Mafia #64 ? Cabin Fever - The Play

[johnlarson66]

Here we go with the innocent card...

 

[IceH2O]

How do "we know 2 of the accomplices were with the madman from the start?"

I think we can safely assume that the doc was turned, based on the first aid kit. I don't know how you got from that that 2 were with the madman from the start. It is possible that no one volunteered to be evil and all of them were turned last night or just one or two.

Odd statement to make.

I assumed only 1 person switched places due to the write up.

 

[dirtydawg10]

I couldn't get on all day until now so I did a quick skim and will do a full reread in a bit and post some comments.

The biggest thing that stands out to me is people trying to make sense of Annie's list

Seriously though...I need to go back and look but didn't Annie join FF and Lab to try and get Tex lynched? The reason I'm mentioning that is I'm wondering if it was an attempt by Annie to try and save FF. As I said I'll have to go back and look.

IT IS NIGHT!

FF- JL 22, Annie 56 (127), Rich 90, DD 140, Dag 215, Lab 252
Lab- Kash 48, Wiz 49, FF 57, FF 123, tex 128, Dawg 192, Ice 194, FF 258
Kash- DD 66
Ice- Zaffy 130
Zaffy- Ice146
Tex- FF 156, Lab 157, Annie 182, Razz 217
Dag- Annie 181

Yup...FF, Lab, Annie and Razz all went to Tex. We now know Lab was trying to save herself by getting people to move to Tex. Annie and Razz both made that move to Tex. Now I need to see what their reasoning was. Also Annie and Razz are the only two who stayed on Tex. Maybe it looks better if FF saves himself instead of one of his teammates coming to the rescue.

 

[AnniesNotOK]

This sounds an awful lot like an excuse, instead of reason. I am sure that ATT has a lot of customers in New Orleans, and you mentioned in the last game that you often post from your phone during the day.

Things that make you go hmmmmm.

Hmmmmmmmmmmmm......

Gee, friends with the same phone had service and you didn't? Something is sounding scummy in ACville here. Besides the fact that with 3G coverage on your friends phone it isn't like the opportunity to pm wasn't available to you. Does it? :bs:

I vote to banish lab rat

unless something scummier surfaces before nightfall

What a shock. The Wiz follows Kash onto an innocent. An innocent Kash is working hard to make a case on.

I am just making observations. I am not implying anything except that for the first day in day one you seem to be awfully defensive.

Besides, you aren't the only one that I have questioned tonight. Just the only one that seems eager to be defensive.

So Wiz, did any of the "questioning" of those other people ever pan out??

Annie, your list is a total joke and makes no sense. FF seems to make more sense than you do at this point.

Besides yourself, you have no one leaning innocent?

I think you are the madman and either kash or the wiz asked to be evil, I don't think they both did because of how wiz followed kash on Lab, I don't think they would do that again. Maybe they hoped the other one did. Of the two, I could see the wiz asking to be evil. His weak vote with Kash to me thinks he was trying to hide in her shadow.

I have Kash and FF leaning innocent. I have annie and the wiz leaning mafia.

The rest are pretty close to neutral, really matters what happens this next nightfall and how the votes go. I think there are atleast three players that won't let annie get banished.

Geez, no need to boot me right in the nards, I admit the list isn't about to make Oprah's Book Club, I did really only skim as much as I can this game, work and home life pretty busy right now.

However, because I did have a little time tonight, I reread the thread in its entirety, so I could try to produce a better list. One you might even be proud of. Maybe not.

My suspects:

Kashta- did everything she could to build the case on Lab.
The Wiz- Because the Wiz is Kashtas shadow. One or both are likely to be evil.
Razz- Razz has been posting just enough to get by. Also, as Lab mentioned in one of her posts, when Jpap suggested in the sign up players switch to invisible and pm him to be evil, Razz asked how to turn invisible. Hmmmmmmm.......

Anyway, heres a better list. Subject to change.

Annie- 1
Dag- 4
DD- 4
Rich- 5
FF- 6
JL- 6
Dawg- 6
Tex- 7
Ice- 7
Razz- 8
Kashta- 9
The Wiz- 9

I would be happy to move my vote to the Wiz or Razz.

 

[Fishfriend1]

Yup...FF, Lab, Annie and Razz all went to Tex. We now know Lab was trying to save herself by getting people to move to Tex. Annie and Razz both made that move to Tex. Now I need to see what their reasoning was. Also Annie and Razz are the only two who stayed on Tex. Maybe it looks better if FF saves himself instead of one of his teammates coming to the rescue.

Whats that supposed to mean?!

Anyway, ive seen a theory here that sounds possible (not in this post).
Its the one where Kashta or Wiz got madman, and then the other moved over. Of course the i also think that tex willingly joined the mafia so yea... I think im gonna I retract my vote from tex, and vote to banish Kashta, untill further notice.

 

[Dangerdoll]

ummmm...... FF... what makes you think you voted Tex??? You voted to banish me!! So, are you ready yet to tell us whio is giving you directions??

 

[dirtydawg10]

I am not convinced Lab is scum. While she has been vehemently defending herself, I find this behaviour is contadictory to the way she played when evil in the past.

I am concerned about Wiz and his eagerness to blindly follow Kash.

Dagamoth's behaviour is troubling. He has played part of a game on another site, and read one from this site. And yet he openly admits to voting for the sole purpose of protecting himself from a lynch, rather than voting in an effort to root out scumbags and save the town.

Lets see how he votes when he sees his name in bold.

I retract my vote to banish FF and vote to banish Dagamoth.

So Annie was the 2nd vote on FF and then retracted here to Dag. I guess Annie could have been distancing from FF but that early on in day 1 to be the 2nd vote on FF I would lean Annie innocent if FF turns up evil. It's tough to say though especially not knowing what FF is.

My bad. Its Texasguy who admitted to voting simply to save himself. Replace Texasguy with Dagamoth in my previous post.

I retract my vote to banish Daga, and vote to banish Texasguy.

Then Annie says to replace Dag w/ Tex in his previous post but I believe Dag was the one who had played mafia before on another site not Tex. So he did get the post all mixed up between talking about Dag and Tex. Then votes for Tex for what I believe to be a Noob mistake.

Hey guys! So after reading the thread, a lot has happened. I am not sure I like the way voting is going. I don't like landslides on day one. Dispite that, I want to put my vote on either Tex or Lab, but like I said, I don't like huge landslides so..... I vote to banish Tex! Lab, depending on what happens tonight and into tomorrow, my vote may land on you next.



Sorry, I haven't been around much. The work week is crazy, but I am not! My dishwasher broke unexpectedly so I have to deal with that but I will post as much as I can from here on out.

Not very strong reasoning from Razz here either. Doesn't like landslides so votes for Tex even though there was no real voting landslide going on.

These two just climbed up my scum list.

 

[Fishfriend1]

ummmm...... FF... what makes you think you voted Tex??? You voted to banish me!! So, are you ready yet to tell us whio is giving you directions??

:rofl::duh::rofl::duh::rofl:
I really need to lay off the sugar...

OK I retract my vote on DD and vote to banish tex again...

 

[RazzleFish]

Ok, I think this is correct.

Votes:
FF- Dag (283), Ice (286), JL (290)
Kash- FF (292)
Tex- FF (307), FF (398)
Ice- Annie (323)
Annie- JL (350), Ice (383)
DD- FF (360), Annie (379)

Ok, that is quite a bit of red for only having 4 votes up there. What stands out to me is the fact that FF voted 4 different times. FF, why are you jumping around so much? I don't want to start assuming things but it looks like you have tried and failed several times to start a train on various players.

 

[rich311k]

Annie- I have trouble figuring him. His logic is quite unique at times. I can definitely see a case against him.

Dag- I have not see enough or remember enough at least to feel one way or the other. Had a reason not to vote Lab but said he would have.

DD- I don't understand her over the top reaction about skimming, She gets that every game, heck she gets it in the sign up threads, makes me worry about her.

Rich- Heck of a guy.

FF- I really think he is apprentice number one.

JL- for the moment seems to be pro town but I never have a clue what he is thinking.

Dawg- I always lean Dawg mafia and this time around he is really feeling that way to me.

Tex- few strange post. I think he is just playing around could be either but leaning evil.

Ice- for the moment I see nothing to think he is not doing his best to find the bad guys.

Razz- on my suspect list, very few posts and not helpful at all.

Kashta- first on LR. Pushed that quite hard, definitely 1 or 2 on my list.

The Wiz- has followed kash's lead. They both claim that is not true but I have not actually seen that. Pushed hard for LR as well. Also 1 or 2 on my list. They were 1 and 2 on LR.

I vote to banish the Wiz.