Mafia 56. An Unknown Evil. THE GAME....

Kash, how are there 3 assassination attempts last night and how do you know one failed???

Ogre, wth do you think a KGB Assassin does for a living? That's what Phoenix' role was... confirmed when she got lynched. Any assassination attempt she'd submitted before she died would not be successful.
 
... would not HAVE BEEN successful.
 
Coler, I said Kash was innocent, you jumped me on it, then you have her as innocent.

Kash posted the sequence of events and makes what I consider an invalid assumption, yet you consider her to be 100% accurate.

Kash, how are there 3 assassination attempts last night and how do you know one failed???

Let me try this again. I KNOW THAT JPAP WAS NOT KILLED BY THE KGB!

Ogre just re-read my posts they speak for themselves, on what I queried you on - and it was a query. You're really struggling to make something of it. Also you havn't answered it.

There's nothing about the sequence given by Kashta that is not plausible, or must be wrong given known facts.

She says that Phoenix, although dead, is unlikely to have been able to use her assassination powers. Why would a KGB - evil - assassin not use the kill power - of course they would try and use it, and if its limited then you'd use it as early as possible.

Presuming that Wycco is being accurate in the nightfall posts, neither kill was a hit placed by Phoenix.

Anyway you presumably are saying that you killed jappy - major cludge as a CIA agent or what ? And can I also enquire as to why anyone innocent and sensible would kill somebody that was accusing them of being 100% evil. So now that you finally claim the kill - care to give us a reason Ogre ?
 
This is actually rather excellent...I really want to hear why Ogre if innocent killed jpappy.
 
All nightly events I list are sequential.

In response to Kash's comment on three evil teams; as mentioned after JPappy's death, the dead innocents, as a team, are no longer capable of winning the game.

The death of JPappy, carrier of the magical "ring of the dead" eliminated their chance at winning.
 
ta Wycco.

I'm beginning to think that Ogre may have yet again left it too late to claim an innocent power role...I'm not voting yet but his piecemeal revelations of his role, killing jpappy etc....they are just not convincing me.
 
Ogre why did you wait till now to come out as the CIA assassin and now claim to have killed Jpap? When you came out as CIA earlier you said non forensic something or other.

While I might could believe you are CIA and believe me I've been thinking on this all day I can't believe that you'd wait this long to come out as the killer.

We know there are KGB and Demons. I'm wondering if the Demons only have a 50/50 chance at turning and that was what killed Jpap and the CIA killed JL. Because unless the KGB have more then 3 players they couldn't have had a hit go through.

My 2nd question would be why did you kill Jpap, your vote was on Annie. Did Jpap really look evil to you?
 
Coler, I said Kash was innocent, you jumped me on it, then you have her as innocent.

Kash posted the sequence of events and makes what I consider an invalid assumption, yet you consider her to be 100% accurate.

Kash, how are there 3 assassination attempts last night and how do you know one failed???

Let me try this again. I KNOW THAT JPAP WAS NOT KILLED BY THE KGB!

I thought this is what you were getting at. Why did you think Jpap was KGB?? Because he picked up on your KGB baiting reference? Did it never occur to you that the mayor would also pick up on that?

This next part might come back to haunt me, but hear me out:

Even IF you are a CIA assassin Ogre, I still am not opposed to lynching you. You claim there are still two of you left. I guess I am willing to play the odds. From my point of view, you are still guilty. Yesterday, you were pretty much begging to be lynched after your mess up. Now, you are begging us not to lynch you. Why the difference? Why didn't you care yesterday, but now care today (if you want my take on it: It is because you are the last standing of your kind). Why wouldn't have JL or Phoniex gone after you gung ho yesterday?? JL was claiming your innocence. He also claimed Phoniex's innocence.There are just sooo many things that aren't adding up.



Coler, the reason I said letting the assassin take care of Ogre is because I was starting to see through the lines on what Ogre was getting at. He is
 
The last part was supposed to read:

I figured he was gonna claim to be the assassin. Therefore, if he really isn't the real assassin could pick him off for us. Now he claims there are two... Hmmm....
 
:popcorn:
 
AquariaCentral.com