Dangerdoll
Global Moderator
good point, rich.... I'm not sure if it is joking or not... I am not used to page 1 being so serious....
Mafia 66: Farmers versus the Railroad - the play
- Thread starter johnlarson66
- Start date
woo hooo!!!!!
Game on!!!!
I actually posted before FF made 30 some odd posts :dance:
Speaking of FF where is your bff JL?
Not like him to not post this soon, makes me wonder about his assignment.
Game on!!!!
I actually posted before FF made 30 some odd posts :dance:
Speaking of FF where is your bff JL?
Not like him to not post this soon, makes me wonder about his assignment.
Dangerdoll
Global Moderator
that's right, where is FF.... completely out of character not to have a fury of pointless blunders.
Agree that it's way odd FF hasn't posted a billion times yet. Maybe he lost his power cord for his computer again. :laugh: Either that, or maybe his team told him to shut up this time...
I'm not sure what to make of the Noods/Kash thing. Kash is making a huge deal of this, but is that because Noods is reacting so strongly? I understand getting defensive, but not quite this early in the game. Guilty conscience Noods?
I guess I just don't get being so fervent in any judgment at this point in the game anyway. I get pointing things out, and discussing but jumping all over someone for (nearly) anything is as scummy as getting incredibly defensive. I think it's another case of two innocents with histories of high posting getting into it early on day 1.
Or it could be distancing. :laugh: I also like all the assumptions about FF based on the fact that he hasn't posted yet. I agree it's different for him, but base a role evaluation on it?
Let's take a deep breath folks... it's gonna be a long game.
Or it could be distancing. :laugh: I also like all the assumptions about FF based on the fact that he hasn't posted yet. I agree it's different for him, but base a role evaluation on it?
Let's take a deep breath folks... it's gonna be a long game.
LMAO.. I had to laugh when I saw that. I won't have time the whole day all the time like I used to before. So I'll post a lot when I can... and get quiet again when I'm busy. Maybe that'll balance this out for you better.
LOL @ pizza toppings and shrubbery. And I agree here that it isn't just what Noods did.. but how she reacted when I called her out and watching to see who takes what position in response.
No DD... this isn't a joke at all.
Noods posted early before the game actually started. Having put myself in this same position previously, I learned the hard way what a big deal this is because it's a very scummy thing to do. Coler even acknowledged that much being true with the post he made, as well. It's a careless mistake to make when you're scum that you're not prone to do at all when you're innocent.... and there's absolutely no way to defend yourself later after you've done it. Believe me, I learned that too. So I called Noods out over her little "boo boo" and I voted her to see what would happen.
Nothing scummy about that. Here, Noods simply acknowledged the vote with a touch of sarcasm and dismissed it. No big deal. Had Noods left this alone at this point and gone on with the game posting about other things, it would have died away. My early vote wouldn't have amounted to anything and I'd eventually retract it or switch the vote to some other suspect once the game got going.
If Noods was in one of the innocent roles, I believe she would not have addressed this again. Why would she bother? A lone vote from me over some trivial Day 1 blunder (that's probably just random anyway) isn't going to get anyone lynched, so why even worry about it, Noodles?
In this case, however, Noods knew she shouldn't touch it according to her statement above that she was "not going to address this again but...." And as a veteran player Noods knows why she shouldn't have said anything more.
Even so, she still couldn't leave it alone.
Noods is no stranger to being in the hot seat, that's for sure. But when she's evil, this kind of scrutiny tends to unravel her. That doesn't happen when Noods is innocent... she takes everything in stride.
Noods coming back again to discuss this even more tells me she DOES have something to hide from us AND that my voting her for that post got to her for some reason. No, this does not conclusively pin her as being evil all by itself. Of course not. But it's a huge indicator in Nood's case that bears watching how her play continues in this game. It's just one little puzzle piece that I'll tuck away for later comparison a few days from now when we're all analyzing voting patterns and such.
After this... Noods came back to my vote again and asked me to explain it. Hmmm.. okay, Noods. I was happy to oblige. Perhaps Noods wasn't counting on the fact that I'd have a real explanation why it's considered a scum tell. But I did, so there we are. Again, Noods should've left this alone. Even against her own better judgement, she couldn't let it slide.
THAT's the most reliable scum tell of all.
Kash, you seem to be trying to justify your vote based on one instance that YOU were involved in...I fail to see the relevance as to how/why Noods posted and the bearing on her role. I've been anxious myself after going without a couple games. Sometimes just posting again feels good...I don't believe that I was in that game you mention, so it's hard for me to comment on any similarities, but still...one isolated instance does not create a "scum tell" as you say describe it as...
As for FF...meh. As much as he does post, I don't expect him to be around 24/7. I haven't checked when he was last on but I think he has shown that he post A LOT no matter the role.
As for FF...meh. As much as he does post, I don't expect him to be around 24/7. I haven't checked when he was last on but I think he has shown that he post A LOT no matter the role.
Aside from Noods responding badly to my vote, I noticed something else I feel was important as the rest of the day continued.
Coler posted what I thought was a reasonable question to ask. Then he went on to vote me, too. Okay, that vote makes his position now in relation to Noodles a little stronger. Still, I didn't think too much of that at the time.
This post from Coler is significant... not just because of the points he tried to make possibly trying to defend Noodles. Of all people, Coler... (1) after having to work so hard to bail me out in that previous game... (2) for the fact that it was a very scummy thing to do, which he's confirmed for us there... and (3) because I managed to get away with it then due to Coler's efforts (which is true).... Coler would be the last person who'd be surprised that I'd let some other player do the exact same thing and just let them get away with it.
If Noods is evil... Coler is trying to help his teammate out of the spot she's in. If Noods is innocent, I seriously doubt Coler would have given this much mind when it happened. And he certainly would not have been surprised that I (of all people) would vote someone for doing what Noodles did today.
Coler posted what I thought was a reasonable question to ask. Then he went on to vote me, too. Okay, that vote makes his position now in relation to Noodles a little stronger. Still, I didn't think too much of that at the time.
This post from Coler is significant... not just because of the points he tried to make possibly trying to defend Noodles. Of all people, Coler... (1) after having to work so hard to bail me out in that previous game... (2) for the fact that it was a very scummy thing to do, which he's confirmed for us there... and (3) because I managed to get away with it then due to Coler's efforts (which is true).... Coler would be the last person who'd be surprised that I'd let some other player do the exact same thing and just let them get away with it.
If Noods is evil... Coler is trying to help his teammate out of the spot she's in. If Noods is innocent, I seriously doubt Coler would have given this much mind when it happened. And he certainly would not have been surprised that I (of all people) would vote someone for doing what Noodles did today.
