Mafia 59 - MAFIA WARS - The Play

What I said is also different than what you said. The whole point was you didn't sound so joking about Rich...you specifically said if you were the mod you might give Rich the role and that you were "game" if you didn't find another suspect. That's not random at all (as I have said), and not really a joke either since you there could be something behind the theory, even though you continue to play it off as such. I'm confused what is so joking about joining in lynching a player that didn't do anything concrete to merit the votes. You alluded to that your final vote would be there ("if push comes to shove") and since you wanted to join in the fun, I assume that means you wanted to join in with other people who may have voted for Rich? Why would you want to jump on a train as a joke, Ice? Unless you're keeping to your story (that the whole post was a joke) please explain what exactly you did mean so I don't make the mistake of believing what I just said if it is not correct.

You're also exaggerating what I said. It was one post, after my initial vote, where I questioned your logic. I have yet to use it against you yet you say I jumped on you...I get a sense that you're almost trying to blow this out of proportion.

All that post said was if I didn't find a suspect worthy of lynching that my random pick would be Rich on the off chance that Dawg did use his name as a cover for a Mafia Boss. Day 1 is as random as it gets if there is no clear choice so why not Rich for that reason?

If I had wanted to vote Rich I would have voted then. I didn't and instead looked for a real suspect, or actually had 1 fall into my lap.
 
I agree that anyone that lists players as suspects then votes for a totally different player is suspect themselves.



Jpap, again you are welcome to your opinion. To me it looks like you are trying to back track now. You placed a vote on me then leaned on me throughout the day cycle. I'm just calling it as I see it. If you think I'm blowing this out of proportion you are mistaken. I'm taking what I think is the most solid case for a Day 1 and being thorough.

No back tracking at all, and I have no idea what would give you that feeling. I leaned on you as much as you have leaned on me...we keep quoting each other and responding so I don't see how that incriminates me at all. Other than my last post I've been pretty neutral in my responses, more than you have to me. So you keep saying that I am somehow pushing for you...

All that post said was if I didn't find a suspect worthy of lynching that my random pick would be Rich on the off chance that Dawg did use his name as a cover for a Mafia Boss. Day 1 is as random as it gets if there is no clear choice so why not Rich for that reason?

If I had wanted to vote Rich I would have voted then. I didn't and instead looked for a real suspect, or actually had 1 fall into my lap.

Which then I argued it really wasn't random at all, seeing as you just gave a specific reason for him possibly being mafia. I've said countless times that there is a disagreement over what is random as apparently you view the situation differently. At this point I again am leaning towards the fact that you're not really thinking like an innocent.

What would be the point in voting Rich at that time anyways? Everyone knew JL was joking but my point was it seemed as if you tested the water to see if it could potentially be a legitimate place to put your vote. Again I questioned what you said, mainly because I didn't fully understand what you meant, and you responded as if I was all over you.
 
well boys and girls - I must tend to the dirty kitchen and then shower before our "Superstar Pres" (:barf:) makes his speech, that just so happens to effect my military sons.... but I will be back by nightfall.
 
What would be the point in voting Rich at that time anyways? Everyone knew JL was joking but my point was it seemed as if you tested the water to see if it could potentially be a legitimate place to put your vote. Again I questioned what you said, mainly because I didn't fully understand what you meant, and you responded as if I was all over you.


So by saying I'm going to vote Rich if no better suspects appear that is supposedly my way to see if I could get a train going on him? Seriously?

How is what I said any different then when someone says I'm going to vote for the 1st person to role play or the last person to post?


You might not call it pushing but you keep me in the spotlight hoping for a bite. I'm keeping the pressure on you because I think I have a case. You have admitted you don't but yet keep harping on it instead of looking or questioning others.

By reading Day 1 posts can anyone tell me who Jpap thinks is the best suspect to vote for?
 
I vote to lynch Luv....

..simply for the fact it has been pretty routine to do so in several of the last games.

Odd that rb, who is known for tying it up, did not tie it up when given a chance.
 
(eeerrrrmmmm, Mods, please delete my previous post if needed. I had "a moment" due to my current mood.Sorry.) :o


Carry on!
 
Part of me really wants to vote for frog...
 
Odd that rb, who is known for tying it up, did not tie it up when given a chance.

It is Night one....no need to tie things up....random is going it's course.
 
AquariaCentral.com