Mafia #48 - Blarney Castle

[Opicana]

Based on their votes for Wyite: Sploke, JM, CJ, and Ice are removed from the top of my list

Based on their vote for Nar (this round): JL

Nar’s vote for Sploke and Ice’s new vote for Nar, also back them up.

Whose Left?
JPappy
Rich
Luckydud13
Dangerdoll

And that’s my top suspect pool. Other than that, I think the most convincing evidence is for JPap…because both he & Wyom voted for MC, a proven innocent. Jpap’s vote was earlier, so Wyom could have been following his lead. Rookie mistake that goes well with possible “protection” of Nar…

[FONT=&quot]An alternative, more far-fetched theory, is that the whole thing is planned/staged…Ice seems to be right almost *too* much. Perhaps, it’s all an elaborate hoax, so we can trust him to til the end, and he’ll be the last evil standing. Who needs a whole team if all the innocents trust one evil so much? Just an idea…I think the former scenario is much more likely. So, right now, my vote is leaning toward Jpap.

Sploke- I love the number system style top suspects post.
[/FONT]

 

[Sploke]

Sploke- I love the number system style top suspects post.
[/FONT]

good to hear, although i can't take credit for it. thats been around since i started playing mafia i think, which was around game 7.

 

[Opicana]

good to hear, although i can't take credit for it. thats been around since i started playing mafia i think, which was around game 7.

Sadly, it hasn't been in any of the games I have played yet. But this is only...my 3rd? maybe 4th?

I may use it in the future.

 

[cjtabares]

Well if the evil want to have the rest of use trust one evil i think it would more likely be the king leprechaun. So i don't think they would give up Nar to make Ice look evil so for now I am leaning Ice innocent.

I also feel just because a known evil voted for someone it dose not make them innocent, there is a lone leprechaun who no one know who he/she is except that person.

Well I voted for Wyite last night because i thought i saw something weird with him and DD they seemed to kind of be on the same page I called them out yesterday but never got an response so for now

I Vote to lynch DD

 

[jpappy789]

What is interesting is that jpap, who was all in the middle of the "Who is Narwhal" discussions, forgets that pix8r comes out as Narwhal. I think this is pretty important.

Yes, and I caught my own mistake JL. I fail to see the importance of this.

Well you can all stop the speculation. As much as I love reading it I have to announce that Pix (Narwhal) has to drop out of the game due to medical reasons. Narwhal was the King Leprechaun. Since this was an unforeseen emergency that caused this I am allowing the lep(s) to keep their investigations. Please keep Pix in your thoughts and prayers.

go/// Feel better pix! ///go

I retract my vote for Nar and vote lynch jpappy789

I can see the case for DD also. I just don't see DD letting the hit not go in. I can see jpap letting it slip by.

I will say this, if Ice is an evil leprechaun, then he and what is left of the evil team deserve to win. Ice had them both pegged day one. From my count there should only be two left.

\\\ game off

pix8r, sorry you are having health problems, get well soon.

/// game on

How am I any different from DD? As I already said I have forgotten to send in a hit in the past but that was the first game I was the evil boss and I distinctively remember leaving much earlier in the day. I was one of the last posters before nightfall and yet you suspect me to be one of the people to forget sending in the hit.

Same here, I think DD is the lone evil. Or its possible she couldn't get in touch with Pix? But Jpap would also be a good vote IMO. He was pretty jumpy about me voting Nar and pointing out Wyom was evil too.
I could easily switch if needed.

I was jumpy because you logic sucked IMO given the posts at the time. Sorry to be blunt but it wasn't jumpiness at all, more like I didn't agree with what you were saying.

Based on their votes for Wyite: Sploke, JM, CJ, and Ice are removed from the top of my list

Based on their vote for Nar (this round): JL

Nar’s vote for Sploke and Ice’s new vote for Nar, also back them up.

Whose Left?
JPappy
Rich
Luckydud13
Dangerdoll

And that’s my top suspect pool. Other than that, I think the most convincing evidence is for JPap…because both he & Wyom voted for MC, a proven innocent. Jpap’s vote was earlier, so Wyom could have been following his lead. Rookie mistake that goes well with possible “protection” of Nar…

[FONT=&quot]An alternative, more far-fetched theory, is that the whole thing is planned/staged…Ice seems to be right almost *too* much. Perhaps, it’s all an elaborate hoax, so we can trust him to til the end, and he’ll be the last evil standing. Who needs a whole team if all the innocents trust one evil so much? Just an idea…I think the former scenario is much more likely. So, right now, my vote is leaning toward Jpap.

Sploke- I love the number system style top suspects post.
[/FONT]

Where did I protect Nar? I merely was pointing out flaws in Ice's reasoning again based on what I saw the first night. My vote on MC was because he changed his stance when I questioned him and I took that to be a scummy move. It was the first night for goodness sakes.

DD and Jm are tops for me. I think Jm is the non communicating lep and DD is the last communicating one. Lucky and CJ make me nervous based on lack of input, a big sign for a non cummicating role IMHO.

I'm concerned with how much Ice is right. I think everyone should at least consider the possibility of a set up. Writing him off as innocent could be just what he wants...I'm not leaning that way right now, but it's a possibility.

I'm also toying with maybe JL being a last lep. He was quick to turn to Ice's side after WY was lynched even though he was for lack of a better word against him the first day. Possibly he knew Pix would have to drop due to past circumstances out so the vote was only to make him look good. Again, not something I see as the best scenario, but something I will keep in mind.

I'm gunna wait for my vote.

 

[jpappy789]

DD and Jm are tops for me. I think Jm is the non communicating lep and DD is the last communicating one. Lucky and CJ make me nervous based on lack of input, a big sign for a non cummicating role IMHO.

EDIT: Also add sploke to the list of low lying players. The fact that his list shows a number of people at 4 and 5 but no explanation as to why he is choosing one person over the other is another sign that he is trying to blend in and not make any "waves" because of what he said.

 

[Sploke]

I agree that there's a possibility of a setup, but its so thin that its not enough to change my thinking right now. Like I said before...for the evils to give up 50% of their team AND miss a hit the first night...that is playing some pretty narrow odds.

 

[jpappy789]

What is interesting is that jpap, who was all in the middle of the "Who is Narwhal" discussions, forgets that pix8r comes out as Narwhal. I think this is pretty important.

I forgot to address another aspect of this statement. How would a teammate of Pix forget he was Narwhal? I find it very unlikely that another lep would forget the real name of their boss after they already came out...or are you suggesting that I am the lone one?

 

[dirtydawg10]

Vote Count:

DD-(2)-Ice(132), CJ(144)
JPap-(2)-JL(138), Sploke(140)

No votes from: JPap, Rich, Lucky, JM, Opi, DD

Just under 2-1/2hrs til nightfall.

PM's Required!

 

[jpappy789]

I probably won't be around for nightfall so I might as well put this in now...

I vote to lynch Dangerdoll