MAFIA #5 The Play.....

Good attempt at claiming Detective too. But you shouldn't have outed KOTD that is kinda indefensible. Glad I did reveal then though, cause KOTD would of been Hit that Night. So I thought I was saving myself but I was saving KOTD. I'm ok with that.
 
Good Game Everyone.. Next game.. Not gonna stat everyone to death cause that caused mine.. LOL

But it has been fun reading a second game..

I also agree I think the game has gone to one sided and that the mafia need something like a traitor or snitch.. Or how about a tatoo artist that can infect one person.. That would be a twist.. :)
 
LOL am I really that obvious? I thought blaming the suspicions on me to the bolded red on the bottom of the page was a good way to divert.....

Your whole problem was that first post.. You jumped the gun really quick for me.. Everyone else whas kind of chit chatting and you went head first into an attack mode.. Not overly heavy but it was different than the light stuff that was going on.. Then after that to me it became obvious because you were on quite a bit, but not posting in the game, not voting etc. Those were your tells for me.
 
heh my list turned out alright huh?
JM-mafia
DD-mafia
Bkw-Mayor
KOTD-vigilante

i told you all i was innocenttt and you still didnt believe me... but oh well, we still won.

Btw, well played ice... i would have honestly never guessed.
 
Your whole problem was that first post.. You jumped the gun really quick for me.. Everyone else whas kind of chit chatting and you went head first into an attack mode.. Not overly heavy but it was different than the light stuff that was going on.. Then after that to me it became obvious because you were on quite a bit, but not posting in the game, not voting etc. Those were your tells for me.
hehehe, I am usually signed on during the day regardless of the game... ;) but thanks for the info...
 
heh my list turned out alright huh?
JM-mafia
DD-mafia
Bkw-Mayor
KOTD-vigilante

i told you all i was innocenttt and you still didnt believe me... but oh well, we still won.

Btw, well played ice... i would have honestly never guessed.

i guess it was the red sox avatar that did it for me....LOL
 
ROFL KOTD.. You just won't let that drop will ya...
 
I almost had you guys there.

It's hell being a 'known' player. Either the mafia kills you early or the detective investigates you first.

Good game guys...

rb... the mayor/detective combo is too powerful. The mafia should be winning about half the time. I don't think the mafia has won one (or was it one?)

Anyway, if you include the mayor again, the mafia needs some help. Like another member or two, a traitor, or a Don who is investigated as innocent.

I agree - the mafia won game one and not since. It's hellishly tough with e.g 4 members in 18 townies; you don't have the muscle to go a'lynching...I think now that people have gotten quite good at the game, either more mafia, or an 'innocent' don, or no mayor would be a good move.

Also agree its tough being a known player...you pretty much presume that if innocent you'll be hit early and if mafia you'll be lynched pretty darn quick lol
 
AquariaCentral.com