Mafia 46: In the Dark

[AC] maelstrom;1813429 said:
But you're not disagreeing that people putting up their suspect lists helps generally are you ?
Click to expand...

Better answer this before people start thinking I'm dodging ;)

Anyway, in general, yes lists are a good thing. However, in this specific game, I don't think they will work so well because of the fluid nature of who's who.

Let's say one player is at the top of your suspect list. That night you get recruited onto the innocents and discover this is your leader. So you have to now defend him and yourself from new accusations. That looks scummy because players in these games rarely think about the innocent side of the equation, they're all looking for signs of mafianess.
 
Well, ya know I am gonna just go ahead and do it...I vote to lynch Gunslinger
In the respect that I am not feeling good about the train on Maelstrom and he has been pushing it really hard. Something is just not sitting right with me in regards to him. If I am wrong about him or mael, I am screwed either way.
I may change my vote later if anything more evident comes up, but for now that's where it is. I have a meeting for the rest of the day - so later.
 
Here are my suspicions
Noodles- To me seems as if she is innocent, more of a gut feeling more than anything else. Because if she was mafia she wouldn't have to make such a hard choice between people. She could just pick whichever seemed the biggest threat.

Ogre- Even though ogre has posted a good amount, I still have mixed feelings on him/her (sorry!).

Mostlycichlids- Nothing scares me more than someone who sits back and does nothing. Posting the bare minimum. Not dong anything to really help, but still not enough info to tilt the fence.

Rich- Nothing really peeks my interest here.

Dawg- Can't really deciphere any hideden meanings behind hist posts, I think he is just an innocent.

DD- Strikes my interest, but not in a bad way, more of less, a helpful way, but unsure

JBradt- Is he even playing? :)

Opi- What one two posts? Come on people, I have school too.

I dont like any of the [AC's] not because of their name but because of their playing style, and I can almost guarenttee I know the identity of one of them. Coler
 
Rich's scale jumped on my suspicion ladder. Getting on a train to protect mael is what I see.
 
luckydud13 said:
Here are my suspicions
Opi- What one two posts? Come on people, I have school too.
Click to expand...


Are you a science grad. student, Lucky? If not, you can't say anything. Grad. school is like nothing else. :p

Besides...there really hasn't been anything all too interesting going on. Though, I am not done with my analysis yet...still working on my list of suspects.
 
Well, braggy mk braggster, nope high school. :)

Interested to see a suspect list from the point of someone who has been quiet for so long.
 
And the train forms on gunslinger.

My top two candidates are now noods and rich. Reason: forming a train on gunslinger.

I wanted to see if anyone would jump if I indicated that I might vote gun and some did. Very interesting.
 
I would still like to hear more about this mafia tell Ogre has on a player and what player he thinks it is.

I could have missed it. I have seen where it could be Coler or ZSandmann.

The mafia tell is much more important than the name of the player.

Also of concern is where MC proclaims DD as being innocent. I will quote it.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom