mafia 63- Who is Who

[jbradt]

jb, I am 99.9% sure that FF1 is not the mayor. I am also 100% sure that annie is mafia.

I have no evidence that FF1 is mafia or innocent. I have thoughts. For a moment, I thought they were innocent, now I have them leaning mafia.

No, really. I was looking for something to lean you innocent as I really want to believe you are the cop. But if you're more sure that Annie is scum than FF is innocent (hehe, I got it right that time), why is your vote where it is? You would be MORE SURE of not voting the mayor if you voted Annie.

Posts like this are why my vote is where it's at for now.

 

[Lab_Rat]

Does it concern anyone else that Ag, BFM, and RB have yet to weigh in about anything? Come on guys, what are your thoughts?

I invite everyone to pick apart my theory, tell me where it's wrong. I've tried. Even with jpap's feedback, I still don't see the holes anywhere. This is the most cohesive theory I have ever established or even seen in a mafia game. Everything makes sense. There are no loose ends. Look at JL's recent behavior, it totally confirms it.

If you cannot pick a hole in my theory, please do what is best for the town and lynch the scum don Annie.

 

[Rbishop]

Already posted my thoughts...since we are playing with two different sets of rules...in two different threads...all post up to now are basically out the window.

 

[Lab_Rat]

Already posted my thoughts...since we are playing with two different sets of rules...in two different threads...all post up to now are basically out the window.

I don't understand this??? I formulated everything on the rules that there was a pre-game investigation for each, and that there has been an investigation post first nightfall. But actually, my theory would still apply if there were no pre-game investigation as it only requires the two scum to be in communication.

 

[jpappy789]

Already posted my thoughts...since we are playing with two different sets of rules...in two different threads...all post up to now are basically out the window.

You're using the lack of rules as reason to not weigh in on the current situation? Lame.

 

[Fishfriend1]

I really truly want to believe that you are the policeman JL but i just cant think that someone who would say that the only way to win is to keep yourself and the mayor alive wile the rest of us can die. Just doesn't seem townie to me.

 

[jbradt]

Already posted my thoughts...since we are playing with two different sets of rules...in two different threads...all post up to now are basically out the window.

You're using the lack of rules as reason to not weigh in on the current situation? Lame.

I've got to agree with Jpap here RB. Even I understood the rules... doesn't matter what form they took. I have a hard time believing you were that confused by it.

 

[Rbishop]

I wouldn't base a theory or justify anyone else's when folks have been playing under two sets of rules and even though there were numerous posts contrary to the rules, the Mod never clarified the issue.

For all those that posted no one was communicating in numerous posts on day one and most of day two and any theories developed on that...they are all bogus since the Mod said a rule from the sign up thread was in affect though not in the rules stated in this game at the on set.

So from what I see, it is nothing more than a crap shoot day one vote...

 

[Lab_Rat]

I really truly want to believe that you are the policeman JL but i just cant think that someone who would say that the only way to win is to keep yourself and the mayor alive wile the rest of us can die. Just doesn't seem townie to me.

FF, that is because he is scum, but more importantly, he is protecting the important scum...Annie. JL's actions point toward protecting his boss. Why should we lynch regular scum when the boss is obvious? If you want to do what is best for the town you will vote Annie for the lynch.

 

[jpappy789]

Its not Day one anymore Rb and I think everyone's CURRENT theories are based around the correct rules. Lab said so herself, Jb did, I acknowledged it...seriously.