OgreMkV
Father of Earth's Next Emperor
I do see the point of RB and Zaff too, especially RB although I can see them "hitting" the person..not really "nitting" them:
I don't know, I hear RB does mean things with crochet hooks.
Mafia #57: The Great Mafia War- The Game
- Thread starter jpappy789
- Start date
I don't know, I hear RB does mean things with crochet hooks.
retractions by annie fixed
I'm wondering why LG,JL haven't questioned Ogre for saving Annie if they think Annie is in fact mafia.
Annies voting doesn't bother me. He voted for 3 others then retracted on players that he could have killed with his vote in the name of saving himself instead of risking dying by coin flip.I'm going to keep an eye on him but right now he isn't vibing me much.
The hit on Dawg has to be someone that is worried about him being a PR or feels like he knows their style to well.
Still would like to hear from Lan and MC. Also JM is in risk of UDing since she didn't vote last night.
Also Luv, I'd like an answer to my question posed yesterday.
Do you still feel your vote was made correctly? Can you explain why so?
Do you still feel your vote was made correctly? Can you explain why so?
Dangerdoll
Global Moderator
ok, let me clear myself up here
again, I vote to lynch Annie
seems like you are trying to throw suspicion in a million places, as long as the heat is off you. And I am prepared for you to call this a train vote, fact is, I have suspected you from the start and came home at 11, read through the thread and am at my point of voting, where my reasons have not changed. You have done nothing to make me think anything other than you being scum.
Without looking back, I don't know of what "issue" was going on with Ogre. The reason I posted that I voted you Annie is because of your very first post. Not because I was following anyone else. As I have already mentioned earlier, the simple fact of you stating that you were having "Mafia withdrawals" more than 24 hours after the game had started seems inconsistent. If you wwere having such withdrawals, why would you have been the 1st, 2nd, even 3rd to post??
as I said and as you even noted, I would not be back before nightfall, so just how did you expect me to be able to explain my vote?? Looks like you were running looking for anything to throw out there... adding to the contined vote changes confusion.....
again, I vote to lynch Annie
seems like you are trying to throw suspicion in a million places, as long as the heat is off you. And I am prepared for you to call this a train vote, fact is, I have suspected you from the start and came home at 11, read through the thread and am at my point of voting, where my reasons have not changed. You have done nothing to make me think anything other than you being scum.
Day one is so full of misinformation. All we've got to deal with really is the voting record.
Annie - Although there are plenty of non-reasons to throw your vote around on day 1. The number of switches is what bugs me. I don't see any real benefit to changing your vote as many times as you did, but to each their own. I am bothered by the one post 119 with the 3 votes/retractions. That seems like unnecessary dirt kicking to me.
RB, Ogre, Ogre, LG, Wood, and DD (I'm looking only at the vote list, so I may have missed a name, or timing) are interesting votes because they are the votes that gave a person more than one. Not much to go on. I think it's a necessary tactic on day one in fact. Still something to keep in the back of my mind.
As far as Ogre saving Annie. I can certainly see the reasoning behind this accusation. Whether it's true or not, I don't feel like I have enough info to make that call, but I can certainly see the logic behind it. Looking at his posts, I get a vibe that it's a set up to distance them from each other while still saving Annie. My problem is that I don't see why Ogre would put the #2 vote on in the first place. It seems sloppy and frivolous.
Lady G and Ogre, (maybe someone else OMG SKIMMING!) have brought up that RB and/or I might be responsable for putting a hit on Dawg. I see it being a useful tactic to deflect suspicion, or cast it depending on your perspective.
I'm bothered by the non-voters. If they forgot they're playing or what.
If I add up my points here. I think the best bet is between RB, Annie and Ogre.
I vote to lynch RBishop
I'm going with RB because it's the most tinfoil of the ideas and I'd like to hear from him his take on the subject. This vote of course subject to availability and change. Not valid with other offers. Not available to residents of Utah, New Hampshire, and Rhode Island.
I don't know why you are so worried about my vote Ice. With everything that went down last night, with all the weird vote switching and such, you are still worried about my vote that happened pretty early in the game. Yes, I pointed out that RB's second vote on someone so early in the game seemed weird. Is that enough to really go on so early in day one? I was expecting to come back in the day to change it to whoever was pinging my scumdar the most. I didn't get to. Yes, at least I did vote, but I am disappointed that I haven't been able to play a more active role this time around.
While I STILL think Rb's early second vote on someone is weird and might be telling, I find Annie's vote switching last night a little more scummy. It looks to me that he was trying to hide something. Maybe's Ogre's vote to save him?? I dunno.
For now, I vote to lynch Ogre.
mostlycichlids
Cichlid Specialist
Why am I worried? Because you placed a vote then vanished. I wanted to know why you voted the way you did which you still refused to answer. If RBs vote seemed the most weird of the day why then didn't the vote land there? Is it because RB already had a vote and you didn't want to be the 2nd on and start any momentum that way?
Question Ogre. What do you mean in the bolded part of the statement?
From what I can tell Annie made a vote post after nightfall and thats it. Rocker came in later and voted you then you made this statement. Annie hadn't posted between so how could he ask about Rocker in whichever sense you mean?
