Mafia 55...Badlands Twisted...the Play...

GAH! I was hoping more would of happened since I was here last...come on guys we gotta get to talking here!
So looking back at the few posts that have been made, I just have a couple questions before I head off to work...

johnlarson66 said:
noods, if you come up innocent. I certainly will keep an eye on Kash. I stated before nightfall that I would trust Kash less if Wycco came up evil. It would be a bold, bold move for an evil to lead the charge against one of their own. The only reason wycco was tested is because of Kash, I was quick to follow, but had given up and the whole wycco vs john thing was getting to be a distraction. The only way they would do this if wycco had to quit playing and was going to UD anyway.

Right now I trust Kash, ZS and MC. That is who I have leaning innocent. EVERYONE else is suspect.
Click to expand...
Why would you trust Kash LESS if Wycco came up evil?

johnlarson66 said:
One thing is odd about wycco's list. The player order. I think most of us do it in the order from where the players are listed on day one, but wycco has his own order.

This could be telling.

I need to get going so I will not be able to torment noods for a few hours, maybe someone else can take my place.
Click to expand...
As far as Wyccos "list" IMO, yes we should look it over and try to see if there is anything to it, but really...a evils lists doesn't hold much for me. Many times they will list their mates as evil thinking others will think them innocent, other times they will list them innocent or leaning innocent. They just have no bases to them and are very distracting to try and figure out.

Now, I have a question for everyone....Rocker, does he always play this way (as in doesn't really play)?

What about Annie?

I would love to hear some thoughts on other players besides Noods and Kash.
 
I think the posting has subsided because it is a foregone conclusion that Noods will be gone tonight. The fact that she is not trying to help the Town knowing she will be gone tonight tells me that we are on the right track. If she turns up innocent I will be surprised and wonder why she didn't do more to change peoples minds.

MC's vote is very questionable but I'm trying to decide if this would be an evil move. most likely an evil would hide in the train on Noods. Especially knowing that she is going tonight.

So now I'm wondering who people think may be the best choices when Noods turns up innocent or evil. For me if she is innocent Kash, JL and I would be suspect and if she turns up evil I would say Rich, Rocker and maybe MC due to his latest vote <--(I'm still trying to figure that one out.)
 
Ooops, I also wanted to add a question for MC,

Ok, I understand not wanting to "get on the train", and agree there really should be others up...as you can see when everyone votes one person all talking seems to end. My question to you though is, why is your vote on the one person most see as the most likely to be innocent at this point? I mean there are others that look scummier, so why Kash? Yes, if Noods comes up as innocent...I can see the lack of trust. Not that I fully 100% trust Kash but a vote on her at this point just seems weird.
 
dirtydawg10 said:
I think the posting has subsided because it is a foregone conclusion that Noods will be gone tonight. The fact that she is not trying to help the Town knowing she will be gone tonight tells me that we are on the right track. If she turns up innocent I will be surprised and wonder why she didn't do more to change peoples minds.

MC's vote is very questionable but I'm trying to decide if this would be an evil move. most likely an evil would hide in the train on Noods. Especially knowing that she is going tonight.

So now I'm wondering who people think may be the best choices when Noods turns up innocent or evil. For me if she is innocent Kash, JL and I would be suspect and if she turns up evil I would say Rich, Rocker and maybe MC due to his latest vote <--(I'm still trying to figure that one out.)
Click to expand...

Looks like I am not the only one wondering about that vote.

As far as who else I think (which is what I think we should be talking about...),
DD has me very courious her lack of participation is troubling to me (yes I know she never post ALOT). Looking back at her posts though...she doesn't really say much of anything.

Annie his (he is a guy right?) posts are very strange to me. Makes very long multi-quote post but really doesn't say much of anything and it is quite frankly hard to know what they are saying.

Rocker just doesn't seem to post. Now him and Annie, I'm not sure how they normally play so I don't know if this is usual.

MC and his vote on Kash has me more then concerned. He has made me wonder quite a bit this game, I was even wondering if his "slip" (vote on Ogre)...maybe wasn't planned. I just can't help but go back and forth on him.

You (Dawg) well you just flat out confuse me:hypnotized:
 
Lady G said:
Ooops, I also wanted to add a question for MC,

Ok, I understand not wanting to "get on the train", and agree there really should be others up...as you can see when everyone votes one person all talking seems to end. My question to you though is, why is your vote on the one person most see as the most likely to be innocent at this point? I mean there are others that look scummier, so why Kash? Yes, if Noods comes up as innocent...I can see the lack of trust. Not that I fully 100% trust Kash but a vote on her at this point just seems weird.
Click to expand...
LG, I have already explained my choice...She is trying way too hard to push the point on noods....almost three pages of posts to alone to prove noods as innocent...While everyone else pretty much agrees...And again, I feel the the mafia in early games control the voting...I don't want to get stuck doing this.
 
Lady G said:
Looks like I am not the only one wondering about that vote.

As far as who else I think (which is what I think we should be talking about...),
DD has me very courious her lack of participation is troubling to me (yes I know she never post ALOT). Looking back at her posts though...she doesn't really say much of anything.

Annie his (he is a guy right?) posts are very strange to me. Makes very long multi-quote post but really doesn't say much of anything and it is quite frankly hard to know what they are saying.

Rocker just doesn't seem to post. Now him and Annie, I'm not sure how they normally play so I don't know if this is usual.

MC and his vote on Kash has me more then concerned. He has made me wonder quite a bit this game, I was even wondering if his "slip" (vote on Ogre)...maybe wasn't planned. I just can't help but go back and forth on him.

You (Dawg) well you just flat out confuse me:hypnotized:
Click to expand...
Sounds like a bunch of chatter to me....can you say something helpful?
 
mostlycichlids said:
LG, I have already explained my choice...She is trying way too hard to push the point on noods....almost three pages of posts to alone to prove noods as innocent...While everyone else pretty much agrees...And again, I feel the the mafia in early games control the voting...I don't want to get stuck doing this.
Click to expand...

I hope you mean Noods as guilty.

kash has some odd things but she did start the lynch of Wycco, so hard to build a real case against her. Even if she knows how many scientists there are.

G has been busy lately try to get some convo started. Could just be a cover.

JL is leaning innocent for me. As he was on Wy as well as Kash,

DD is really quiet and that is not that odd but she usually says something.

MC is making an odd vote today and is on my list as a possible.

Z worries me. He is not saying much of anything. He is usually good for some incite.

Dawg always worries me. I can never figure him out.

Annie made a few posts not saying much or rehashing others ideas. Definetly a worry.

Rich hell of a guy and a great photographer.

If I forgot someone it is because I am only vaguely aware they are playing.
 
mostlycichlids said:
LG, I have already explained my choice...She is trying way too hard to push the point on noods....almost three pages of posts to alone to prove noods as innocent...While everyone else pretty much agrees...And again, I feel the the mafia in early games control the voting...I don't want to get stuck doing this.
Click to expand...
Yes, I know you said she is pushing too hard for Noods...but still it just seems IDK odd.

How exactly are YOU being helpful?:huh:
 
HA! I didn't even catch the whole (prove Noods innocent thing) LMAO!

Also, if the mafia was "controling" the voting...why would they take one of there own...their LEADER at that?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom