Mafia 62- The Play

[jpappy789]

Since you have said something, I will change my vote.

I retract my vote on Razz and vote to lynch JL

Out of the two people who haven't shown up yet, JL seems like a better choice to me. I've played games with AlexW before and he is always quiet no matter what role he has. Not sure if JL is normally quiet or not.

Ag, I have another question...you say that Alex is normally quiet so you change your vote to JL. Are you basically assuming that JL is a talkative player?

(He usually is, by the way)

 

[ZSandmann]

So Z, is it still too early to ask a question?

If you're expecting it... yes.

 

[Agassizii]

Ag, I have another question...you say that Alex is normally quiet so you change your vote to JL. Are you basically assuming that JL is a talkative player?

(He usually is, by the way)

Yes, I am assuming the he is a talkative player.

 

[Agassizii]

Yes, I am assuming the he is a talkative player.

The bold word should be "that"...

 

[jpappy789]

Yes, I am assuming the he is a talkative player.

Alright. That's what I thought, but I have to wonder why you just didn't wait for someone to comment before making your decision. Instead you assumed JL was talkative. There was no reason to switch to someone in the first place, you could have just retracted your vote.

Could you also address why voting for someone who would UD is at all helpful?

 

[IceH2O]

My vote was going to stay on Razz if he didn't show up. It was not a random vote. I decided I was going to place my vote on someone who hadn't posted yet. Since Razz posted, my vote changed to another who hasn't posted.

The good ol' "lynch a UD victim" debate comes back from the dead...what purpose does voting for a player who may die serve?

Was going to be my question also.

I noticed I put 2 players as one in my post back there. I said Agi said something Alex was quiet twice when in fact it was Agi and Lab that said it.





Ok...so I've been thinking. I think the towns best option with me is to make me a pocket mafia. Don't follow my lead, take everything I say with a grain of salt. If we get down to only needing 1 or 2 mafia players to kill then take me out.

To put the mafia on edge I'm going to come out and say the Dr should protect me. This way if the mafia try to hit me and fail everyone knows I'm innocent. The Dr doesn't really need to protect me though because the mafia won't know if I'm protected or not.

 

[Agassizii]

Alright. That's what I thought, but I have to wonder why you just didn't wait for someone to comment before making your decision. Instead you assumed JL was talkative. There was no reason to switch to someone in the first place, you could have just retracted your vote.

Could you also address why voting for someone who would UD is at all helpful?

Well, now that I gave that some more thought, I'd have to say it doesn't. It's just a wasted vote.

I retract my vote from JL....

Will read through the thread again and think about this some more before voting again.

 

[jpappy789]

Well, now that I gave that some more thought, I'd have to say it doesn't. It's just a wasted vote.

I retract my vote from JL....

Will read through the thread again and think about this some more before voting again.

How convenient.

I retract my vote on Ice

Agass is turning out to be a very interesting player in my mind, I could even go as far to say he's Day 1 vote material. Right now he is the one who has most of my attention.

 

[Lab_Rat]

JL isn't someone you figure out. He is one you need to use your gut on. He is very crafty in not giving away his role or tying himself in with other mafia if he is one of them.

So for those who have played with JL before, what is your gut saying about his lack of posting? Does that indicate mafia with him?

Since you have said something, I will change my vote.

I retract my vote on Razz and vote to lynch JL

Out of the two people who haven't shown up yet, JL seems like a better choice to me. I've played games with AlexW before and he is always quiet no matter what role he has. Not sure if JL is normally quiet or not.

I don't see your logic in this at all Ag...please explain even though you have now retracted. I'd like to hear what you were thinking.

First vote switch AND I believe the first person to double up a vote. If this doesn't draw attention than nothing does.

Agree

Oh the remaining non-posters JL is the most alarming. I can't believe he wouldn't have seen this by now.

Is anyone else alarmed with the lack of posting?

Yes, I am assuming the he is a talkative player.

Why would you assume that? Are you talking with him at an offsite message board? Is he quite talkative there?

Well, now that I gave that some more thought, I'd have to say it doesn't. It's just a wasted vote.

I retract my vote from JL....

Will read through the thread again and think about this some more before voting again.

Convenient...

Ag, you're looking scummy to me. Since my vote was a random one to encourage conversation I will have no problem switching it. I would like to hear more about JL (or even better, from JL).

 

[jpappy789]

JL is usually talkative but he's been known to be busy traveling or doing something else with work...can't say it's really making me worry at this point. Maybe if by tomorrow he doesn't show until late I will think more about his absence.