Mafia 50/50 The play..back to Basics..almost

[The Red Severum]

^hmmmm

 

[rich311k]

So are you saying that you and Johnlarson are the remaining 2 communicating innocents?

No i am saying that the only way a mafia could communicate with an innocent is if the innocent was turned and that bala would have announced that this had happened.

 

[The Zigman]

so when do you think a mafia and innocent communicated, I think I missed that part.

 

[rich311k]

That is interesting Wing, really puts this all in doubt. What have you got to say John?

 

[rich311k]

so when do you think a mafia and innocent communicated, I think I missed that part.

Noodles obviously spoke with John. She said so. We are debating whetheror not JL is what he says he is.

 

[The Zigman]

right, I got it now, Why would he vote to lynch another confirmed innocent if he was one, like he claims...

Well John?

 

[Kashta]

Is there a spot in the rules of this game which would allow a mafia to speak with an innocent? I know there is a turn but doesn't it have to be announced by the big fish? I do not remember that happening.

Now all that stuff in the beginning makes better sense. There was a switch in place already... Bala doesn't have to issue one. RBishop did it already when he brought TRS into the game.

I didn't pay much attention to the odd player factor in a 50/50 game in the first pages because I couldn't figure it out. But do the math now...

If TRS is innocent, then johnlarson is lying.

Bala notes, for those that can't read..lmao...13......50/50.....

thats 6.5 on each side simple math..

So TRS is on both sides.

ooo a double agent?

rb is all about twists, so it is really hard to say what he did with TRS joining late.

 

[The Zigman]

or did they communicate outside of the rules???

 

[The Red Severum]

Now all that stuff in the beginning makes better sense. There was a switch in place already... Bala doesn't have to issue one. RBishop did it already when he brought TRS into the game.

I didn't pay much attention to the odd player factor in a 50/50 game in the first pages because I couldn't figure it out. But do the math now...

If TRS is innocent, then johnlarson is lying.

I don't understand, care explain more?

 

[The Zigman]

Well if he is a double agent, he was not a communicating innocent.. so where does that put us? What good would it do to have a double agent if they cant communicate with both sides?

I am also going to guess since he joined late in the game that he couldnt communicate with the mafia because all of the roles would have already been assigned.

Unless he was on one side till midpoint through the gams, and has now shifted sides..

IDK, I know my role in the game, and am really doubting john again..