Mafia #47 "Ghost Hunters"

[noodles62]

So 4 is the magic number for a train, not 3?

I am not asking you to vote for me, but I am asking you to vote. To make a meaningful contribution to game. Who should go?

well, 4 is not necessarily a magic number but it is a significant number of votes when there are only a few left that have not voted - myself included.

I am never "trusting" of DD but am also not ready to vote her out yet. I do not wish to place a useless lone vote out there either.

I am gonna have to go with a sort of random vote right now...I vote to take the soul of Johnlarson66. This is subject to change....Something just is not sitting right with him at this moment, more so than DD...Lucky is definately on my radar, but as I said a lone vote would be stupid and useless......

//game off//Sorry for the delay, my son, whom is going to Afghanistan soon called me from Guam...:hearts: //game on//

 

[johnlarson66]

There would be....2 evil people right now? At least that's what it seems like according to the rules. There are 12 people...so minus yourself...that's 11. I still think that saying with any kind of confidence that someone is "evil" is a little shady. It's just mho. We aren't talking about probabilities here...we are talking about accusations. It's shouldn't be taken lightly.

Misquoting someone is misleading...but I didn't paraphrase or misquote you. Listing the post # merely indicates either a) laziness or b) lack of time.

Considering you were on the bottom of my suspect list, I feel that your defense was a bit unnecessary. Besides, I thought you liked being a "suspect"?

My list still stands: DD, Rich, JL.

I'm not confident on ANY of the above...but day one votes are necessary. I am going to hold off voting til I get a response from DD about the "Rickets" comment. If she convinces me, then I will go with Rich.

Opi has my attention also. Here she states that I was on the bottom of her list, but after pointing out her misleading actions I move up to number 3.

I am curious about what jpap says about when Opi voted and if DD had responded or not. I didn't catch it and want to verify.

 

[noodles62]

And another! I might as well jump on and follow as well...I officially find myself suspicious :headshake2:



Yes, the conversation was light. It was frickin' day one for crying out loud, I was willing to "converse" with anyone who was online.

I can't explain the sudden realization by rickets regarding myself. We are independent players, I will tell you that.

DD I was thinking you were just trying to poke around and dig up some dirt but your really trying to make something out of nothing IMHO. Somehow you think my day one conversations with other players links us as teammates? (please correct me if I am wrong).

However, one thing has stood out to me. Opi listed DD as a top suspect twice after DD commented on Rickets. She then said that she would probably vote her but wait for a response. But as soon as Ice switched to DD, Opi followed. Problem was DD never responded during that time. Classic mafia following.

I vote to take the soul of Opicana

Very excellent point jpap! I have been cautious about Opi myself, but have given her the benefit of the doubt as she is somewhat of a newb, but then I remember that she also plays in other venues!.....I would be willing to change my vote to Opi if it would make a difference......

 

[johnlarson66]

Really? Huh....totally not how I read that. Hmm....in that case, JL's claim was a bit more reasonable. Though, I am still not okay with declaring anyone as evil just yet.

With that said...I still need to make a vote. Not sure how much time I will have between now and nightfall. So, just in case, I will throw my vote out now, but I may still retract it.

Sorry, DD, but I vote to take the soul of DangerDoll.

As you can see from my previous list, she was my number 1 suspect, primarily because of the jump on Rickets. However, I am not absolutely confident in this...I still may switch to Rich later.

Here Opi explains her vote. Has DD responded to Opi's questions?

 

[Opicana]

Opi has my attention also. Here she states that I was on the bottom of her list, but after pointing out her misleading actions I move up to number 3.

I am curious about what jpap says about when Opi voted and if DD had responded or not. I didn't catch it and want to verify.

If you check my previous suspect list, you were on the bottom....DD, Rich, JL....

It hasn't changed. You've been #3 since I posted my list. You haven't moved once...not sure where you are going with that....

 

[johnlarson66]

If you check my previous suspect list, you were on the bottom....DD, Rich, JL....

It hasn't changed. You've been #3 since I posted my list. You haven't moved once...not sure where you are going with that....

Oh, bottom of your list of three not bottom of the list of all of the players.

So has DD answered your questions?

 

[Opicana]

However, one thing has stood out to me. Opi listed DD as a top suspect twice after DD commented on Rickets. She then said that she would probably vote her but wait for a response. But as soon as Ice switched to DD, Opi followed. Problem was DD never responded during that time. Classic mafia following.

I vote to take the soul of Opicana

Well, I waited for awhile (4 hours) but I wasn't sure how much time I would have (I've managed to hop on more than expected, as things are taking awhile in the lab, but as soon as they are done I will be MIA for awhile)...so I voted my top suspect to make sure I didn't get a UD. If you'll notice, that post was a bit long, and it took me a few minutes to write it (I was also reviewing my notes). I actually hadn't seen Ice's post for DD until AFTER I voted. Still, I said that if she provided a reasonable response, I'd switch to Rich. However, her response hasn't changed my mind, so my vote still stands.

I really don't see voting for the person I said I was GOING to vote for several posts prior is a "mafia following"...I accused DD before there was a train, because that's what I thought was right. If anything, the people who voted for her after my accusation were "following".

 

[Opicana]

Oh, bottom of your list of three not bottom of the list of all of the players.

So has DD answered your questions?

Exactly! Yes, she did....but not as I had hoped. I thought perhaps she made a mistake and didn't mean to accuse Rickets...but she seems to stand by her claim. And it was really only that one post he mentioned Jpap....she quotes to others but that is just banter with no real substance, imo.

I think my vote will stand.

 

[noodles62]

from my notes, the only player that has not voted yet is firedancer....(I hate day 1!! - never have enuff to go on...)

 

[Opicana]

Very excellent point jpap! I have been cautious about Opi myself, but have given her the benefit of the doubt as she is somewhat of a newb, but then I remember that she also plays in other venues!.....I would be willing to change my vote to Opi if it would make a difference......

It's only 1 venue...my own tiny group...we've had 4 games...I moderated all of them, and ALL my players are newbs....My experience in playing really hasn't changed much, erv:.