Mafia 66: Farmers versus the Railroad - the play

[jpappy789]

Coler...

Last night you said that you thought that there were 5 RROs. You were very sure of it...

If all that is true, then why did Noods not vote for you? Or even for herself? Even if Noods was lynched then with a successful recruit and some luck on the coin flip they end up with 5 RROs. With only 10 players left they win. If they were more conservative then she could have voted for you. A 50/50 chance of lynching an innocent means that they could have even withheld a hit a it would be game over with luck from the coin toss.

So either I have to call in question all your posts about the numbers or the fact that Noods saved your butt and basically lynched herself.

In light of recent events, disregard part of this post...

I'm still not sure why you were so convinced that last night we had 5 RRO's. That's obviously not true now since a loss and recruit would have kept them even and they would have won. Unless you're going to bank on the fact that Onin UDed as a RRO.

 

[rich311k]

When you say his posts rang true and still do, does that mean you think I'm scum?

Not sure on that yet. You have been the head bush kicker. His claim of innocence is what got me. Innocents have disagreed before and will again. He made me uncertain enough that I felt I should vote for the know RR. So I did.

I am thinking more Annie or Wiz right now.

 

[Lab_Rat]

I feel stupid as well.

Noods obviously staged her vote on Wiz to further paint Coler in an unflattering light.

Voting for Coler would not have saved her scummy arse, so she didn't.

How are you so sure of Coler's innocence?

 

[Lab_Rat]

Not sure on that yet. You have been the head bush kicker. His claim of innocence is what got me. Innocents have disagreed before and will again. He made me uncertain enough that I felt I should vote for the know RR. So I did.

I am thinking more Annie or Wiz right now.

Ok, so along those lines...I see an Annie--Coler--Wiz connection. So if you're thinking Annie or Wiz, Coler "seriously" thinks Wiz is innocent, Annie is defending Coler like a pit bull, do you still not think Coler is scum?

 

[AnniesNotOK]

How are you so sure of Coler's innocence?

The only thing I'm certain of is that anyone who wanted Coler and Noods in a cointoss deserves the towns careful attention.

The scumbags were dangerously close to winning last night if an innocent were lynched. Why would Coler have been so kind as to point that out if he were a scumbag?

 

[dirtydawg10]

I did some rereading and I can't believe I didn't see this before...

well, i am almost out of time and my company has finally left. (not sure why my house has become the friday night hangout?) While i am not against a lone vote on night one, this day has been unusually busy so I would not feel right leaving it as such. Now, where to move? I do not find what Coler has said/done suspicious so not moving there; Kashta/Labby, I find both suspicious......

I retract my vote for odinthejd and vote to lynch Kashta

Ummm...with that said I'm not sure how I can't vote for Coler.

I vote to lynch Coler

 

[Lab_Rat]

The only thing I'm certain of is that anyone who wanted Coler and Noods in a cointoss deserves the towns careful attention.

The scumbags were dangerously close to winning last night if an innocent were lynched. Why would Coler have been so kind as to point that out if he were a scumbag?

Coler was trying anything to save his butt. Yeah, scum could have won if the toss was between scum and an innocent, but if the coin toss was between two scumbags then the town had nothing to fear. His pointing that out does zero to make him seem innocent.

I did some rereading and I can't believe I didn't see this before...

Ummm...with that said I'm not sure how I can't vote for Coler.

I vote to lynch Coler

Nice catch Dawg! I'm going to go ahead and lay my vote out there too.

I vote to lynch Coler.

As of now, my version of the scum team:
Coler
Annie
Wiz
Rich or FF or JB as the ones possibly turned

I don't think Dawg, Dag, or Jpap has been turned simply because their posting has stayed pro-town from what I can tell.

 

[jbradt]

Well, I didn't get a lunch break so I just took a few minutes to skim what happened... mg:.

I've got to rethink through some things. I'll be back after work with more...

I agree that we're in sudden death at this point though... seems like it must be really close.

 

[jpappy789]

The only thing I'm certain of is that anyone who wanted Coler and Noods in a cointoss deserves the towns careful attention.

The scumbags were dangerously close to winning last night if an innocent were lynched. Why would Coler have been so kind as to point that out if he were a scumbag?

Seems like Lab already answered this but this really does not prove that Coler is innocent. He tried to scare us into voting Noods because otherwise we would lose...yes, that could have happened if Coler was innocent but if Coler was scum it was presumably the only way he could get votes off of him. Having two scum up for the lynch meant that the RROs couldn't win last night no matter what.

Lynching Noods helped the scum because now we are about as unsure as before. All they have to do is keep pointing fingers in the opposite direction and hope that they convince enough innocents to vote along with them. That's the best scenario they could hope for other than lynching an innocent obviously. Problem is, I don't think that was a possibility.

 

[Dagamoth]

the way i see it if coler isn't lynched tomorrow scum win