Mafia 58-

[jpappy789]

So there's what, three non communicating mafia left? My top three suspects are TRS, Zaffy, and Ogre (no real order at this point) and I'm confident that at least two remaining mafia are in that group. The odds are much better now than at the beginning of the game.

 

[jpappy789]

So there's what, three non communicating mafia left? My top three suspects are TRS, Zaffy, and Ogre (no real order at this point) and I'm confident that at least two remaining mafia are in that group. The odds are much better now than at the beginning of the game.

By this I meant given the popular suspects. Obviously, there are more innocents out there that we could accidentally lynch, but I think we have narrowed it down enough.

 

[jpappy789]

By this I meant given the popular suspects. Obviously, there are more innocents out there that we could accidentally lynch, but I think we have narrowed it down enough.

Still not sure if that makes any sense.

I guess I was considering 2 out of 3 is better than 50%...I need rest.

 

[The Red Severum]

Why am I one your list? I was one of the main people that was in it for rich? You were the one who was saying I was setting up rich, when he was a CM.
(jpap)

 

[ZSandmann]

I vote to lynch Zaffy

Mainly to keep the votes balanced I will openly admit. I think Zaffy and I have gone at it from about every corner of logic there is with landslides vs. two horse races but this is clearly a Day where we need to weigh the suspects and keep multiple working hypotheses on the table. Do I need to explain why today is a two horse day versus yesterday Zaff?

 

[Kashta]

Why am I one your list? I was one of the main people that was in it for rich? You were the one who was saying I was setting up rich, when he was a CM.
(jpap)

Red, you were after Rich on Day #1. Not only that but from your very first post. And this postion never wavered to anyone else at any time for any reason.

This was your first post in the game.

I vote to lynch rich

Why? Becuase I don't like him. Nice to be back around..

Since you were predisposed to be "in it" for Rich before he could even be suspicious yet and he coincidentally turned up as scum later in the game, how do you get credit for suspecting Rich now or for having REAL suspicious type reasons about him?

The fact that you started out picking someone at random with a 50/50 chance of being right doesn't mean a thing. And it has no bearing whatsoever on which team you're on. It was a 50/50 chance so all your, "See I was right!" and "I told you so!" nonsense isn't going to wash.

 

[Zaffy]

I vote to lynch Zaffy

Mainly to keep the votes balanced I will openly admit. I think Zaffy and I have gone at it from about every corner of logic there is with landslides vs. two horse races but this is clearly a Day where we need to weigh the suspects and keep multiple working hypotheses on the table. Do I need to explain why today is a two horse day versus yesterday Zaff?

I think me vs ogre is a great idea in fact. Seeing as how MC was the last communicating mafia. I don't feel that my previous accusation towards you is valid any longer.

I vote to lynch Ogre.

 

[The Red Severum]

Red, you were after Rich on Day #1. Not only that but from your very first post. And this postion never wavered to anyone else at any time for any reason.

This was your first post in the game.



Since you were predisposed to be "in it" for Rich before he could even be suspicious yet and he coincidentally turned up as scum later in the game, how do you get credit for suspecting Rich now or for having REAL suspicious type reasons about him?

The fact that you started out picking someone at random with a 50/50 chance of being right doesn't mean a thing. And it has no bearing whatsoever on which team you're on. It was a 50/50 chance so all your, "See I was right!" and "I told you so!" nonsense isn't going to wash.

Yeah, everyone is random in the start. But then I started to notice rich was quite, and defensive.

 

[Zaffy]

By my count, there are now 3 remaining non-communicating mafia members. They no longer have the capability to make a hit.

The 3 communicating innocents are intact plus 2 regular innocents, and the innocent journalist (appears to have learned nothing, or found innocents based on the sports headlines). The only wildcard right now is the Mafia journalist, who seems to be implicating Jpappy.

We can't lost at this point, it's just a matter of time. There is no way that the non-communicating mafia can win a vote over the communicating team, unless the communicators really botch it.

 

[ZSandmann]

He was quite what?