Mafia #51 - Mafia Citizens - The Play

[Dangerdoll]

UGH!! this sucks....

I am not liking that, plant.... out of all the votes on Zig, I think hers actually makes the best sense.... everyone else, I don't see any solid foundation. Does this make me think Kash is on a innocent side, no on your life... out of all last nights votes, I think I am most interested on the reasons from Coler and RB....

 

[dirtydawg10]

UGH!! this sucks....

I am not liking that, plant.... out of all the votes on Zig, I think hers actually makes the best sense.... everyone else, I don't see any solid foundation. Does this make me think Kash is on a innocent side, no on your life... out of all last nights votes, I think I am most interested on the reasons from Coler and RB....

I agree on the part in bold above. The votes for Zig came out of nowhere close to nightfall.

 

[dirtydawg10]

So what are you all doing? I see people in the thread but no one is posting. Are you waiting for direction from your team members?

 

[ZSandmann]

Welcome to the game mostlycichlids.

I really don't like her last ditch effort to save herself w/a vote for Zigman and no other reason.

I vote to lynch Kashta

Man I missed all the craziness at Nightfall...

Plant I don't like what you did there, Kash saved themself, I think we all would do that regardless of role.

I'm not voting anyone right out the gate but I would like to see what people think of the Coler and Rb shuffle, losing a Citizen, losing Ice (whatever he is, the Mist did something), and what's up with Mostly joining us on Day 2?

 

[Luvbugz]

Rough night

Plantling sure has some sorta vendetta against Kash. What are the reasons for trying to wait til last moment to change your vote? Why not just outright vote for Kash last night? Why the last moment jockeying?


What did RB mean by this?!?

I retract my vote on Dawg...and vote to lynch Zig.....just to help Coler...

 

[dirtydawg10]

Going back and reviewing I do see Plant's actions as a bit disturbing. Here she votes for Zig her 2nd suspect because she thinks it is a foregone conclusion that Kashta will be voted out.

Not sure if mucs would be 3rd or even 4th vote on each other day 1. I'd think they'd want to try to save them by campaigning against another player first. If it turns out Kashta is a mucs then we should look at who has been trying to turn heads another way.

Speaking of which...

Hmm in this post Zig says it is Mad's train and he is trying to get us to board it.


Now in this post when questioned about his vote Zig says Mad is simply jumping on the train and trying to get others to follow. I'm still not sure how Mad's vote is all that different from the previous votes on Kash.


To me it seems Kash cannot make up her mind about Red's vote on her. Kash's first reaction was a little harsh then she chalks it up to Ice as just a funny thing between herself and Red continued from the last game then in this last post it was a stupid random vote on her. She goes on to describe Red's voting habits from the previous game. Sounds kinda bitter to me. And it appears Kash has gone silent perhaps being instructed by her teammates to lay low.

If my vote is needed I will put it on Kash. But it appears not atm. I'm placing my vote on my 2nd highest suspect, reasons given above.

I vote to lynch Zigman

Then Coler and RB place their votes on Zig.

I get the logic for kash...50/50 she is either wiseguy/power role or mucsy but I hate the people voting her lol.

I like action at nightfall too. If there is no movement for rbishop today I won't be leaving my vote on a nobody. I retract my vote to lynch Rbishop and vote to lynch Zigman. I'd be happy to vote bob if anyone wants to join me btw.

I retract my vote on Dawg...and vote to lynch Zig.....just to help Coler...

Then 20min after RB's vote which ties the vote on Zig and Kashta (and after Kashta's vote to put Zig over the top she tries to switch her vote. Why? She wants both to be voted out but then tries to switch at the last minute. Not sure what to think but Plants explanation is in order IMO. As is one from RB and Coler still.

Well that's it for tonight. I'll check things out tomorrow.

I retract my vote for zigman. I vote to lynch kash

 

[dirtydawg10]

I messed up the parenthesis and the quote location. In case it matters it should look like this...

Going back and reviewing I do see Plant's actions as a bit disturbing. Here she votes for Zig her 2nd suspect because she thinks it is a foregone conclusion that Kashta will be voted out.

Not sure if mucs would be 3rd or even 4th vote on each other day 1. I'd think they'd want to try to save them by campaigning against another player first. If it turns out Kashta is a mucs then we should look at who has been trying to turn heads another way.

Speaking of which...

Hmm in this post Zig says it is Mad's train and he is trying to get us to board it.


Now in this post when questioned about his vote Zig says Mad is simply jumping on the train and trying to get others to follow. I'm still not sure how Mad's vote is all that different from the previous votes on Kash.


To me it seems Kash cannot make up her mind about Red's vote on her. Kash's first reaction was a little harsh then she chalks it up to Ice as just a funny thing between herself and Red continued from the last game then in this last post it was a stupid random vote on her. She goes on to describe Red's voting habits from the previous game. Sounds kinda bitter to me. And it appears Kash has gone silent perhaps being instructed by her teammates to lay low.

If my vote is needed I will put it on Kash. But it appears not atm. I'm placing my vote on my 2nd highest suspect, reasons given above.

I vote to lynch Zigman

Then Coler and RB place their votes on Zig.

I get the logic for kash...50/50 she is either wiseguy/power role or mucsy but I hate the people voting her lol.

I like action at nightfall too. If there is no movement for rbishop today I won't be leaving my vote on a nobody. I retract my vote to lynch Rbishop and vote to lynch Zigman. I'd be happy to vote bob if anyone wants to join me btw.

I retract my vote on Dawg...and vote to lynch Zig.....just to help Coler...

Then 20min after RB's vote which ties the vote on Zig and Kashta (and after Kashta's vote to put Zig over the top) she tries to switch her vote.

I retract my vote for zigman. I vote to lynch kash

Why? She wants both to be voted out but then tries to switch at the last minute. Not sure what to think but Plants explanation is in order IMO. As is one from RB and Coler still.

Well that's it for tonight. I'll check things out tomorrow.

 

[Kashta]

Welcome to the game mostlycichlids.

I really don't like her last ditch effort to save herself w/a vote for Zigman and no other reason.

I vote to lynch Kashta

Plantling, I am with the town... plain and simple. You guys had me wrong as a PR player because I posted early. This theory seems strange to me. If I'd received a PM and was collaborating and communicating with other players I would have gone off to collaborate and communicate, not post in the thread.

Then TRS posted immediately to lynch me. After the previous game we had just played, I took that to be a joke and I thought it was funny if not a little annoying. So I laughed it off and TRS replied saying it was a joke.

I am sorry that my posting and this exchange with TRS drew so much attention on me. Not only was I gone today and unable to defend myself, this also interfered with our normal flow and our efforts to flush out the rebels.

There's a lot in this thread for us all to review now. We've lost both Zig and Ice who were innocents. I didn't know Zig was innocent when I had to still vote and there was building suspicion against him now which you had raised previously. I was hoping you and the others were right and that my last-minute vote would not just save my neck but also help the town in the process.

 

[bkw1982]

ugh, wtf.

I dont understand the surge of votes for zig. the case on kash makes much more sense. The fact that kash is alive and ice was hit gives me the impression that either:

• Kash is rebel scum and ice was hit cause they figured him to be PR
• or kash is a citizen and ice was hit cause they thought him to be PR

Id like to hear from the folks that jumped on zig.

Jumped on Zig
Zigman - plant (176), cjt (178), Coler (180), Rb (190), Kash (197)

Plant you especially have some explaining. why not go to kash when you see the surge for zig?


To does who didn't vote kash or zig it would help if you explained why you didn't vote zig or kash when the votes were so close? IMO you crapped out cause u didn't want the attention on you, and that makes me think rebel scum.

Didn't vote kash or zsig
Maverick - Ice (44), ZS (149)
Ice - dawg (58), Luvbugz (159)
DD - jpap (61), jbradt (131)
TRS - DD (65), Maverick (137)

 

[The Red Severum]

We got to get rid of coler or rb. The way they talk, is that they are planning together to save each other. Unless they are both citzens, and are cheating by communcating. Which one is it? Why would you save each other. After tonight, kash seems to even more just scream out scum.
As again,
I vote to lynch kash
This is early, but people need to notice her. This is subject to change, looking at RB and coler.