Mafia 58-

I made a new list. Lots of time to make lists between D&D sessions down here in moms basement.

3 - TRS
3 - Ogre
4 - Jpappy
5 - Zsand
5 - Noodles
8 - DD
8 - Annie
8 - Kash
10 - Zaffy

Sorry it's all orange, I was eating cheetos.

Kashta said:
Well, that's the problem Pappy. It's a fine line. Not everything we think about should be posted in the thread when we know there are 3 scum alive, hiding out, and alert for any sign or subtle clue they can latch on to. Most of us can probably justify or explain away just about anything. Still.. openly discussing who may or may not be the town journalist by name for any reason is a big no-no IMO. Even when there is a different/valid reason for the comment... at the same time, it also helps the isolated mafia folks think something through they may not have come up with otherwise. They don't get to use someone else as a sounding board.. all they have to work with is what we give them in the thread, good intentions or not. This isn't just a matter of who isn't helping the town. It's also looking at who's been helping the mafia... at the same time.

In this case, I'll just drop it. But those posts you slipped in concern me.
Click to expand...

Is it ok to discuss who the scum journalist might be? I suggested it may be Jpappy earlier, but what are the chances that it's Zsand or Noodles, or someone? I don't think it's TRS, I don't think that he would use the same parts of speech and adjectives.
 
Sure Zaffy. Whatever you could add to that which helps us is worth posting. As you very well may be the next one lynched, the more you can offer (if innocent) is better than leaving the game with it unsaid. If you're mafia, which we all seem to believe... we'll each evaluate your ideas that way too. There's no harm in this for the town either way and your perspectives might help us make better choices.
 
Kashta said:
Well, that's the problem Pappy. It's a fine line. Not everything we think about should be posted in the thread when we know there are 3 scum alive, hiding out, and alert for any sign or subtle clue they can latch on to. Most of us can probably justify or explain away just about anything. Still.. openly discussing who may or may not be the town journalist by name for any reason is a big no-no IMO. Even when there is a different/valid reason for the comment... at the same time, it also helps the isolated mafia folks think something through they may not have come up with otherwise. They don't get to use someone else as a sounding board.. all they have to work with is what we give them in the thread, good intentions or not. This isn't just a matter of who isn't helping the town. It's also looking at who's been helping the mafia... at the same time.

In this case, I'll just drop it. But those posts you slipped in concern me.
Click to expand...


Bravo :clap:
 
Kashta said:
Sure Zaffy. Whatever you could add to that which helps us is worth posting. As you very well may be the next one lynched, the more you can offer (if innocent) is better than leaving the game with it unsaid. If you're mafia, which we all seem to believe... we'll each evaluate your ideas that way too. There's no harm in this for the town either way and your perspectives might help us make better choices.
Click to expand...

I don't really have anything other than Jpappy.

If you (kash) are the Scum journalist, then you're the best player by far this game. I think you're innocent. Same goes for Annie and DD, they've also been really helpful to the town all game long imo.

That leaves Zsand, Noodles, TRS, Ogre, and me.

If I'm the scum journalist, then I'll go down as the worst in history. I hope I'm smarter than that. I think I've played pretty poorly this game because I don't talk good at words sometimes.

I don't know about Zsand, noodles, or Ogre.
 
ok, here is my list.....1 = mafia; 10 = equal innocent. (is that the right direction?)

Ogre - 1
Zaffy - 1.5
TRS - 2
Annie - 4
Jpap - 6
Zsand - 6
DD - 7
Kashta - 9.5
Noods - 10
 
it would be good to have Zsand's spreadsheet of the suspect list right now....
 
Just a note.. I'll be gone tomorrow morning, back in the afternoon.
 
Zaffy said:
I don't really have anything other than Jpappy.

If you (kash) are the Scum journalist, then you're the best player by far this game. I think you're innocent. Same goes for Annie and DD, they've also been really helpful to the town all game long imo.

That leaves Zsand, Noodles, TRS, Ogre, and me.

If I'm the scum journalist, then I'll go down as the worst in history. I hope I'm smarter than that. I think I've played pretty poorly this game because I don't talk good at words sometimes.

I don't know about Zsand, noodles, or Ogre.
Click to expand...

can you justify this comment please? Seems like you have them pretty high on your list and I would like to see what you are seeing.....


What?!?!?!? (Simple Jack?!?!?)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom