OK... so you're ready for my re-evaluation?
Post 43 and 44- Rbishop followed a "train" (in his words) after Zaffy- to go after Dawg a known innocent.
Post 48 ZSand "darn archangel again) - read very little into this- but "Archangel" was an evil character and every game since I've started playing that ZSand was innocent he made the claim he was. The one time he wasn't- he didn't.
Post 143, 145, 149, 150 - Lots of post in quick succession from Lady G against Annie. 150, Lady G possible distancing from RB and/or Zaff.
Post 152 Ice known innocent-plays down Annie's (known innocents) guilt- possible attack on LG and JL.
"I'm wondering why LG,JL haven't questioned Ogre for saving Annie if they think Annie is in fact mafia."
Also- posts interest on Land and MC "Still would like to hear from Lan and MC. ". - post 184 implicatate JL, LG, DD as people he doesn't trust. Was Ice a threat to the mafia team?
Post 168 - 168 posts into the game JMax posts a lot of off topic info- has been really quiet in the game and tops off her post with a vote against an innocent.
Post 179 JPap comments Lan in risk of UDing.
186 JL defends Annie's role (known innocent) - indifferent to RB (known scum) - doesn't see Luv (known innocent) as guilty because didn't crack. This takes aways suspicion from JL.
187 Ogre agrees with Ice's list- which I too think was pretty accurate in hindsight- even though I though Ice might be guilty at the time. This takes a little suspicion away from Ogre.
188 JL debunks's Ice's list of to trust.
207 Lan finally shows up (at request of team mates???- had time for PM to go his way)- votes for innocent Ice.
217 ZSand shows up after long absence and takes the "trying to avoid being voted off" argument against Annie after it had been proved wrong.
221 Wycco (to include myself on here and my own screw up
) Makes a complete hash of things in an early theoretical list- including several players later found out to be innocent.
228 Ice again implicates DD. - again implicates LG (kinda) for voting one way and arguing another way regarding Annie.
240 Rich votes for RB as he begins to take the lead. Could have voted on Annie if a team-mate of RB to tie things back up. Unlikely though Rich and RB are on same team.
24(x) JL questions why Rb is seen as guilty several times.
258 ZSand makes really odd comment. "I still don't like the late run on Rb even though he was scum, it proves nothing of innocence in a two Evils game." Also claims both mafia groups went after Ice. - as later pointed out by Lady G- how did he know? Later he points to JPaps comment of another character in the shadows... maybe.
304 Cichlids exonherates himself somewhat by posting a long informative post. Points doubt at Annie and Luv known innocents- but nothing strong- makes a lot of good posts... a worth read.
311 Woodward makes observation ZSand taking game more seriously than everyone else.
313 JohnL makes intesting participation notes.. Ogre, himself, Lady G are the only three (still alive now) that have made large participations.
330 Onwards- Annie implicates me because I voted for him and I've been quiet.
So what do I make of all the evidence going back, knowing what we know now?
Well - of everyone LadyG looks the most likely to be guilty having voted for innocents every night and her post history doesn't look particulary sparkling.
I vote to lynch LadyG.
I have very strong suspicions on DD based upon the above. She'd be my second choice.
After them:
Zsand and JMax look suspicious without either really having done anything noticably wrong.
Lan's been too quiet to judge. Woodward has blended into the wood work well as has Rich.
On the other hand- Ogre and JohnL have been very "noisy" and with that many posts without anything seriously big to implicate them- battering each other a fair bit- I'm not considering them as likely mafia. Possible- keep an eye on them- but I think there are better choices.
I do buy Mostly's claim of being busy- and when he has been on board I've found him Mostly helpfull and his posts agree with Ice's who I think was most on the ball the first two days. I have him most likely innocent too.
Zaffy has shown to be fairly helpfull too... and he's not done anything wrong... For some reason I don't 100% trust him- but I've got him as most likely innocent for now too... Perhaps it's the rolling Captain Picard that makes him look guilty.
