Mafia #6.....The Play

[FireDancer7905]

How does voting for judge help the town? If too many people jump on that train, then go to bed, then she posts, we may lose a valuable townie. I am hesitant to throw in for mike, he seems to just be a real, real big newb. Maybe he's just read one to many crime novels. But, i dunno. I'm not feeling much of a case for Swayde or DP either, but my feelings proved to be pretty useless last game. I'm holding off voting until later tonight. ~brandy

 

[Hooked Newbie]

OMG! Am I the only one that can't get on this site at work?! Judging by the last page it seems like there's been alot going on. I'm off to start reading... I'll post my thoughts and reasoning for everyone a bit later.

 

[Sploke]

I like the plan to vote for judge max. I'm going to join the vote for her right now, and hopefully I'll be able to come back later tonight to check if she has posted.

Mike is still my top pick for mafia though, but if we can avoid lynching a possible innocent for someone who will be booted anyway, thats fine with me. Who knows, maybe JM will be mafia and we'll get a lucky break anyway.

 

[Madcrawdad]

Current Votes

Day 1: 16/24 Votes Cast Night @ 4AM Tuesday
IceH2O: 2 -Hooked Newbie (69) nickmcmechan(170)
MikenDanielle: 5 – IceH2O (82) clown-lover (123) Charlie_stubbs (124) Corey Lover (227) Dwarf Puffers (272)
Swayde: 3 – johnlarson66 (161) MadCrawdad (174) joander123 (190)
Dwarf Puffer: 2 – jpappy789 (162) Ogre (165)
JudgeMax: 4- Zsandmann (189) Coler (290) MikenDanielle (292) Swayde (293)

Kind of funny, but did anybody notice how MikenDanielle and Swayde (who were the top 2 vote getters at the time) JUMPED at the chance to vote for JudgeMax?

 

[Sploke]

How does voting for judge help the town? If too many people jump on that train, then go to bed, then she posts, we may lose a valuable townie.

The idea would be to vote for her, and stay up late to check and see if she posts later or not. Its a chance, but if there's greater than a 33% chance she'll get booted from the game, its a better gamble than a random vote for someone, regardless of whether she's innocent or not.

 

[Sploke]

Oh yeah lets make it official for now

I vote to lynch judgemax.

 

[Coler]

Oooooooooooookay *yawn* done some work on this game now.

Here is my list of mafia candidates; I have a good feeling about it. I suggest that the detective investigate the first on the list and the mayor the second and if I'm right on both we may have four of them, but, that's for you both to decide. No particular order to these

1. Madcrawdad
2. Sploke
3. Swayde
4. Clown-Lover

I don't know about Mike...but I'm feeling sorta weak about him as mafia at the moment. Happy to let my vote sit on Judgemax until we hear what she has to say. It would be donnish behaviour to sit back this long...but we'll see.

I reckon they hit me tonight folks have a go at the list if they do and see how you do.

 

[ZSandmann]

How does voting for judge help the town? If too many people jump on that train, then go to bed, then she posts, we may lose a valuable townie. I am hesitant to throw in for mike, he seems to just be a real, real big newb. Maybe he's just read one to many crime novels. But, i dunno. I'm not feeling much of a case for Swayde or DP either, but my feelings proved to be pretty useless last game. I'm holding off voting until later tonight. ~brandy

My thinking was this. rb will kill any player that doesn't vote. We aren't real sure of who to lynch on day 1 and using past games as reference, we've never been right. So why lynch an Innocent, the Mafia Hit an Innocent, AND lose JM anyway due to her not posting? That would be three Innocent possibly lost in Night 1! If we instead lynch JM there is a chance she is Mafia but even if she were Innocent as stands she is marked for death anyway. We save ourselves losing an extra Innocent. I'm not saving we HAVe to do this, it is just good logic though in my opinion.

Kind of funny, but did anybody notice how MikenDanielle and Swayde (who were the top 2 vote getters at the time) JUMPED at the chance to vote for JudgeMax?

I noticed, but also you to think if you were in there spot you'd do about anything not to be voted off Innocent or not. Not clearing them but just keeping it all in my mind.

 

[Coler]

ok for the moment I'm happy to put the list at, generally in no particular order :

Madcrawdad
Swayde
Sploke
Clown Lover
Judgemax

Judgemax being the weakest of those 5

 

[MikenDanielle]

Kind of funny, but did anybody notice how MikenDanielle and Swayde (who were the top 2 vote getters at the time) JUMPED at the chance to vote for JudgeMax?

Kind of funny, but did anybody notice how Madcrawdad looks so deep into things that they no longer make anysense. I am sorry if you can not see the logic behind voting for Judgemax, I truely feel sorry for you.