Mafia 65: Masons and Mafia (Game Thread)

[Dagamoth]

holy crap this game went into warp speed. it went from page 3 to page 15 from the last time i had internet access. i totally had to DD and skim like no other to almost get a grasp of what has gone on. Still reading more and will post again in a few to figure out who seems to be the evilester.

 

[Lab_Rat]

So what is it in these posts that has Dag as your top suspect Lab?

His suspect list and vote lacks substance. I know he's smarter than that and capable of producing more solid reasoning than he did. I feel he threw a vote out there to simply have one out there.

Tell me JL, where has Dag posted anything pro-town?

 

[Fishfriend1]

well, good night everyone!

 

[johnlarson66]

This post seems very pro-town -

Don't you see how there can be a problem with taking a grain of salt with every FF post? If FF is mafia then taking all his posts with a grain of salt is discounting the possibility that he is mafia. Unless you know for sure that FF isn't mafia which the only way would be if both of you are on the mason team. FF being FF shouldn't disqualify him from being a suspect. Right now in my mind everyone is suspect.

This is an unusual format. If just three innocents votes for an innocent theoretically the mafia could swarm the target and drop down 5 votes on them and get them lynched right then and there. Although that is unlikely due to giving the whole team away it's still a possibility. I'm going to have to agree with you Ice that stretching the day is probably hurting mafia more then any other just for the reason of they can't decide to train vote on someone who gets 3 votes.

 

[johnlarson66]

What have FF and Tex posted that was pro-town?

 

[Lab_Rat]

What have FF and Tex posted that was pro-town?

Off the top of my head, I can't think of anything that stands out. FF I've taken with a grain of salt. Tex got the benefit of the doubt for the first night. He's actually started to become more active. Though he was the kill vote on Wiz. :wall:

 

[johnlarson66]

Here are all of tex's posts -

The first post -

I'm here!

Chimes in on a couple of suspects, I think, calls dawg DD and votes dawg -

Well from what little Mafia ability I have I've scanned the posts. And I've seen two extremes.

JL- seems determined to defend himself from anything, constantly talking like hes an innocent that doesn't want to die so early,

DD- He seems to come and go. Posting very "deep" things and then dissapearing again like he wants to make his point but doesn't want to say something stupid that would reveal his role.
I vote to Lynch DirtyDawg

So he has a few votes and this is his defense -

So now a lack of posts instantly means I'm the mafia?

States that FF and the wiz both seem scumbaggy and throws some suspicion on Ice, votes the wiz -

Wow Day 2 was fast! I agree with most here, FF and Wiz both seem very suspiciously scumbaggy... Also Ice seems to be playing very agressively, not necesarily pointing mafia but he is definitly seriously into this game possibly giving him a role?

anyways I vote to lynch Wiz

explains his Ice comment -

I have no idea on Ice's scummyness just that he's been playing with force.

Response to Ice's question -

I would love to know

Now has this response instead of replying to what Ice had stated or giving any reasons for his votes -

I'm sorry that I wasn't present for the whole 2 hours that Day 2 lasted, but I fail to see how that justifies me as a suspect for mafia.

Here he edited a post and I am not sure what he was even talking about -

For all of you who keep bringing it up I said he was in my suspect list, just that he was posting a lot.

Edit: totally forgot to mention that was about JL

Suspects:
Ice- after mentioning his style of posting, he has turned defensive and started talking against me.
DD- seems to be a semi lurker just like I though dawg was and I can only hope that my idea is right this time.
FF- seems very tense right about now trying to get JL to help him so he doesn't get voted out.

So now Ice asks him some questions and places a vote on him he has Ice as a suspect. Not sure how DD can be considered a semi-lurker, she seems to be more active in this game than she has in recent games.

Odd the he does not place a vote on FF.

So what in the world has Tex done that was pro-town?

 

[Dagamoth]

If I were to vote with who I feel is most scummy right now, I vote to lynch Dagamoth. I see he's gained internet access so he won't UD.

Now that is just a low blow Lab. Saying that I am scummy because I'm not able to actively follow the game as much as I would like due to RL circumstances which suck and put me in a rush is very weak. Asking what have I done to help the town isn't fair because I haven't been here when 98.4% of all the scumnessosity went down. When I was up to date last was on page 3 I believe right when I found out that I needed to fly down to florida to help G-Ma / G-Pa. At that point there wasn't much to go on so I went with my gut and the information I had at the time which was FF's crazy all around the board posts which I don't think anyone is able to interrpret what they mean. In my experiences it's the people who are trying to hide something who blab on and on about things that have no relation to questions asked. If you don't think that is accurate listen to a politician do an interview when they don't have the questions before hand.

I will say it was nice of you to wait till I got a couple minutes of time to try and read the over 400 postings that I missed before saying that I am scum for not having a better reason for my vote on FF (day 1) when I was rushing to make plans for two weeks down taking care of the grandparents. If that isn't shady I don't know what is.

 

[johnlarson66]

Off the top of my head, I can't think of anything that stands out. FF I've taken with a grain of salt. Tex got the benefit of the doubt for the first night. He's actually started to become more active. Though he was the kill vote on Wiz. :wall:

A grain of salt you say, where have I heard that before... Oh your #1 suspect said the EXACT same thing.

You really gonna keep your vote where it is? I think a two player race with two top suspects would be good for the town.

 

[Lab_Rat]

Now that is just a low blow Lab. Saying that I am scummy because I'm not able to actively follow the game as much as I would like due to RL circumstances which suck and put me in a rush is very weak. Asking what have I done to help the town isn't fair because I haven't been here when 98.4% of all the scumnessosity went down. When I was up to date last was on page 3 I believe right when I found out that I needed to fly down to florida to help G-Ma / G-Pa. At that point there wasn't much to go on so I went with my gut and the information I had at the time which was FF's crazy all around the board posts which I don't think anyone is able to interrpret what they mean. In my experiences it's the people who are trying to hide something who blab on and on about things that have no relation to questions asked. If you don't think that is accurate listen to a politician do an interview when they don't have the questions before hand.

I will say it was nice of you to wait till I got a couple minutes of time to try and read the over 400 postings that I missed before saying that I am scum for not having a better reason for my vote on FF (day 1) when I was rushing to make plans for two weeks down taking care of the grandparents. If that isn't shady I don't know what is.

I'm saying you're scummy because I feel your vote on FF was lame and really without substance. I've acknowledged that you have spotty internet access so there is no need for you to baww about it. Come on Dag, I know you could have come up with better reasoning for voting how you did. You get no noob pass from me, I know you better than that.