ok rich, instead of using the denial, who do you think is mafia? Make me change my vote, who do you think is mafia?
Mafia 58-
- Thread starter IceH2O
- Start date
My point is that Jb's only "splash" really his only connection to any other player is to Rich via his case (and vote). I don't think Rich would be on the communicating mafia side then...
Otherwise, yes it was what I would consider a pretty normal mafia hit on someone who hasn't done much.
Headlines from Nights 1 and 2
Looks like the red ones are from the mafia side.. the blue ones from the town side.
Mafia journalist is writing about the underworld. The town journalist uses sports analogies.
I think the mafia guy really blew this one trying to pin a communicating mafia role on me when Dawg was up for the coin toss at all. You took a big risk there.. so sorry, you lose... lmao.
Not only does that show the other writer has to be the good guy, but it also validates the townie's investigation results. I just can't read that as trying to tell us Rich was revealed innocent. So we'll have to conclude that Rich is mafia. That's a hard one for me, since I was leaning Rich for the town side and because Dawg named him a suspect. But if Rich was non-communicating, Dawg couldn't have known... or was it distancing?
My suspects... Jpappy, Zaffy, Annie, Rich. Not sure which one to vote for. I may have picked up on something enough to draw Dawg on my butt and the mafia reporter.. but the odds of me guessing all the right names in the exact right relationship are much too.
Looks like the red ones are from the mafia side.. the blue ones from the town side.
Mafia journalist is writing about the underworld. The town journalist uses sports analogies.
I think the mafia guy really blew this one trying to pin a communicating mafia role on me when Dawg was up for the coin toss at all. You took a big risk there.. so sorry, you lose... lmao.
Not only does that show the other writer has to be the good guy, but it also validates the townie's investigation results. I just can't read that as trying to tell us Rich was revealed innocent. So we'll have to conclude that Rich is mafia. That's a hard one for me, since I was leaning Rich for the town side and because Dawg named him a suspect. But if Rich was non-communicating, Dawg couldn't have known... or was it distancing?
My suspects... Jpappy, Zaffy, Annie, Rich. Not sure which one to vote for. I may have picked up on something enough to draw Dawg on my butt and the mafia reporter.. but the odds of me guessing all the right names in the exact right relationship are much too.
TRS, Who else do YOU think is mafia?
All I see from you after day 1 is rich, rich, rich, rich, etc.
One thing that I have been thinking about is that the non-communicating mafia wouldn't want to risk implicating their teammate in the headlines. Does anyone else think that then it would be best for them to avoid naming specific players, like the first one, in case people catch on and it ends up that they caused another mafia player to be lynched?
All I see from you after day 1 is rich, rich, rich, rich, etc.
One thing that I have been thinking about is that the non-communicating mafia wouldn't want to risk implicating their teammate in the headlines. Does anyone else think that then it would be best for them to avoid naming specific players, like the first one, in case people catch on and it ends up that they caused another mafia player to be lynched?
Actually Kash I thought the top one sounded more like an Innocent going undercover to spy on the Mafia, but there's no reason a Mafium wouldn't want it to sound that way.
Honestly if I had to vote Kash or Rich right now I like Rich as a suspect more.
Honestly if I had to vote Kash or Rich right now I like Rich as a suspect more.
I do not need to play by your terms. I will post my thoughts when I have them organized.
hhhhmmm, I think we are on the same page here. Not scratchin Rich off my list but show me the money or get off the bus!
