Mafia #6.....The Play

Madcrawdad said:
As mafia I like:

Ogre - for reasons listed earlier

Plantling - She's been whispering in my ear for the past 2 days trying her best to get Jensons and KOTD lynched. After I voted Nick on Day 4, Plantling jumped off another vote (DP maybe?) and hopped on Nick with me. On Day 5 when I voted Swayde she immediately followed. As soon as I mentioned Ogre yesterday, though, she hems and haws a little and offers up Jensons again. I think as the Ogre train is building steam, the mafia are distancing and she's now coming on board...

Sploke - mainly because Plantling has been so bent on getting Jensons lynched. I think that the mafia, however, has been VERY effective in distancing themselves this game, so could still be Jensons.

Jpappy or JohnLarson - I've always kind of thought JPappy could be mafia, and I did like JL66 until Ogre did, too (but maybe he's just distancing with a JL66 vote). I'd prefer to lynch one of them (JP or JL) last.

Like I said in an earlier post, if DD is mafia, I think we're down to 8 townies v 4 mafia at this point. If we find out otherwise and are still alive, I'll give another pick.

Swayde, I know that you think that all townies should follow you (and mee-mee and Z) since you're innocent. That fact doesn't make you correct, though. RBishop all but confirms the fact that I'm innocent, too. I really hope you'll consider.
Click to expand...

I don't understand Mad, I do believe you are Innocent. I also am starting to be convinced that Ogre is as well, because of RB's hints. And why would you want to save the known mafia for last when we can get them out and make the odds a lot better for townies so that another night when the candidates are not as clear cut and dry if a mistake is made, it won't be game over. Face it, Z, Mee-Mee and me are going to be taken out by mafia to help muddy the waters, so all the finger pointing and uncertainty can begin all over again.
 
Swayde said:
I don't understand Mad, I do believe you are Innocent. I also am starting to be convinced that Ogre is as well, because of RB's hints. And why would you want to save the known mafia for last when we can get them out and make the odds a lot better for townies so that another night when the candidates are not as clear cut and dry if a mistake is made, it won't be game over. Face it, Z, Mee-Mee and me are going to be taken out by mafia to help muddy the waters, so all the finger pointing and uncertainty can begin all over again.
Click to expand...

On Day 4, Z knew that you and Nick were mafia. That actually helped me make my decision to vote Nick as I liked the way he was jumping around on the hotseat. Actually made my decision easier, as Z said one of you were mafia, and Z is a good player, I could vote either Swade or Nick and still hit mafia....Woo-hoo, we got one FOR SURE. Nope, we were wrong.

With that said, I just feel better about Ogre than JL at this point.
 
Madcrawdad said:
On Day 4, Z knew that you and Nick were mafia. That actually helped me make my decision to vote Nick as I liked the way he was jumping around on the hotseat. Actually made my decision easier, as Z said one of you were mafia, and Z is a good player, I could vote either Swade or Nick and still hit mafia....Woo-hoo, we got one FOR SURE. Nope, we were wrong.

With that said, I just feel better about Ogre than JL at this point.
Click to expand...


And on Day 5, until BKW came out with his Detective notes it was going to be either me or Zsandman, both Innocents, because everyone was so sure (including Z & me) that we were right. We got played...all of the Innocents did. It's been that way all along....look at Ice. Ogre's not a sure thing IMO. There is a chance he's Mafia, but it's slim if I am reading RB's hint right. You said you believe JL is Mafia, so why take an unnecessary chance? Especially a chance that could cost the game. I really don't follow your line of logic in thinking JM was the Don, she quit the game and died of mysterious illness. I guess it's possible, but I really think Mee-Mee did hit DD as the Don and I think the clues by RB are highly convincing on that matter. We HAVE to err on the side of caution and proceed with the understanding that it's 7-5 and a mistake will cost us the game.
 
I am tempted to go watch a movie to pass time, but I don't think my mind can focus on anything but this game right now. I am well and truly addicted :P
 
Swayde said:
And on Day 5, until BKW came out with his Detective notes it was going to be either me or Zsandman, both Innocents, because everyone was so sure (including Z & me) that we were right. We got played...all of the Innocents did. It's been that way all along....look at Ice. Ogre's not a sure thing IMO. There is a chance he's Mafia, but it's slim if I am reading RB's hint right. You said you believe JL is Mafia, so why take an unnecessary chance? Especially a chance that could cost the game. I really don't follow your line of logic in thinking JM was the Don, she quit the game and died of mysterious illness. I guess it's possible, but I really think Mee-Mee did hit DD as the Don and I think the clues by RB are highly convincing on that matter. We HAVE to err on the side of caution and proceed with the understanding that it's 7-5 and a mistake will cost us the game.
Click to expand...

You'll notice I still haven't switched my vote off of JohnLarson66....Like I said, we either win it as a town, or blow it sky-high as a town. At least promise me that If we're still alive tomorrow (regardless of JL66's status) that you'll consider...

On a side note, this game's really gotten good, hasn't it? Just 2 days ago I thought we could be headed for the most lopsided townie loss in AC history... nice to know that we at least nailed 2 (although if DD is mafia, I say 3, even though nobody believes me).

Does anyone know the current vote tally?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom