Mafia #6.....The Play
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
Alright, now that I see JM will not get the boot, it does not make sense to vote for her. I know its going to seem like a throwaway vote right now, but I don't want anyone to lose sight of Ice. I know he's been mentioned on a few lists, but I feel like, just like the first vote last game, this mafia is running a train on mike. I do get funny feelings from him, but I just don't think he's mafia. I also disagree ith Ice's evaluation to leave in good players regardless of loyalty. If a player is suspected mafia, we should get rid of them. We shouldn't hold on to them because they're good...thats just more reason to get rid of them sooner. The known good players are going to have a much easier time leading people in the wrong direction . So, its not that only mafia should fear good players...if the good players are mafia, we should fear them even more and respond accordingly. That excuse for himself really tipped my meter and I'm hoping we're not going to let it slide too far down the list. Anyway, I'm exhausted, so I'm done.
I retract my vote for judgemax and vote to lynch Ice.
I retract my vote for judgemax and vote to lynch Ice.
Sploke you're twisting my words.
What I said is to investigate the top players. That though was before I realized the Don comes up innocent and we don't have a mayor so the only investigations done are by the Detective. Rb really swung the pendulum in this game.
I retract my statement because it makes zero sense with only 1 person able to investigate.
The statement was made thinking 2 people a night could be investigated. Therefore checking out the top people would make more sense. As mafia my plan was to take out Coler, he was innocent and my biggest fear, didn't even bother investigating him. KOTD was the 1st investigation you were 2nd. IMO you 3 were the top players not on my side. I lucked out in that you 2 had power roles which I was hoping you did. Just was hoping 1 was Dr.
Like I said, Mafia wants top players out. But without multiple investigations on our part its going to be hard to clear any innocents. You're just going to have to go with your gut this round.If your gut says me then go with it. Unless you're mafia then you don't need the gut check, you already know.
What I said is to investigate the top players. That though was before I realized the Don comes up innocent and we don't have a mayor so the only investigations done are by the Detective. Rb really swung the pendulum in this game.
I retract my statement because it makes zero sense with only 1 person able to investigate.
The statement was made thinking 2 people a night could be investigated. Therefore checking out the top people would make more sense. As mafia my plan was to take out Coler, he was innocent and my biggest fear, didn't even bother investigating him. KOTD was the 1st investigation you were 2nd. IMO you 3 were the top players not on my side. I lucked out in that you 2 had power roles which I was hoping you did. Just was hoping 1 was Dr.
Like I said, Mafia wants top players out. But without multiple investigations on our part its going to be hard to clear any innocents. You're just going to have to go with your gut this round.If your gut says me then go with it. Unless you're mafia then you don't need the gut check, you already know.
Lets see if I can make any sense of all this...
Mad-suspect because jumped to jm's defense even though everybody ended up realizing that the reason sucked. Still was very quick to defend...
JM- suspect because she's not posting, makes some sense but not enough for day 1
Mike-obvious reasons already stated, but I am not sure
Who else? It's hard to sit and read 100 posts without missing even more, but I'm trying my best...ow my eyes hurt...
Mad-suspect because jumped to jm's defense even though everybody ended up realizing that the reason sucked. Still was very quick to defend...
JM- suspect because she's not posting, makes some sense but not enough for day 1
Mike-obvious reasons already stated, but I am not sure
Who else? It's hard to sit and read 100 posts without missing even more, but I'm trying my best...ow my eyes hurt...
Oh I forgot to add...I retract my vote for dwarf puffer
Too much stuff has come up and I believe that even if dp is mafia, which I don't think so, there are much better candidates...
Too much stuff has come up and I believe that even if dp is mafia, which I don't think so, there are much better candidates...
Oh and to make myself clear that's not my list, those are just the names of people who kept popping up in recent posts, and I needed to think outloud and see if people can explain why...
No JM is not a suspect. At least not one of mine. She could be Mafia, but them again anyone could be. My hypothesis for voting JM was to prevent having to vote blindly on Night 1.
I retract my Mike vote and vote to lynch Mad
To many people piled onto Mike, obvious mafia votes. Ogre made me a bit uneasy claiming he'd rather take a chance on voting out a mafia player and losing JM to untimely death. Why chance losing 3 innocents in one night?
I think Ogre might be Mafia but don't take this as fact.
Why do i think he might be? Ogre continually preaches against trains.Yet he jumped on one. Why not put a vote on another suspect and see if it garnishes any attention? He doesn't care if JM gets an untimely death, could know she is innocent and wants 3 innocents gone.
Didn't even touch the list Coler posted, no words of wisdom for us about Mad? What are your thoughts Ogre about Mads posts of mafia guilt to Mike but vote on Sway?
To many people piled onto Mike, obvious mafia votes. Ogre made me a bit uneasy claiming he'd rather take a chance on voting out a mafia player and losing JM to untimely death. Why chance losing 3 innocents in one night?
I think Ogre might be Mafia but don't take this as fact.
Why do i think he might be? Ogre continually preaches against trains.Yet he jumped on one. Why not put a vote on another suspect and see if it garnishes any attention? He doesn't care if JM gets an untimely death, could know she is innocent and wants 3 innocents gone.
Didn't even touch the list Coler posted, no words of wisdom for us about Mad? What are your thoughts Ogre about Mads posts of mafia guilt to Mike but vote on Sway?
Since the rule has been clarified and voting for Judgemax is risking targeting an Innocent (that is not on her deathbed) I am going to withdraw my vote for Judgemax and vote for No One at this time.
My suspicions still fall onto MadCrawdad and Johnlarson66 and I believe that Mike is just flustered and overwhelmed and that there are too many people too eager to see him gone for him to really be Mafia.
My suspicions still fall onto MadCrawdad and Johnlarson66 and I believe that Mike is just flustered and overwhelmed and that there are too many people too eager to see him gone for him to really be Mafia.
Keep in mind that the only reason Mad voted Sway was because Sway used a revenge vote on Jl for voting for her. No other explanation/reason. But he has numerous posts on Mikes mafia guilt.
