Ok, I can see how a 3 horse race among Coler, Noods, and XXXX could give us more information than simply lynching Coler. I would like to hear from others (especially Dawg, Dag, and JB) about their thoughts on this scenario.
You may not think it's likely that he would have had the IWs know the same player, but I think there is a very good possibility that is the case. It's less risky for the scum team that way, rather than having two of their members known. More than 2 IWs, yeah, I kinda doubt there are. I think the point of the IW role was to give the innocent team an automatic investigation into a scum member.
But we've already seen how risky it is for the IW's to go on their given invest result...it got Kashta lynched, unfortunately. I think the role was another reason for the mafia to be hesitant with the hits. They were bold last night, but they got a farmer. I just don't think JL would punish ONE RR (in this case Noods) for the team choosing to hit a IW.