Mafia #57: The Great Mafia War- The Game

[Woodward]

That is it. No reason as to what rings true.

huh?

 

[Wycco]

BTW- My vote stays on Lady G. But if a known innocent would like to suggest someone else- I'll gladly go on one of the other unknowns.

If the 8 starting Mafia theory is correct we've got a 75% chance of hitting scum.

I would like us all to vote as one block though- until we are in the majority again. So if you don't like Lady G, pick someone else and we can vote as a unit of innocents.

 

[ZSandmann]

I retract my vote on MC

 

[Wycco]

As for my predictions:

Rich, DangerDoll, Wood, Zaffy, ZSand, Judge, LadyG, Lam

LadyG and DangerDoll both voted for innocents three nights in a row... so find it unlikely they're innocent.
ZSand, Judge both voted for Annie twice- and I do think the newspaper headlines could have been suspected to be Annie... see my earlier post.


That leaves Rich, Wood, Zaffy and Lam. Which two are innocent? Well knowing Zaffy and Lam have been in contact- I would suspect Rich and Wood are the two other remaining innocents but obviously I can't know for sure.


If I'm right though- I think I've got the whole thing pegged- so should the doctor choose not to protect me tonight and I get killed- for the town here is my analysis (ASSUMING 4 MAFIA PER TEAM):


Ogre- known innocent
JL - known innocent
MC - known innocent

Wood - maybe innocent
Rich - maybe innocent
Zaffy - likely guilty
lam - likely guilty

Zsand - most likely guilty
Judge - most likely guilty
Ddoll - most likely guilty
LadyG - most likely guilty.



Voila!

 

[Wycco]

Oh and I'm obviously going to keep investigating incase I'm wrong...

 

[Zaffy]

Yikes... I don't know what to make of that.

Either you're both on a team together and you just stuck your foot in it by mentioning the IM- or Zaffy bent the rules a little there.

From what I understand there is not supposed to be any interaction about the game off the main post thread.




Otherwise, from what you've said- I can buy your quietness- and prior to that last comment you wern't really on my radar- it was just an observation that you've been hard to read because you've been quiet.

We talk on IM all the time about all kinds of things.

I told him that the mafia game had started when I noticed that he hadn't posted yet. We didn't talk about anything in game, or people in game.

I don't feel like that is outside the rules. We didn't and don't talk about mafia game stuff outside the thread. If you guys feel that's out of line, then we can have Jpappy make a ruling there.

 

[Zaffy]

I retract my vote on ogre

 

[Woodward]

We talk on IM all the time about all kinds of things.

I told him that the mafia game had started when I noticed that he hadn't posted yet. We didn't talk about anything in game, or people in game.

I don't feel like that is outside the rules. We didn't and don't talk about mafia game stuff outside the thread. If you guys feel that's out of line, then we can have Jpappy make a ruling there.

Im new to this game, so maybe my two cents doesnt matter as much as some other peoples.....but i would have to say dont worry about it.
The group as a whole will never know if two players illegally communicate, and im sure it has happened before....even though it does take the fun out of the game, there is nothing that can be done about it.
If you and whoever really dont talk about the game outside of this thread (unless you guys have permission) then just plain dont worry about it. Everyone else will deal with it. :

 

[Wycco]

Zaffy, regardless... you're not at the top of my list- so maybe we'll get a clearer picture on who is guilty by the time we reach you- and see if you and/or lam are innocent or guilty.

We only get to lynch one person a day- and I get one investigation a day. We'll see when we get to you.

Right now- hoping I'm right about Lady G- and my investigation for tonight.

 

[ZSandmann]

Wycco I believe you because honestly it would be dumb for either Mafia team to Role Claim at this point in the game. I suspected the Journalist would have investigated JL and Ogre first too, so that adds credibility. Unfortunatly they are all targets now and we have to hope the Doctor is clever and makes the Mafia second guess who they will protect.

I am not sold on LG, but I am willing to follow your lead till I see a better suspect.

I vote to lynch LG