Here's my input this morning. I feel DD and Luv are both mafia. I also highly suspect FD being part of this but she still may be innocent... yet after reading FD's more recent posts, they fit in well having a connection to both DD and Luv. Reviewing the thread more has cleared Noodles, Ice, JL, and Rich in my mind. JM made a huge mistake calling for speculation about the Dr. which was really bad but may have been done out of inexperience, not realizing such a discussion would tip off the mafia as to who they'd want to hit next.
DD is not playing the same as she did when she was noncommunicating mafia or a noncommunicating wiseguy. This time, she was more active and connected in the game. When she is noncommunicating, she tends to float in and out more sporadically. I think she is communicating this time because her activity was a lot more connected/purposeful before she later had to defend herself for not voting.
In this game, DD has been posting more suspects and was quick to stir up interest over Luvbugz early on... which she failed to follow through on to vote Luvbugz for the lynch. I suspect Luv is her teammate and DD started that to distance them from each other while nothing else was going on yet, intending to switch off as soon as someone else flubbed up or a new suspicion developed elsewhere once the inactive players showed up. That just didn't happen through the first day.
I don't believe for a moment that DD decided not to vote out of indecision. The DD I've seen before would've played her best hunch to vote somewhere else, except she'd already committed herself to vote Luvbugz over anyone else. So she stayed out of the voting completely.
FD cast a late vote to save Luv by taking MC out instead. That was how they resolved the problem to save Luvbugz. FD voted MC with 5 minutes to spare with DD's vote held in reserve in case somebody switched from MC back to Luv. When nobody did, DD didn't vote for Luv (her #1 suspect) because that would've put Luv back in tied with MC with her fate decided by a coin toss. DD didn't vote Noodles or MC because she'd not built up a convincing case against them and it would've been obvious that she was only saving her teammate Luv.
As a vet, DD knew she'd end up taking flack over not voting but she also knows she can talk herself out of a tight spot fairly well. She tried to blow that off at first with her explanation to Ice... which isn't very solid at all. But Ice wasn't buying it... and that's when JL came into this. DD's now having to defend herself more intently. I just don't see it as being very convincing.
Jpappy (mafia) voted Noodles because he knew she wasn't on the scum team. He doesn't strike me as a vote switcher, hoping to distance himself with that vote. And I seriously doubt Ice would've followed Jpap's vote if both Jpap and Ice were mafia.