Here's mine...
Jpap - Bears watching... Asks good questions, pokes around for clues, and calls people out when he thinks he's onto something. Could be pro-town... could be pretending to be pro-town because he's on the other side. Can't read him well enough to be sure.
RB - Highly suspicious. Not helping the town.. which is typical. Covers himself instead (or the vamp side) by laying low. Needs to get more involved.
Coler - Fairly neutral. Not as suspicous as he seemed. Others saw us as bickering with each other. I didn't see it that way at the time and don't now. I drew attention Day 1 spouting my ideas all over the place.. and Coler grilled me about it. There's nothing hostile in that.. it's even good game play. I answered his questions but I wondered at first if he was on the vamp side trying to set me up. When I got more aggressive myself to see how he'd react to it, it didn't phase him.. which is typical for him.
JL - Highly suspicious for not playing his usual game. Antagonizes/provokes people differently than he normally does (not just me either). He's not doing the town any good this time and that's an important factor. In my case, he enjoys messing with my head... so JL has a cat and mouse game going on with me that started before this game did. That'll just be the case from now on no matter what game we're in.. even when we're on the same side. He thinks it's fun and he's told me this (and others) often enough that I believe it. I do see him as one of the vamps who's just decided to stir things up a lot while he sits back and laughs at us. This game must be a fun one for him.
Zsand - Nothing suspicious. Still cautious about which side he's on.
Jm - Leaning suspicious.. he's got no follow-through in anything. Pops in and out lobbing random questions but he's not real self-directed.
Annie - Uninvolved.. either confused or disinterested. Generally suspicious but there's not enough to go on yet.
Ogre - Neutal/nothing suspicious.
Zaffy - Puts himself ahead of everyone else regardless of which team he's on. Not the least bit helpful in a pro-town way. Still justifies his longevity in the game over any concept of team play. His attitude hurts the town.. but if he's on the vampire team, he's not interested in doing them any good either. That's bad game play and he doesn't seem to get this at all.
Noodles - Can't read anything because she's not involved enough this time. This happens more often with her when she's mafia than innocent, I'm afraid.. so I expect to lean her slightly more suspicous than usual for that reason alone. In this game, she's an obvious pick for the vamps to turn.
Dawg - Too good a choice as a vamp/turn pick for us not to suspect him (eventually) as the scum side grows. Nothing real suspicous stands out though.
Rocker - Neutral. More of a non-player than just holding back to avoid attention. Not helpful as a villager at all but wouldn't be if he's on the vamp side either. Not a bad lynch though as their numbers increase. Vamps might turn him just to hide someone we're less likely to go after.
Wycco - Suspicious as a matter of game play. He was too vocal last time and got himself lynched for it. So he's laying low this time hoping we won't notice him he's playing differently. He'll find out that doesn't go unnoticed. Not a bad idea to look over all his posts this game. He bears even more scrutiny than I'd give him otherwise.
DD - Dead innocent.. staked D1.
Phoenixn7g - Dead innocent.. UD'd D1.
Lanimret - Not looking at anything else except his relation to his friend who invited him to play. Thinks it's fun to add ammunition to the fire that Zaffy has drawn. Too new at this to know it's not really a way of participating in this. See as neutral now.
Rich - Adds as little as possible.. falls into same category as Rbishop for the most part. Default to lean him on the suspicious side.. just not sure.
Paperdragon - Making a good effort to jump right into this. Nothing yet though to go on.
Overall impression of the game itself.. not optimistic at all. Out of 19 players there's a prevaling assumption among a lot of people that we've managed to ID not just one of the vamps on Day 1..... but that we had both of them up for lynching the very first night? (And you guys thought my theories were far fetched.) I can't believe this impression bodes well for us over the long run.
The odds of us finding 2 vamps the very first day are extremely low. Even when there's 6-8 mafia players on team, for us to locate just 1 scummy player the first day in...... how often does that actually happen the first or second day? In this format there's only 2 for us to find and we have virutally nothing to go on Day 1. It's highly unrealistic for us to think we're that smart or that lucky.
Jpap - Bears watching... Asks good questions, pokes around for clues, and calls people out when he thinks he's onto something. Could be pro-town... could be pretending to be pro-town because he's on the other side. Can't read him well enough to be sure.
RB - Highly suspicious. Not helping the town.. which is typical. Covers himself instead (or the vamp side) by laying low. Needs to get more involved.
Coler - Fairly neutral. Not as suspicous as he seemed. Others saw us as bickering with each other. I didn't see it that way at the time and don't now. I drew attention Day 1 spouting my ideas all over the place.. and Coler grilled me about it. There's nothing hostile in that.. it's even good game play. I answered his questions but I wondered at first if he was on the vamp side trying to set me up. When I got more aggressive myself to see how he'd react to it, it didn't phase him.. which is typical for him.
JL - Highly suspicious for not playing his usual game. Antagonizes/provokes people differently than he normally does (not just me either). He's not doing the town any good this time and that's an important factor. In my case, he enjoys messing with my head... so JL has a cat and mouse game going on with me that started before this game did. That'll just be the case from now on no matter what game we're in.. even when we're on the same side. He thinks it's fun and he's told me this (and others) often enough that I believe it. I do see him as one of the vamps who's just decided to stir things up a lot while he sits back and laughs at us. This game must be a fun one for him.
Zsand - Nothing suspicious. Still cautious about which side he's on.
Jm - Leaning suspicious.. he's got no follow-through in anything. Pops in and out lobbing random questions but he's not real self-directed.
Annie - Uninvolved.. either confused or disinterested. Generally suspicious but there's not enough to go on yet.
Ogre - Neutal/nothing suspicious.
Zaffy - Puts himself ahead of everyone else regardless of which team he's on. Not the least bit helpful in a pro-town way. Still justifies his longevity in the game over any concept of team play. His attitude hurts the town.. but if he's on the vampire team, he's not interested in doing them any good either. That's bad game play and he doesn't seem to get this at all.
Noodles - Can't read anything because she's not involved enough this time. This happens more often with her when she's mafia than innocent, I'm afraid.. so I expect to lean her slightly more suspicous than usual for that reason alone. In this game, she's an obvious pick for the vamps to turn.
Dawg - Too good a choice as a vamp/turn pick for us not to suspect him (eventually) as the scum side grows. Nothing real suspicous stands out though.
Rocker - Neutral. More of a non-player than just holding back to avoid attention. Not helpful as a villager at all but wouldn't be if he's on the vamp side either. Not a bad lynch though as their numbers increase. Vamps might turn him just to hide someone we're less likely to go after.
Wycco - Suspicious as a matter of game play. He was too vocal last time and got himself lynched for it. So he's laying low this time hoping we won't notice him he's playing differently. He'll find out that doesn't go unnoticed. Not a bad idea to look over all his posts this game. He bears even more scrutiny than I'd give him otherwise.
DD - Dead innocent.. staked D1.
Phoenixn7g - Dead innocent.. UD'd D1.
Lanimret - Not looking at anything else except his relation to his friend who invited him to play. Thinks it's fun to add ammunition to the fire that Zaffy has drawn. Too new at this to know it's not really a way of participating in this. See as neutral now.
Rich - Adds as little as possible.. falls into same category as Rbishop for the most part. Default to lean him on the suspicious side.. just not sure.
Paperdragon - Making a good effort to jump right into this. Nothing yet though to go on.
Overall impression of the game itself.. not optimistic at all. Out of 19 players there's a prevaling assumption among a lot of people that we've managed to ID not just one of the vamps on Day 1..... but that we had both of them up for lynching the very first night? (And you guys thought my theories were far fetched.) I can't believe this impression bodes well for us over the long run.
The odds of us finding 2 vamps the very first day are extremely low. Even when there's 6-8 mafia players on team, for us to locate just 1 scummy player the first day in...... how often does that actually happen the first or second day? In this format there's only 2 for us to find and we have virutally nothing to go on Day 1. It's highly unrealistic for us to think we're that smart or that lucky.
