Mafia #6.....The Play

[Madcrawdad]

I'm less sure of jpappy.

Mad, I'm curious as to what you think of my list. Do you believe it is fairly accurate?

Do you mean Sploke, Plantling, Swayde, BKW, Jensons, and JohnLarson?

Although the clue that 'Bala looks toward sunrise when he's always looked toward sunset' could imply the mafia heading home after a hard night's work (although I agree with Plantling that townie power players work at night also), I find it hard to believe that the snitch would give 3 mafia on one list. I also find it harder to believe that rb would submarine nearly half the mafia team with that clue. It does make them all look equally guilty...

-Sploke mumbles, and appears to head off with a little spring in his step
-BKW looks at his PDA (a device which stores data and communicates with others)
-Jensons sits calmly on a bench and watches as the town flushes itself down the toilet (implying that she may not care about the town?)

Problem is, I think I'm starting to read way too much into these things. Call me hypocritical for saying that I believe rb when he implies that I'm innocent, but alot of the other clues are really ambiguous.

 

[OgreMkV]

sploke and plantling say we need cohesiveness and then vote to lynch DP who has no other votes... why not lynch sway... she's got plenty... or nick, the two of you could swing the vote to his favor. Why not, because you're all mafia.

I was thinking DP, but now, I think he might be the innocent target of a mafia train. You want cohesiveness... it's already out there, but you aren't voting for it.

 

[Sploke]

I remove my vote for swayde and vote to lynch nichmcmechan.

While I don't like DP, the lack of posting makes me think he/she just doesn't care. If DP was mafia, I feel like the mafia would have jumped on the train to get DP lynched....it would have worked as a great distancing tactic, if they all helped to lynch a mafia.

Nick on the other hand, seems to have a handle on the game, then almost a week into it starts saying things like "i'm so confused about this" or "i'm still a newb give me a break". It works in the beginning, but once you've shown an understanding you don't get to go back and use that excuse. Then, he started jumping all over JL as soon as his name was brought up. Its not so much the attack, but his reasoning was "he's not postiing, he's probably hiding because he's guilty." This, after jl posting repeatedly that he's traveling who knows where and has limited access to a computer. Of course he's not going to post much, he told us that. Several times. Flawed logic IMO. In any case, the flow of his posting doesn't make any sense to me and I think its because he's mafia.

 

[OgreMkV]

I disagree...

1) we were never supposed to get two sets of names... just one set of four.
2) we're getting our rears handed to us on a silver platter.
3) try not to analyze too much... that, I think, is where most of us get messed up. Over thinking, when it's really much simpler than we make it out to be.

Random thoughts:

Is sway a sacrificial lamb? Or is she telling the truth and she's innocent. If my picks are correct then they're sacrificing her... I don't really buy that.

I think the mafia are trying for a clean sweep... all of us for none of them.

I bet rb is laughing HIS rear off right now.

JO, I see you and Z are on... what do you think of my analysis of rb's posts.

 

[Sploke]

sploke and plantling say we need cohesiveness and then vote to lynch DP who has no other votes... why not lynch sway... she's got plenty... or nick, the two of you could swing the vote to his favor. Why not, because you're all mafia.

I was thinking DP, but now, I think he might be the innocent target of a mafia train. You want cohesiveness... it's already out there, but you aren't voting for it.

Ogre I explained this. I DID vote for swayde, pay attention. I didn't vote for DP, I never have in this game. I posted about 24 hours ago, we had two candidates between swayde and nick. I just switched from swayde to nick. You're the one bringing new candidates into the voting (i.e. me). I don't know what else I can do, my actions seem to agree with your theories and you're still calling me out on it. I don't know if you're not seeing it or just ignoring it because you want me out regardless.

 

[OgreMkV]

sploke, right sorry, that was plantling ans jpappy doing that.

I admit to being less sure of nick than I am about the others. Here's my reasoning.

We know that the snitch was supposed to give us a list. Everyone hated my initial plan that everyone on the list was mafia... So, I rethought it and came up with just plantling. I know no one else will vote for her now, so I looked at the second list and proposed you.

Sploke, the only other thing that would make sense is that you are the detective and found something out. Since you've changed your vote, I think that maybe you didn't find anything out, but instead are mafia, pleased with the turn of events.

Unfortunately, you are my most likely candidate at this time.

Look, the mafia have played a nearly perfect game so far. They have been relatively quiet, only putting forth ideas that others are thinking and supporting the status quo.

Either I'm right or I'm wrong. Believe me or not. I'll cast my vote with the majority holder from my list as we go. Let me know what you guys want to do...

 

[Dangerdoll]

did john larosn just make a boob and give himself away as mafia with a slip of the tongue?

at this point only the mafia are a "we"

mad, you have a lot of argument and create a lot of trouble...if you are a townie your making yourself look like mafia

Completely disagree...I'm sure people playing the game will agree with me. The vote that matters is the one you've got cast when rb calls 'night'. You trying something there, Nick 'ol boy?

please note that johnlarson has not replied to my assault on his slip of the tongue...what does that tell you guys?

i can see he is viewing the thread

listen i'm just a newb to this

ok here, it looks to me as all of a sudden, we have another member freaking out and trying to off the blame on other people because soemthing happened. I'm think Nick is Mafia and started freaking and posting wildly, accusing and twisting words just because Swayde was in the lead..... As much as swayde has been in my suspicion, and this just justifies it.... I vote to lynch Swayde

 

[Coler]

boo

*sigh*

 

[ZSandmann]

Good Morning all, I hate to post a hit and run but I'm hosting a Wii Party tonight and have to go pick up the party trays.

Ogre: Leans Innocent to me. He is not at all like he was when he was Mafia before, he is posting and being very helpful. I think the Mafia are doing a really good job of playing the experienced players off one another.

Mad: Ditto my Ogre sentiment.

I disappointed in how the votes went overnight. There are currently six lynch candidates and I attribute that to Mafia persuasion. We can not win the vote if we spread out over many people, they have 7 votes and if even three candidates are even close then they have the power to flop us. Look at the votes that have fallen off Sway! That to me is very telling. I'll post my stats but then I have to run, I don't know when I can get back on again but will try. As far as the RB/Snitch list. I think its pretty useless, I mean it gives us some logic info but as a hit list it stinks. And I don't think RB would purposely give clues, he is usually very careful not to reveal too much. Just my opinion. sploke has rung true the whole game to me, I've seen no Mafianess, but no one is above investigation and I am not perfect this round at picking the Mob obviously.

Here the current votes:
Day 4: 12/17
Swayde: 3 -- Zsandmann (1343) johnlarson66 (1407) KOTD (1417) sploke (1436) Ogre (1440) Plantling (1549) Ogre (1555)
Nickmcmehan: 5 -- Charlie_Stubbs (1366) MadCrawdad (1413) joander123 (1437) mee-mee (1475) sploke (1603)
Zsandmann: 1 -- Swayde (1412)
Johnlarson66:1 -- Madcrawdad (1322) nickmcmehan (1446)
Sploke: 2 -- Ogre (1558) Madcrawdad (1551)
Dwarf Puffers: 2 -- johnlarson66 (1404) jpappy (1596) Plantling (1598)
Ogre: 0 -- Swayde (1333) Plantling (1585)
MadCrawdad: 0 -- Ogre (1521)
Jpappy789: Zsandmann (1332)

Here's my current list:

--MAFIA—
Nickmcmechan -2
Swayde -2
bkw1982 -3
Mee-mee -3
jpappy789 -4
johnlarson66 -4
joander123 -4
Dwarf Puffers -5
Plantling -6
KingOfTheDeep -6
Dangerdoll -6
OgreMkV -6
Sploke -7
Madcrawdad -7
Jensons -7
Charlie_stubbs -7
Zsandmann – 10
Cory Lover – Dead Night 3
IceH2O –DOCTOR Dead Night 3
Clown-lover – Dead Night 2
Judgemax – Dead Night 2
Hooked Newbie – Dead Night 2
MikenDanielle – Dead Night 2
Coler – Dead Night 1
--INNOCENT--

 

[OgreMkV]

I vote to lynch Swayde