Mafia 50/50 The play..back to Basics..almost

Kashta said:
I disagree here, which is something I've had to resolve in my mind early on in this game. While I haven't participated in these mafia games before now, I do know RBishop well enough to believe he would love nothing better than to mess with us in some way with that last added player and then chuckle to himself the whole time because it leads us in the wrong direction.
Click to expand...

My thoughts are that he would use a andom generator to determine which side to put him on and then chuckle at the results.....JMO
 
Unless something else develops later I feel is strong enough to make a change...

I vote to lynch The Red Severum
 
noodles62 said:
My thoughts are that he would use a andom generator to determine which side to put him on and then chuckle at the results.....JMO
Click to expand...

oops! should say "random" generator...
 
kash, would you agree that TRS is not a communicating mafia. They could be mafia, but I don't think that rb would add a whole other communicating member to the team.

Instead of trying to get something going on TRS with only a few hours left, can you place a vote on someone that already has votes? A lone vote at this stage is not good for the town.
 
Kashta said:
Unless something else develops later I feel is strong enough to make a change...

I vote to lynch The Red Severum
Click to expand...

Kash, if TRS is mafia, then it is 3 innocents (2 talking - 1 not) vs 6 mafia (3 talking - 3 not).

I am hoping that TRS is innocent and it is 4 (2 talking - 2 not) vs 5 mafia (3 talking - 2 not).

A good nightfall can make it 4 vs 3.
 
rich311k said:
I vote to lynch JL.

He is starting with complex plans to get people killed. I don't like it.
Click to expand...
Complex plans to get people killed? Sounds like he is trying to save the town to me....what are you afraid of Rich?
 
johnlarson66 said:
kash, would you agree that TRS is not a communicating mafia. They could be mafia, but I don't think that rb would add a whole other communicating member to the team..
Click to expand...

Yes, agree. No reason to put a 4th communicator on either side.
 
[AC] wing nut;1983196 said:
I vote to lynch Noodles

Noodles, do you realize that you NEVER ended up voting for the person you REALLY wanted to vote for? Not only is that odd, it looks like posturing to me.

Here you decide to retract your vote for Blue and vote for Dawg (known innocent), because his game is 'off' on Day 1.


Another post where on Day 1, Dawg is 'way off' his game...so you feel good about your vote on him.


Now when asked to explain what 'off' means, you dunno...maybe it's just you being paranoid, and Dawg isn't 'off'. Doesn't seem like a very good reason to lynch someone on Day 1, does it?


Now here you're having a hard time reading Dawg... so you'd charge in and vote for him on Day 1?


Another defense of your vote on Dawg. You don't trust him and his game seems 'off'. But we still dunno what 'off' means.


Now here, you're okay with your vote, but might be willing to hop off if you saw some options that might make a difference. If you felt happy about your vote, why would you be looking for other options that would make a difference?


Now right before Dawg goes down, you want off. Oh, the anguish you must feel. If only you could bring yourself to vote for a newbie you'd do so and save Dawg. WRONG! I pointed out earlier that doing so would kill you...so all the anguish about not having the heart to vote a newb is a bit of a smokescreen here, isn't it?


So after all of this, apparently you weren't voting for the person you really wanted to on Day 1.


On Day 2, you vote for Luvbugz. Fine. Once cj's fate is sealed, though, you point out that, 'Yeah, you woulda gone there, but there's no real reason to do so now...' Right. Gotcha.


Here again, you'd move, but see no real reason to do so. You'll just sit this one out on Bugz, who isn't really one of your top suspects. Okay. Gotcha.


As Day 2 comes to a close, noodles is once again sitting where she doesn't really want to be. What's that about?


As far as the remaining mafia, it's likely 5 v 4 in favor of the mafia, so there are more bad guys than good at this point. As some of the folks playing haven't seemed to scumhunt much AND haven't given others much of a look into their heads, it's probably easier to pick those I have leaning innocent at this point.

I think that TRS is likely innocent. They joined late, after original roles went out. As the original roles would have been 6 v 6, I think that adding an additional mafia to the mix would have really stacked the odds against the town. I don't think that rb would have done this.

At this point, I am also leaning JL innocent. While I disagree with his earlier statement that the case on cj was weak, he does seem to be turning over a lot of rocks.

That would pretty much leave everyone else as suspects, with most of them being guaranteed mafia.
Click to expand...

Since it leaves pretty much everyone else as suspects, can you humor me and change your vote?
 
rich311k said:
I vote to lynch JL.

He is starting with complex plans to get people killed. I don't like it.
Click to expand...

What complex plan is that?

To let the communicating innocents decide noods fate? What is so complex about that?

While I am glad you aren't voting for noods, I wish you would vote for someone besides me.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom