MAFIA #5 The Play.....

I did a read of the posts I'll pull some quotes and my thoughts in a few minutes, it'll take time lol.

I know the quiet ones aren't a main concern right now,but if they are shadow mafia then they are more dangerous then the loud boisterous ones. The loud ones will always be on the radar to take out, the quiet ones slip through and then you have to find them at the end of the game. Remember HN, he played it real well. If it wasn't for JM would they have gotten him?

Sploke, as I stated in the post above I was over analyzing. I was still on the Triad conspiracy. Somehow i had it in my head that Coler cleared himself, JM became the sacrificial lamb so that you and Zman could jump on the train and buddy up post wise with Coler. This would in turn make you guys innocents.

Like I said I'm going back to basics. Game 3 I pulled CL (wasn't hard ) and mee-mee out as mafia and was correct. Game 4 I got whacked to early to make a difference and I didn't really look back to see if my list actually had any mafia on it.
 
for what it is worth, HN's suspects as listed were JM, JL, ZS and Ice

Again the question...he was hit because he was right, or he was hit because he was wrong
 
He did also name mee-mee pretty early...didn't make his final list though...he also said that if JM turned out mafia, he would have thought ice and ZS were also mafia.

hmmm...right or wrong...he was hit why ?
 
He did also name mee-mee pretty early...didn't make his final list though...he also said that if JM turned out mafia, he would have thought ice and ZS were also mafia.

hmmm...right or wrong...he was hit why ?

I'm on the list but if you want my opinion it was because it was off. There may be one Mafia on it, but the majority is wrong IMO. I also think I am being made to look guilty by a few Mafia.
 
Here are some thoughts:

We need to remeber the Unexpected Post.

The "appears to be four Mafia" could mean that the Don is extra OR it could mean the vigilante is with the Mafia this game.

Malbri was the only player not to vote yesterday.

No one ever commented on this post of mine. I was curious if anyone else agrees this is a possibilty. I always assumed that the Vig was Innocent but by reading the wording for this round at least, it appears the Vig is either Neutral or Mafia themselves.
 
Here are some thoughts:

We need to remeber the Unexpected Post.

The "appears to be four Mafia" could mean that the Don is extra OR it could mean the vigilante is with the Mafia this game.

Malbri was the only player not to vote yesterday.
sorry about that. I set my alarm clock for 5, but I put 5pm(doh!) so i could vote. Either tonight or tomarrow during the day i will definetly be voting
 
No one ever commented on this post of mine. I was curious if anyone else agrees this is a possibilty. I always assumed that the Vig was Innocent but by reading the wording for this round at least, it appears the Vig is either Neutral or Mafia themselves.

I understood the vigilante to be either one of an innocent or a mafia, and will act accordingly.
 
My list of Mafia candidates...I feel about as strongly about DD as I do about Ice...bkw is slightly stronger as a candidate that he was yesterday but still weakish overall. Ogre is beginning to have a case to answer (no offence buddy there could be a very good explanation) :

Judgemax (RIP)
Dangerdoll
Ice
bkw
Ogre (weak)
Joander (weak)

This was my post shortly after the last 'night' round...I'm not saying its 'the' list, just candidates. Just bringing back around to the front of the thread, still thinking on it.
 
AquariaCentral.com