Mafia #48 - Blarney Castle

[IceH2O]

I almost forgot about Rich...

He said the reason for my vote was as good as any better not that it was good.

Turned out to be the best reason.

Why of my "bad reason" did you choose me to vote for? Because it was weak? Can you tell me who had stronger reasoning and why you didn't vote them?

should read but not better

 

[jpappy789]

My thought is that Wyom being a rookie doesn't know to NOT protect a team mate. When they saw something that stood out and was called on they reacted as most would and tried to squash it.

I'm keeping an open mind to others but I think Nar will end up getting my vote come night fall.

I agree with JL on the fact that something about you isn't sitting right.

Good point about WY. I guess I can see it, although I'm not sure about a vote yet. Unfortunately the game has been kind of low so far and there are quite a few people that have barely posted. I may be forced to vote Nar as there is nothing else to go on right now...

And I'm totally fine about you and JL being uncomfortable with me. The way things panned out last night really discredits me and I realize that. To tell the truth I'm uneasy about you and JL because of how you guys have played in the past. I will not be putting anything past you...

My thinking thus far:

I am focusing on the "no hit" aspect first, since I think that could give away a lot.

Here is what I found to be the last post times of all members still in the game...I did my best to get them right, but if I made a mistake, please let me know.

JPappy –8:42
Rich- 7:31
IceH2o- 8:58
Johnlarson- 9
Luckydud13- 8:02
Judgemax- 7:47
Sploke- 4:38
Dangerdoll- 7:40
cjtabares- 8:14
[ac] Narwhal- 8:11

I find it doubtful that JPap, Ice, or JL is the King given their posting times, and the fact they are all pros who wouldn't let something like that happen.

While I think it is totally possible for an evil to cast a vote on another evil, I think this is more commonly done when the votes are not so close. So, for now, I am going to cast those people who voted for Wyom as "non-suspects"...NOT innocent...just not at the top of my radar. So...Sploke, JM, Cj, Ice.

This leaves me with:
Rich- 7:31
Luckydud13- 8:02
Dangerdoll- 7:40
[ac] Narwhal- 8:11

The only other valuable evidence that I may consider is who voted for MC, and innocent....there is only 1 match, DD.

As of now, my top suspects are:
DD
Rich, Lucky, Nar

I'm doubting DD would be one to misplace the hit. She's one of the most seasoned veterans playing and would probably not forget like that. Rich, Nar and Lucky, on the other hand, I could see although I can't say for sure about Nar because I don't know their level of experience.

 

[johnlarson66]

LOL, your spelling goes down hill when your buzzed, MC.

A leprechaun avatar AND an alias? Seems too obvious, sticks out like a sore thumb. Might as well slap a sticker with "I'm a leprechaun, lynch me" on your forehead.

WYite

Isn't the best hiding place right out in the open?

Could change before night fall but I want to make sure I have a vote in and hope it generates some discussion anyway.

I vote to lynch Narwhal

probably wouldn't have given it a 2nd thought if Wyom hadn't brought that aspect of it sticking out like a sore thumb. Which means if Nar is evil Wyom is also.

its simple.

i picked a funny saint pat's day pic for an avatar. mostlycichlids said it was funny and joked about leprechauns being evil post 40-41

WYite said it was too obvious post 42

ice said if im evil then wyite is too. post 44

here's how it all started.
when i read the game theme i got a few pics for avatars, to switch every day or so.

mostly for my wife who like a few others is Irish but shes also Scottish. i tease her that she must hate herself

i guess i ahve to stick with donald/lep now, since it became a issue.

Thought it was a pretty easy thought to follow.

Classic rookie mistake of protection without consultation.

My thought is Nar is Coler.
Coler is irish, who better to be the Leprechaun? Its so obvious no one would think it so why not go totally obvious and put up the avatar saying the same? As DD said its so Mafia 1 or 2 no one would pay attention to it. More reason IMO to pay attention to it.

I could vote Wyom and if he is evil then vote Nar but I'd rather get the king and let the rookie make more mistakes.

Okay, I lets assume Ice is on to something. I do see the how the statements about nar made by wyom can be made out to be defensive. I can also see how nar also did a bit of that himself and also explained himself. I think he later "came out of the closet" and made his alias useless. I think this is also an indication that he is evil and is panicing.

I vote to lynch [AC] narwhal

 

[jpappy789]

In my last post I said I don't know Nar's experience, well I forgot it was Pix. My mistake.

I guess I would clump him in with the others as people who would possibly forget to send in a hit. DD still doesn't fit IMHO.

Well I think I may as well out myself, I haven't played for a while and it was the norm to use different avatars back then.

I'm not Coler, Hooked, Lady... I'm kary, pixl8r, or Mr Gimpy.

 

[Opicana]

I'm doubting DD would be one to misplace the hit. She's one of the most seasoned veterans playing and would probably not forget like that. Rich, Nar and Lucky, on the other hand, I could see although I can't say for sure about Nar because I don't know their level of experience.

Mmm...I kind of agree with you...I can't really see anyone forgetting the hit, and definitely not DD. I think it is more likely they were waiting to communicate with their team or something, then though they would be back in time and accidentally missed it or something.

But you do make a good point...hmmm

 

[jpappy789]

Mmm...I kind of agree with you...I can't really see anyone forgetting the hit, and definitely not DD. I think it is more likely they were waiting to communicate with their team or something, then though they would be back in time and accidentally missed it or something.

But you do make a good point...hmmm

It's been done in the past so I wouldn't discount it, but out of all of them DD is least likely in my mid to be the leader.

People get caught up and just forget their role. I've done it before. (and no I didn't do it again:silly

 

[Opicana]

Okay, I lets assume Ice is on to something. I do see the how the statements about nar made by wyom can be made out to be defensive. I can also see how nar also did a bit of that himself and also explained himself. I think he later "came out of the closet" and made his alias useless. I think this is also an indication that he is evil and is panicing.

I vote to lynch [AC] narwhal

Humm....I'm kind of liking this theory...and Nar *is* on my suspect list.

 

[Opicana]

(and no I didn't do it again:silly

:lol:

Yeah, okay...my top suspects are now in this order:

Nar
Rich, Lucky
DD

 

[IceH2O]

The thing that gets me a little jumpy about the whole thing, Ice is that it is completely not you to jump on something like an avatar issue.... which it seems to melike you had. Whether it be because someone pointed it out or protected it, still... it doesnt seem to me that it is something you would go for especially on day 1. Yeah, you haven't said you know for sure or anything like that but the fact is you are a vet here and a pretty good one, I would even venture to say one of the best so pretty much a lot of what you say or post is going to be taken to thought.

DD are you the lone evil and is this a hint to the team to hit me?

 

[Dangerdoll]

pk... sorry I have been gone for the day, am struggling with a migrane here that I thought some sleep would help... no chance though....

anyway, not really sure I can follow Opicana's reasoning for adding me to her suspect list but that could be the headache, sorry.

I can guarantee you that if I were evil, I would have sent a hit, I wouldn't have let that pass and if I was evil and not the king, I wouldn't have let whoever was King miss it. Fact is, I was leaving before night call last night and if evil, would have PMed Dawg since I knew I was going to be out and might not make it back by call.

and Ice no, sorry. If I were on the evil team, why would I have to hint on the board to hit you?? Don't you think I would at least put that in a PM or IM? And when I made that post, it was before night call.... before Wy was lynched.... wasn't there 2 leps and a King before nightcall? Where do you figure there would only be one? (I am referring to your questioning if I was the "lone"