Sorry that 1st quote by Jpap was supposed to be near the bottom. It was supposed to be my way of saying I think Jpap could be kicking bushes and not attacking since we both are coming to the same conclusions.
Mafia #47 "Ghost Hunters"
- Thread starter Lady G
- Start date
Hope this makes sense.......It would be really helpful if the quotes within the quote would post but here goes my attempt at a reply.....
Why would you even post like that. Why not whittle it away so only that 1 quote appears and quote it.
I'll fix it for you as I would like to answer it anyway.
I'll fix it for you as I would like to answer it anyway.
Let's try a copy and paste version so I can at least change to font color! my responses in red....
Originally Posted by IceH2O
Sorry for the long post but once you get a hold of something its hard to let go. I know not all of these players can be evil but it gives me a suspect list and a way to watch from day to day.
I am going to try to keep the players in their own section so this is not chronologically correct.
I hate seeing this, then afterwards he doesn't vote Jpap. He decides Jpap is more likely to be innocent. See below
Is any vote worthless? Did you mean you didn't want to be 1st on someone? Was it you didn't want to be 1st or you didn't want to be alone and have to move?
I am certainly not worried about being the first vote on anyone. By worthless, i meant random or a lone vote on someone. night 1 is tough.
Here she won't vote DD and won't vote Lucky because she thinks she will be alone there so she jumps on the mini train of John hoping that others follow? Doesn't matter which innocent goes home huh? Not saying JL is innocent but having you as a suspect makes him innocent per diem.
Not voting DD cause I do not find her as "questionable" as apparently others do. I am always cautious of her but did not feel that she was an imminent threat on night one.
Distancing? That panda theory crap is well,,,crap!
It has been proven and admitted by Jpap at a later date he was wrong about the timing.
Now Noodles is willing to jump to Opi. Really starting to look like Noodles will jump anywhere that will take out somebody, except DD.
I had already voiced my suspicions of Opi and if my vote would better serve the "town" elsewhere than I would certainly be willing to change -
here she admits to vote for anyone even DD but still doesn't vote DD
see above responses....
never like seeing that stated on Day 1
I agree....
Here Jpap rips Opi for her post then in the same post admits he had the timing wrong in answer to my post.
A second time Fire says Jpap is innocent.
Did Jpap know DD was going to show innocent and therefore hope we think he must also be innocent?
seriously Ogre the best reason? want to explain to us why this overruled any other reasons? Then you go from a lone vote on Rickets to Noods. Could be distancing here also.
Basically saying he thinks DD is innocent
Now saying Noods is innocent.
I'm sure you will be.
Woah another innocent claim? There can't be that many evils.
Yeah I was on DD, I posted on DD so I expect to be looked at. But I don't trust you at all Noods,especially with how you were all over the place willing to hide everywhere and anywhere except onto DD whom you said you would vote for. I think you look more suspicious than anyone that was on DD at the time except maybe Fire but only because you posted more then her.
I never said I would vote for DD; I said I was not comfortable with the train on her and did not agree with voting her, (altho i am always cautious of her- I would be stupid not to be!), I was not hiding, simply trying to make my vote "count" for the good of the town on night one, with no clues to go on. I had my vote where I thought it best, but was willing to hear what others had to say. If I agreed, I would have changed; note that I did not.....trying to take the focus off of yourself much, Ice?
I tried to keep a level post but there was way to much to move around. I hope you guys can follow it.
Of the ones I posted about I'd have to say Noods, Fire, Lucky are the top 3 suspects. Only 2 could have been team mates at the time. I'd lean towards Noods and Lucky as the starting team though.
Jpap drops down but not out. I could see that he could be kicking bushes and not attacking but I don't like some of his posts.
Ogre I'd like to hear more from. I don't like single votes but I can relate to a day 1 single. Just not after stating you don't like day 1 singles then moving to another day 1 single.
Originally Posted by IceH2O
Sorry for the long post but once you get a hold of something its hard to let go. I know not all of these players can be evil but it gives me a suspect list and a way to watch from day to day.
I am going to try to keep the players in their own section so this is not chronologically correct.
I hate seeing this, then afterwards he doesn't vote Jpap. He decides Jpap is more likely to be innocent. See below
Is any vote worthless? Did you mean you didn't want to be 1st on someone? Was it you didn't want to be 1st or you didn't want to be alone and have to move?
I am certainly not worried about being the first vote on anyone. By worthless, i meant random or a lone vote on someone. night 1 is tough.
Here she won't vote DD and won't vote Lucky because she thinks she will be alone there so she jumps on the mini train of John hoping that others follow? Doesn't matter which innocent goes home huh? Not saying JL is innocent but having you as a suspect makes him innocent per diem.
Not voting DD cause I do not find her as "questionable" as apparently others do. I am always cautious of her but did not feel that she was an imminent threat on night one.
Distancing? That panda theory crap is well,,,crap!
It has been proven and admitted by Jpap at a later date he was wrong about the timing.
Now Noodles is willing to jump to Opi. Really starting to look like Noodles will jump anywhere that will take out somebody, except DD.
I had already voiced my suspicions of Opi and if my vote would better serve the "town" elsewhere than I would certainly be willing to change -
here she admits to vote for anyone even DD but still doesn't vote DD
see above responses....
never like seeing that stated on Day 1
I agree....
Here Jpap rips Opi for her post then in the same post admits he had the timing wrong in answer to my post.
A second time Fire says Jpap is innocent.
Did Jpap know DD was going to show innocent and therefore hope we think he must also be innocent?
seriously Ogre the best reason? want to explain to us why this overruled any other reasons? Then you go from a lone vote on Rickets to Noods. Could be distancing here also.
Basically saying he thinks DD is innocent
Now saying Noods is innocent.
I'm sure you will be.
Woah another innocent claim? There can't be that many evils.
Yeah I was on DD, I posted on DD so I expect to be looked at. But I don't trust you at all Noods,especially with how you were all over the place willing to hide everywhere and anywhere except onto DD whom you said you would vote for. I think you look more suspicious than anyone that was on DD at the time except maybe Fire but only because you posted more then her.
I never said I would vote for DD; I said I was not comfortable with the train on her and did not agree with voting her, (altho i am always cautious of her- I would be stupid not to be!), I was not hiding, simply trying to make my vote "count" for the good of the town on night one, with no clues to go on. I had my vote where I thought it best, but was willing to hear what others had to say. If I agreed, I would have changed; note that I did not.....trying to take the focus off of yourself much, Ice?
I tried to keep a level post but there was way to much to move around. I hope you guys can follow it.
Of the ones I posted about I'd have to say Noods, Fire, Lucky are the top 3 suspects. Only 2 could have been team mates at the time. I'd lean towards Noods and Lucky as the starting team though.
Jpap drops down but not out. I could see that he could be kicking bushes and not attacking but I don't like some of his posts.
Ogre I'd like to hear more from. I don't like single votes but I can relate to a day 1 single. Just not after stating you don't like day 1 singles then moving to another day 1 single.
Good try, I even said in my post "A CASE FOR LUCKY" so why wouldn't it be? I only mentioned Opi because she was involved in the convo, NOT because I am defending my teammate. Would have been pretty bold to vote for my teammate day one, eh? Unless you are insinuating that we weren't on the same side last night. But even then, why would one of us recruit the other? Methinks you are a little riled up because heads are turning your direction...
Yes, I admitted that my thoughts on Opi yesterday may have been off because of timing. I also said I wasn't fond of the vote myself, but I didn't see a need to switch. So my vote stayed.
I am wary of voting DD day one because of the reason that we have argued and ended up innocent in a number of games. I had no idea if she was innocent or not, but I didn't see enough for a vote.
After rereading the back and forth between him and Opi I full on posted a case for Lucky and then voted. How is that not attacking?
I've been called overly aggressive in past games but now I'm too defensive and not attacking....
Noodles said
I never said I would vote for DD; I said I was not comfortable with the train on her and did not agree with voting her, (altho i am always cautious of her- I would be stupid not to be!), I was not hiding, simply trying to make my vote "count" for the good of the town on night one, with no clues to go on. I had my vote where I thought it best, but was willing to hear what others had to say. If I agreed, I would have changed; note that I did not.....trying to take the focus off of yourself much, Ice?
Funny that sure does look like you are saying you'd vote DD to me.
Also what focus is on me? Who has said anything about me? I believe I'm the only one to actually point out that I was on DD and expect to be looked at.
I never said I would vote for DD; I said I was not comfortable with the train on her and did not agree with voting her, (altho i am always cautious of her- I would be stupid not to be!), I was not hiding, simply trying to make my vote "count" for the good of the town on night one, with no clues to go on. I had my vote where I thought it best, but was willing to hear what others had to say. If I agreed, I would have changed; note that I did not.....trying to take the focus off of yourself much, Ice?
Funny that sure does look like you are saying you'd vote DD to me.
Also what focus is on me? Who has said anything about me? I believe I'm the only one to actually point out that I was on DD and expect to be looked at.
Ice are you seriously this shallow? Noodles has her son leaving for Iraq, and an officer calling her house to confirm an adress in case something takes a turn for the worst. Any sane, understanding, person would see that the outbreak she had was due to this.
I feel like taking questions, does anyone have any specific questions for me as to how and why I said what I said?
