich being innocent and Eddie being the accomplice.
Given my belief in Dawg's innocence, and Ogre's list...I would have to suspect Lady G as an accomplice. And I clearly ruled her out too quickly, originally, due to her lack of posting.
Rb: I originally had suspicions about Rb. And they continue to grow. While he posts often, his posts aren't very helpful or full of theories. And he doesn't seem to be trying to solve this at all. Also, given my above beliefs listed above, Rb is the obvious choice.
Therefore, I vote to banish Rb!
I vote to banish DirtyDawg. For some reason he has been pushing the RB vote really hard. And that is fishy to me.
On a side note. This game is pretty slow compared to others. Alot of errors it seems and a bad nightfall time. Thats just my opinion though.
On a side note. This game is pretty slow compared to others. Alot of errors it seems and a bad nightfall time. Thats just my opinion though.
I am sorry I have been missing. We were at a friends yesterday and due to the weather (and a little too much rum) we spent the night there. I thought there would be quite a bit to read but I guess everyone has been busy.
I have read everything and I am not really convinced by anyone that they are telling the absolute truth here. I have not seen enough from Lady G to form an opinion and I think the Lucky and DD are making the most noise. I have to read this one more time and will come back with what I think.
I have read everything and I am not really convinced by anyone that they are telling the absolute truth here. I have not seen enough from Lady G to form an opinion and I think the Lucky and DD are making the most noise. I have to read this one more time and will come back with what I think.
The more I read this the more I think that dawg is covering for himself by making claims of knowing something the rest of do not. Unless I see something else he is now my primary suspect for madman with opi as one of his accomplices.
OgreMkV
Father of Earth's Next Emperor
Wow I was about to say it was an RB, Eddie, LadyG badguy team. But Rich is acting awfully funny too. I'm sure he's just being influenced by the dark side. Come back rich... it's OK!
Confusing...Eddie votes fr who you think is right, Dawg, and Eddie is the guilty party... foolish, ogre, foolish.
- Status
