Mafia 55...Badlands Twisted...the Play...
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
Ok I still want someone to explain to me how Kash can be an ES? She was THE FIRST VOTE on Wycco, prior to her, there was no case on him. There is no way the ES would feel confident enough in their game to lynch their LEADER on Day 2! It just doesn't work like that. Yes they will lynch each other sometimes to clear their names, but I just can't for the love of Mafia, see any End Game of that strategy that benefits them.
She's pushing the envelope, as are the majority of the players BTW, because of Noods ties to Wycco, the Dead and known leader of the ES's. I'm all for looking for other suspects but you are really confuzzling me. Now I expect you will come back with another post saying me and Kash are working together or I'm protecting her or whatever, so I'll beat you to the punch. Kash is probably the strongest lead we have on a confirmed Innocent, I tend to lean towards those I believe I can trust.
From the game sI have played yes they are pretty laid back, Rocker more so than Annie. When you put pressure on them they tend to speak up. Thus the reason I voted for Annie early.
Glad I worry you since I have you leaning strongly ES. And I'm sorry my posts are not up to your quality standards. I will try to be more concise tomorrow when I vote for you.
List of suspects:
Noodles: Connections to Wycco, good chance of Day 1 distancing votes. (8/10)
Rich: Defensive of Noodles, refuses to see why Kash is mostly cleared. (8/10)
Annie: Quiet, also doesn't get why Kash is Mostly cleared, seems to want to go against the grain. (6/10)
MC: Confuses me entirely, I see reasons for and against possible Evil behaviors. (6/10)
DD: Just quieter than normal, but may have RL issues like I did earlier. (5/10)
Rocker: Who knows for sure. Watching for now. (5/10)
I said you were not inciteful nothing about concise. This post was much better. I feel more comfortable now.
mostlycichlids
Cichlid Specialist
Uh yep that is what I meant "guilty"...was still early didn't even have my glasses on yet.
Well...I guess people are saying I am being confusing...but My allegations are specifically from wycco's list....His list should, as i have already said have some clues...got to try and read between the lines I guess.
They made a simple slip up and now they are trying to cover things up really well.... I am in no way saing noods is absolutley innocent I am just trying to think in different avenues just in case she does come back innocent.
When did I say you worry me? Now you say you will definately be voting me tomorrow....who is being confusing now? In BOLD...she was the first on him and he turned up evil...I get that...why would a teammate do this....I dk, maybe she was going to change later but whe she seen he was doomed kept her vote there and started building a case agauinst noods....just a thought. I have read through her posts and am gong both ways on this really.
mostlycichlids
Cichlid Specialist
Woops guess I didn't see you are talking about rich ZS...disreguard leaning me as ES and me worring you.
johnlarson66
These Pandas Rock
Last game, I led the charge on jpap, twice. I had everyones complete trust at the time, except one person. That is because I was investigated. When the investigation was made public, then AND ONLY then did the rest of the town no longer trust me. We felt we could lose a teamate because of the format being able to gain a member.
It would have worked if it was not me leading the charge. I was investigated right out the gate. If we could have waited a bit and maybe used a lower profile player, I think it would have worked. If I would not have been pronounced evil last game or would have claimed to been the seer, I think we would have won.
In this format the players that have the investigations CAN NOT go public, if they do and they get hit, the game is over. There is one player left that can investigate and if they are hit, the game is over. We can not rely on their help this game.
I do not think it is out of the relm of possibilities that evil will kill a teamate or even lead the charge. So Wycco was the leader, big deal, now the team has to each send in their own PM. Dr Gene used his special power. I also think there is a vial that turns someone out there.
It would be a bold move. I don't think it happened, but it is not impossible. That is why I will keep an extra eye on Kash if noods comes back innocent.
It would have worked if it was not me leading the charge. I was investigated right out the gate. If we could have waited a bit and maybe used a lower profile player, I think it would have worked. If I would not have been pronounced evil last game or would have claimed to been the seer, I think we would have won.
In this format the players that have the investigations CAN NOT go public, if they do and they get hit, the game is over. There is one player left that can investigate and if they are hit, the game is over. We can not rely on their help this game.
I do not think it is out of the relm of possibilities that evil will kill a teamate or even lead the charge. So Wycco was the leader, big deal, now the team has to each send in their own PM. Dr Gene used his special power. I also think there is a vial that turns someone out there.
It would be a bold move. I don't think it happened, but it is not impossible. That is why I will keep an extra eye on Kash if noods comes back innocent.
My first meeting finally ended and trying to catch up. You know I am becoming less and less trusting of Kashta. Yes, she was the first one to vote for Wycco, the known Dr Gene, however I also noted that Wycco posted another thread yesterday stating that he was headed out of town to Florida. Perhaps the evil team new he would not have the available time to devote to the team so they decided to lead the charge to take him out thus giving them all a place to hide.....She has pushed so hard to prove me scum and has spent much time and pages to do so. When you get tonite's resutls I would suggest looking at her in a new light.....
And as far as me being connected to Wycco as several of you have mentioned; the only connection there is was him saying that I was leaning innocent. I do not see how this can be considered a connection! Puleeeze! I would also like to add that I believe it was LG that took that little comment and blew it out of proportion. A conventient tool, with Kashta's help, for the evil team to take down another townie, probably hoping to get the second Bio Engineer in the process......
More after I read over a few more things......also, in regards to me trying to help, I have stated what I see, in the small amount of time that I have had. Sorry it has not been sufficient in some's eyes.
And as far as me being connected to Wycco as several of you have mentioned; the only connection there is was him saying that I was leaning innocent. I do not see how this can be considered a connection! Puleeeze! I would also like to add that I believe it was LG that took that little comment and blew it out of proportion. A conventient tool, with Kashta's help, for the evil team to take down another townie, probably hoping to get the second Bio Engineer in the process......
More after I read over a few more things......also, in regards to me trying to help, I have stated what I see, in the small amount of time that I have had. Sorry it has not been sufficient in some's eyes.
mostlycichlids
Cichlid Specialist
