Mafia #6.....The Play
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
.Coler was the first person to vocally believe you to be Mafia...he's dead and Innocent. MikenDanielle was going after you, he's dead and Innocent. Hooked Newbie suspected you, another dead Innocent.
I've already stated what I believe to be Coler's reasoning for suspecting me. Mike suspected me because Coler supected me. And HN suspected me because Coler pointed me out also (I believe at one point HN even posted a list IDENTICAL to Coler's, after Coler posted his list...I might be wrong on that, though, but I'm not digging through 1000+ posts to see). Mike really made his own bed, so I'm not going to say much about that.
Let me explain something. The mafia want to cause confusion among the townies. What better way to do that than 'hit' someone who has posted flawed logic. Bam, Coler gone. Then townies (with a few mafia saying 'Madcrawdad, madcrawdad....') run this way. Next, Hooked Newbie is jumping up and down frothing at the mouth, screaming 'Madcrawdad.' Bam, Hooked Newbie gone.... Townies run that way. Now the snitch even names me? It's really getting pretty amusing, actually. What a perfect way for the mafia to telegraph the identity of one of their members.....hit the 1st person who names him, hit another person who names him, and then name him themselves on the snitch list. It's brilliant. NOT!
How can you dare say that I am not sticking my neck out by sticking with my suspicion on you?
Pretty sure you're safe....why don't you go ahead and pull those shutters closed, and sit in your house and look for mafia? I think there's probably a mirror in your bathroom...
Charlie... I noticed that post about the snitch as well. Just more reassurance my vote is in the right place. Here's something to consider. When people choose to ignore the obvious, and act like they're playing with blinders on, I'm not the only one who becomes suspicious of them...
Ogre is #2 man on my list. I still think that him and Mad are in cohoots with each other. BTW. I listed some pretty good reasons for voting for Mad on post #1009
None of that was addressed. I would have especially liked to see the explanation for the invisible mode posting and then taking it off. MikenDanielle also noticed this.
As far as invisible mode, I've been in invisible mode since my first mafia game. Anyone who has been in a mafia game as an innocent and had to hear 'so-and-so has been sitting on the thread all day and not posted, they must be mafia,' will probably agree, it's a distraction. Since I frequently visit the mafia thread throughout the day, it's just easier to stay viewing the thread and hit refresh as I walk by the laptop. Since this is the first game that I can recall where folks have really made an issue of whose watching the thread, I've decided to reappear. Being invisible was now just as big of a distraction as parking on the thread all day.
As for the snitch. I believe they are trying to help the town and I believe they did so by giving us a very obvious Mafia member to lynch so we can even up the playing field a bit without giving away any new Mafia info and making themselves more of a mark. :y220e:, People who keep saying that the snitch is playing for the town are highly suspect. RB clearly states that the snitch is mafia. The snitch doesn't win the game if the mafia doesn't win the game. RB is forcing the snitch to give up a name....I truly doubt the snitch has any reason to want to submarine the mafia.
One thing I've noticed about Mad, he likes to make accusations against proven Innocents, and those I suspect to be Innocent. Never said Coler was mafia (said he was protecting one he thought to be mafia), never said Hooked Newbie was mafia (actually briefly defended him for a second, until somebody pointed out an error in my facts), and Mike has himself to thank for being lynched.
Time will tell. I see no point in voting for anyone else at this time since I am just not as convinced about anyone else, just strong suspicions, like Ogre, DP, Jpap...I am going to be doing some reviewing today of Mike & HN to see if I can find anything there that might help give me more solid convictions about other potential Mafia.
Glad you saw that one too, Ice. Caught it here, but didn't want to mention it and be accused of trying to sway the town..
I don't think the Mafia game really works with this many.... There are almost 1000 posts I haven't read...
So you say you're going to quit, then vote, then admit you've actually only read about 10% of the actual game? How does that work? I guess its easy when you already know who's who.
OgreMkV
Father of Earth's Next Emperor
I like the mee-mee planting infomation. I'd almost be willing to vote for Mad after Charlie's vote... maybe it's not Mad and Ogre working together, but Mad and Ice?
I can see what you're saying charlie, but since the real damning evidence is
recent, what was the info at the time?
In fact, let's see what happens... I vote to lynch Madcrawdad
BTW: Doc, I may need you tonigh.
I can see what you're saying charlie, but since the real damning evidence is
recent, what was the info at the time?
In fact, let's see what happens... I vote to lynch Madcrawdad
BTW: Doc, I may need you tonigh.
Fair enough but with seven Mafia they are probably scattered over everything.
Nice 180, Ogre.....It wouldn't really be a mafia game if you didn't come after me at some point, would it?
