Mafia 62- The Play

Oops, forgot to address my other 2 quotes there.

Ice, I thought that statement is pretty bold, Mafia vote mafia all the time.

Dawg, what if Noodles put all the scum on that list, so when one came up scum we'd lessen our view of the rest.
 
I'm pretty sure that a mafia wouldn't have piled on to Noods and risk losing her even for distancing when they had 2 innocents to climb on instead.


I already explained why I made that statement Zaffy McSkimmer.
 
I'm pretty sure that a mafia wouldn't have piled on to Noods and risk losing her even for distancing when they had 2 innocents to climb on instead.

Get out your tinfoil hats.
tinfoil-hat.jpg


Stephen King is the reason I suspected noodles. In a previous game Annie asked a question about the dark tower series. So I'm not drinking any fluoridated water under the assuption that Annie chose his mafia team out of members of his book club.

I hid this info from everyone because frankly I was embarrased to even think it. But, with noodles coming up scum it's something to wonder about
.

Is that contrived enough for you?

I vote to lynch Zsandmann.

Ok so Annie the Mod

Noods we know is scum

Z I know read SK as he admitted it.

Who are the rest of the book club Zaffy?

Has to be more then 2 mafia.
 
Ok so Annie the Mod

Noods we know is scum

Z I know read SK as he admitted it.

Who are the rest of the book club Zaffy?

Has to be more then 2 mafia.

That's another part of why I wanted to keep it to myself and see what happens. I don't know the other 2.
 
As I said prior, Razz is my number one mafia suspect. He was trying to lay low and go with the town. When he got called out by Ice for lack of any ideas to help the town, I'd bet someone in the scum den told him he better post something with some semblence of original thought. These thoughts named 4 he thought for mafia. He put me in the unsure category, yet did not retract his vote. He knew I would show innocent and wanted to be able to say that he really wasn't sure. Also, he claimed Noods innocent. Rich was claimed to be mafia. Now his most recent post/theory he is trying to align himself with Rich. Nice try Razz, but the whole thing left me :rofl: His list was so vastly different than mine that it shifted him from not sure to leaning mafia.
I don't get how I didn't see that. I just couldn't see the argument about noods...... I have to rethink my list. Also, was Rich getting to something? Why would the mafia hit him? It didn't really stop any suspicions, right? I have to look through his posts and see if he was hinting at something.
idk Razz, could you not have suspected Noods because she was the one coaching you? Also, I totally don't understand the hit on Rich...why did you guys think he was a threat?


In regards to the snitch's list, i think it's highly likely that at least 2, if not more, on that list are mafia. I think Noods was trying to protect them by putting them on the list. Surely when she showed mafia and was on the list then she would have been the only mafia on the list, right??? I'm sure that was her hope, but Ice already pointed that out and I agree very much with that possibility.

My list, in order of most suspect at this time:
Razz
Dawg-moved up due to his flub and the fact he keeps insisting Ice is mafia. I am still not sure what to think of Ice, except that I still think he's being framed. I also happen to agree with Ice's theories and logic for the most part.
Michwol-pretty sure you were coached, really need to hear more from you

I vote to lynch Razz
 
Checking in before work. My top 3 in no order.

Mich
JL
Razz

Admittedly, I have not had much time the last few days. I'm hoping to be able to go through and find more concrete evidence later on.
 
Zaffy, I don't like the tinfoil conspiracy. The main reason I don't think it's valid is that Annie has commented several times from the debate about random vs handpicked roles that he believes all roles should be truely random. He said that for the games he mods all roles will be random. I don't think he'd go back on that.
 
wow Dawg... that was quite a flub...

Yup...I don't know what else to say except I totally misread the rules.

The Don has no special power. Its one of the reasons I complained that they show innocent the 1st 3 days. The mafia lose nothing by losing him. There was no reason for the Don to show innocent.

Razz I loved your post. It made me laugh. After you are lynched should we lynch Dawg or JL 1st?

JL do you prefer being lynched before or after Dawg?

Dawg same question to you.


Can you guys figure out what my suspect list is?

I don't care if and when I'm lynched except that it will hurt the town. The one benefit of me being lynched will be that the town may begin to focus on you a bit more when I'm gone and confirmed innocent.

Oops, forgot to address my other 2 quotes there.

Ice, I thought that statement is pretty bold, Mafia vote mafia all the time.

Dawg, what if Noodles put all the scum on that list, so when one came up scum we'd lessen our view of the rest.

That's why I said...

Wow! That's not what I expected to come back to but the snitch is gone and we have their list. The problem with the list is Noods could be the only mafia on it or they could all be mafia...which I doubt. Not sure if we can get any info from the list.

I'm too tired to be of any good tonight so I'll be checking in tomorrow morning.

Annie, can we assume Rich was an innocent townie with no PR?
 
AquariaCentral.com