Mafia #6.....The Play

sploke said:
Z, Ice is second on your list of suspected mafia but you think he's an innocent? Explain please.
Click to expand...

No I don't think he is Innocent. The way I meant for that to sound was that the Mafia would pick one of the four, which would be an Innocent. I listed us four as I think we are the most vocal with no weight on who is what. Obviously if Ice IS Mafia they wouldn't pick him. Sorry that does look ambigous reading it back.
 
sploke said:
Z, Ice is second on your list of suspected mafia but you think he's an innocent? Explain please.
Click to expand...

The mafia would not hit one of its own members, except maybe their own Don after they were out of investigations, which is highly unlikely.

I can say this, Day Three is going to be very interesting.
 
johnlarson66 said:
If the Vigilante is mafia, are they counted in with the mafia?

This could change the odds even more.
Click to expand...
My understanding after asking for clarification last round is that the Vig is Innocent but can play the game how ever they choose, IE may kill an Innocent OR Mafia.
 
charlie_stubbs said:
nick this statement alarms me. are you saying you think he's guilty or innocent?
Click to expand...
Heres my theory.

There is much confusion, but there is one certainty, certain players have taken advantage of Mike putting his head on the block from the start. Look at who's attacked him later in day one and into day two.

If this guy is innocent we will find out by lynching him, that then points the finger at several players who are mafia. We need to take this risk early on in the game before the mafia has a better ratio.

We then know who to lynch. I've noticd since I posted my last couple of statements about Mike my 'likelihood' of being mafia has went up in the ranks....i think mafia are becoming worried about my theories now....why?...are they trying to save mike?

We'll find out when we lynch mikey boy!

I have another theory. There are incredible number of posts...good tactic by mafia to throw us off the scent by making the game dificult to follow. Look for multiple posters.
 
I will read more on that later. Maybe rbishop can explain.

I thought last time the vigilante was assigned to be innocent, was KOTD the vigilante last time, maybe he can clairfy this, if allowed.

I would understand if the town or the mafia did not know who they were and which side they were on. If they are assigned mafia, then are they accounted for.

If they get to choose, who would be against the town? I think they are assigned. But it did say "Total Wild Card"
 
The rules that Johnlarson posted clearly show the Vigilante can be either Innocent or Mafia and strike at either. I understand that it's 17 people are Innocent, 7 are Mafia...out of that 7 Mafia 1 is the Don, 1 could be a Vigilante, 1 is the Snitch....and out of the 17 Innocent 1 is the Doc, 1 is the Detective, 1 could be Vigilante.
 
nickmcmechan said:
I have another theory. There are incredible number of posts...good tactic by mafia to throw us off the scent by making the game dificult to follow. Look for multiple posters.
Click to expand...

I disagree, posting is how we learn. The more posts the better. Well not personal attacks and insane stuff. I am not a big fan of the role playing, but have never thought of it as a mafia tactic.

I am more weary of those that do not post much than those that post lots. I think if you read the first three games you will see the town lynched every vocal person very quickly and most were innocent.

There are lots of people playing and there are going to be lots of posts. Most of us that have played are certainly "into it". I feel bad for Coler that he just has to watch, I know he is dying to play. I would hate to die on the first few days.

Posting is good for the town.
 
johnlarson66 said:
I disagree, posting is how we learn. The more posts the better. Well not personal attacks and insane stuff. I am not a big fan of the role playing, but have never thought of it as a mafia tactic.

I am more weary of those that do not post much than those that post lots. I think if you read the first three games you will see the town lynched every vocal person very quickly and most were innocent.

There are lots of people playing and there are going to be lots of posts. Most of us that have played are certainly "into it". I feel bad for Coler that he just has to watch, I know he is dying to play. I would hate to die on the first few days.

Posting is good for the town.
Click to expand...
you would say that - you post a lot
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom