Mafia #64 ? Cabin Fever - The Play

[IceH2O]

Ice, my main reason for suspecting you was based on an erroneous thought that you knowingly misquoted my invests in the last game. You answered and corrected satisfactorily that I do not suspect you.

I do have a suspect list but see no point in posting a list, my most solid case is the way JL and his scum partners have been keeping the townies split with coordinated efforts at misdirection.

Since we only have one chance to get someone that is evil or we lose I therefore cast my vote now

I vote to banish JL

As I can see it looks as though I will be next. This could well be my last post before nightfall.

I have my daughter this weekend so probably won't be back until after i get banished. I will then be able to see if my logic lined up correctly on my other suspects.

Good luck townies remember if the scum can split you up on who to banish they will at last minute all jump to an innocent and win.

Some type of suspect list would have been nice to help me decide if you are innocent or not. Not a good move if innocent. Only reason to not give one is so you don't gve away who your team mates are.

No comments about Dag?? Is he a team mate?


And what does the line in red mean? What good does that do anyone after you are dead?

Okay guys we need to come to the conclusion that Wiz vote is placed hoping that enough innocents pile on to one other innocent with the evil group and that Wiz plans on making a last minute jump.

I only plan on voting Dag or Wiz after this post probably Wiz but I'll give him time to come back and answer.

I see no reason to vote anyone else. Think we might have 2 mafia here.

 

[IceH2O]

Screw it, no reason to wait.

I vote to banish Wiz

 

[dirtydawg10]

Ice, my main reason for suspecting you was based on an erroneous thought that you knowingly misquoted my invests in the last game. You answered and corrected satisfactorily that I do not suspect you.

I do have a suspect list but see no point in posting a list, my most solid case is the way JL and his scum partners have been keeping the townies split with coordinated efforts at misdirection.

Since we only have one chance to get someone that is evil or we lose I therefore cast my vote now

I vote to banish JL

As I can see it looks as though I will be next. This could well be my last post before nightfall.

I have my daughter this weekend so probably won't be back until after i get banished. I will then be able to see if my logic lined up correctly on my other suspects.

Good luck townies remember if the scum can split you up on who to banish they will at last minute all jump to an innocent and win.

Ice, I'd like to know your thoughts on Wiz now after this most recent post.

Wiz, your posts just keep getting scummier. Why would you hold back on your list? That is not very pro-town. The only way we know what each other are thinking is to put it out there on the thread. You also made no clarifications of your thoughts on Kash's last minute posts and why you think she had plenty of time when it is clear from her posts that she didn't have time. I'm not sure what else to think.

I vote to banish Wiz. I would still like to hear from Dag and also from Ice on Wiz's latest post.

 

[dirtydawg10]

Screw it, no reason to wait.

I vote to banish Wiz

I guess I know your thoughts...you posted while I was typing I guess.

 

[IceH2O]

I have unofficially

Wiz -4- JL FF Ice Dawg

Dag-2-DD Rich

JL-1- Wiz

no votes

Razz Dag

 

[Fishfriend1]

I knew there was somthin fishy here. Definitely sticking with voting wiz.

 

[Fishfriend1]

Good night everyone!

 

[the wizard]

My daughter has gone to bed now so thought i would see what has developed. It appears I could have been a little clearer with my posts since nightfall.

Forgive me for that, it was 4 am when i posted last night. i was up all night trying to figure what Kashta was getting at.

I know Kashta very well,as everyone obviously is very aware of. She is pretty direct.

It appeared as though she was making a case against Ice but voted annie.

She didn't need to vote annie and she knew it she asked for a vote tally while she was posting.

What I meant when I said she had time was that she was going to survive being banished. Being hit didn't enter her mind.

So having time was that she could continue to post after nightfall.

So if she thought Ice was scum she would have voted for ice.

I repeat my question who else did she suspect?

I see to others in her posts that are virtually side by side everywhere.
Dawg and Jl.

Some type of suspect list would have been nice to help me decide if you are innocent or not. Not a good move if innocent. Only reason to not give one is so you don't gve away who your team mates are.

No comments about Dag?? Is he a team mate?


And what does the line in red mean? What good does that do anyone after you are dead?

Okay guys we need to come to the conclusion that Wiz vote is placed hoping that enough innocents pile on to one other innocent with the evil group and that Wiz plans on making a last minute jump.

I only plan on voting Dag or Wiz after this post probably Wiz but I'll give him time to come back and answer.

I see no reason to vote anyone else. Think we might have 2 mafia here.

You are right Ice you do deserve better than what I gave in my last post.

I have been racking my brain trying to figure out how to turn this around. I just don't know how to do it.

Let's see innocents:
Ice, wiz,dag, ff,

scum:
jl,dd,dawg

I include dawg here because i see him right along with jl in kashtas posts
like i said who else did she suspect?

I was leaning rich scum until reading his post after nightfall now tending to lean him more innocent

i had razz innocent until reading his post after nightfall now thinking him scum

what the highlighted line means is just what it says. It is my weekend with my daughter so dont have a lot of time to spend on the thread. from what i saw in the thread I am the next to be banished

Since this is only my second game and only the first one i could be active in you don't know yet that i am pretty direct with my statements.

That being said here are my thoughts

The scum are laughing and having a grand time.

There are 2 innocents up to be banished and no one is even questioning the spin dr's that have kept us looking at the wrong details all along.

to quote Kashta again look at the big picture

 

[Fishfriend1]

you know, i think that we are putting to much onto kashta's posts. She only ad a chance to invest 2 people right? And here we are thinking she knows everything. She may have invested Razz and Ice; or LR and Jl; or any other pair of people. Who knows...

 

[IceH2O]

My daughter has gone to bed now so thought i would see what has developed. It appears I could have been a little clearer with my posts since nightfall.

Forgive me for that, it was 4 am when i posted last night. i was up all night trying to figure what Kashta was getting at.

I know Kashta very well,as everyone obviously is very aware of. She is pretty direct.

It appeared as though she was making a case against Ice but voted annie.

She didn't need to vote annie and she knew it she asked for a vote tally while she was posting.

What I meant when I said she had time was that she was going to survive being banished. Being hit didn't enter her mind.

So having time was that she could continue to post after nightfall.

So if she thought Ice was scum she would have voted for ice.

I repeat my question who else did she suspect?

I see to others in her posts that are virtually side by side everywhere.
Dawg and Jl.



You are right Ice you do deserve better than what I gave in my last post.

I have been racking my brain trying to figure out how to turn this around. I just don't know how to do it.

Let's see innocents:
Ice, wiz,dag, ff,

scum:
jl,dd,dawg

I include dawg here because i see him right along with jl in kashtas posts
like i said who else did she suspect?

I was leaning rich scum until reading his post after nightfall now tending to lean him more innocent

i had razz innocent until reading his post after nightfall now thinking him scum

what the highlighted line means is just what it says. It is my weekend with my daughter so dont have a lot of time to spend on the thread. from what i saw in the thread I am the next to be banished

Since this is only my second game and only the first one i could be active in you don't know yet that i am pretty direct with my statements.

That being said here are my thoughts

The scum are laughing and having a grand time.

There are 2 innocents up to be banished and no one is even questioning the spin dr's that have kept us looking at the wrong details all along.

to quote Kashta again look at the big picture

I'm not buying it.

Why would she build a case against me if she thought I was innocent?

I am completely at a loss right now. I need to reread from 5:00 I will be back.

Her late vote forced her to vote to save herself. it would seem she dd not have an evil on her list because I would think she would have voted for that person early and tried to get people to get on that person.

I find it interesting that both Ice and Jl are still with us. Leads me to think this is a creative evil team or one or both are the bad guys. from their posting and work I would say they are not but it is a thought.

That leads me to who of the others is that creative a thinker. There are several possibilities, I would think dawg or DD.

He is building his case against me JL. I think that is what he means any way.

Dag is LRs brother that is correct. He made a point of not voting her. Maybe it was not the sibling thing maybe he did not want to be on an innocent.

Right now my top 3 are Dag, Wiz and I am not sure,. I can see raz and dawg. The fact that Ice and Jl are both still with us could easily lead to beleive one of them is the man, but I have no case on them but that fact.

For the moment I vote to banish Dag. I will be around the rest of this evening and should be around a decent amount tomorrow. I want go read today for the third time. See if something new shakes.

So what about these posts makes you move Rich from evil to innocent?

Could Kash invest anyone? I have a hard time beliving you Ice, if Kash already knew a mafia player.

Nope, nightfall was on time.

^Excuse me? What are you saying?

This is ringing some bells in my head. I don't like this reason. This late in the game with the standings as they are, gut feelings aren't enough. If you don't have a reason, I would rather you just not put his name up there.

Wiz- I agree with everything said so far about him hiding behind Kash, but I don't know what to make of her list.

FF- He has a very odd playing style and by the way he was going to "give up" I think he may be a mafia player. Also going off the way he was going to "give up" I do not think he is the madman.

Dag- He just doesn't seem to be trying very hard to help the town. Unless he just isn't posting his thoughts, he may be the madman.

I would feel comfortable voting any of them tonight.

What about these posts moves Razz innocent to evil?


I understood the part about being next to be banished. What I didn't get is how was that going to help us see if your logic lined up with your suspects when all we knew at the time was that JL and Dawg were 2 of your suspects.Without your thoughts on everyone how would we put 2 and 2 together. There are 4 evils.

So I should get from this post your evils are
JL
Dawg
DD
Razz

I do agree with 2 of them at this point but the next few hours should help me be more sure of my evils list.

FF is right to a point. She only had 1 invest, to be any stock in her list is to trust her gut. On top of that we need to trust her based on limited skimming because she got home late.I already know her case against me was due to skimming or not reading far enough into the thread.