Mafia 66: Farmers versus the Railroad - the play

[Coler]

(snip)
Wiz, Annie, FF, Rich (turned last night) could VERY WELL be your scum team. Did you not see my hypothetical sequence of who was scum, who was turned when? Hold on, I'll go pull it for you...

No I did see it but I 100% don't buy it.

 

[Lab_Rat]

Here ya go Coler...how those voting for Dag could possibly be on the same scum team.

I'm starting to wonder if the scum team went something like this:

Day 1:
Noods
Wiz
DD
FF/Coler/???

Night 1: DD UDs, Annie is turned

Day 2:
Noods
Wiz
FF/Coler/???
Annie

Night 2: Noods lynched, Dag turned

Day 3:
Wiz
FF/Coler/???
Annie
Dag/???

Not sure about FF in there, it could be someone else. It could be Coler. Dag may not have been turned last night.

Anyone care to comment or change any of that around?

Remove your name, keep FF's in that spot. Then replace Dag with Rich for the last nights turn. That is what makes the most sense to me.

you know coler, im starting to think that you are innocent after all, you have been making a large number of pro-town posts and im really do think noods set you up.

I retract my vote on coler.

My second best bet would be dag, then wiz, then annie.

So who is your first best bet then FF? You say Dag is your second.

I think we have not payed enough attention to scummy little FF. He's made very sketchy posts that have been written off this entire game.


And this, this statement really bothers me:

There are lots of ways to make this a 3 or even 4 way tie. This could be quite the nightfall. Especially since we need to get this right.

Rich, what were you trying to accomplish with this statement? Were you trying to pull the wool over our eyes? This is the scummiest thing you've posted and it sets off alarm bells in my head. I know you came right back and said it would be a bad idea, but to even put it out there...

 

[Lab_Rat]

No I did see it but I 100% don't buy it.

What about it don't you buy?

 

[Coler]

Pretty much all of it actually.

Two other quick points are that that theory doesn't accomodate JB who is also voting Dag and strikes me as innocent and that my belief is that Dag was mafia from early, and not a turn.

 

[Coler]

Here ya go Coler...how those voting for Dag could possibly be on the same scum team.



Remove your name, keep FF's in that spot. Then replace Dag with Rich for the last nights turn. That is what makes the most sense to me.

answered in my previous post

So who is your first best bet then FF? You say Dag is your second.

I think we have not payed enough attention to scummy little FF. He's made very sketchy posts that have been written off this entire game.

You are casting your net wider

And this, this statement really bothers me:

Rich, what were you trying to accomplish with this statement? Were you trying to pull the wool over our eyes? This is the scummiest thing you've posted and it sets off alarm bells in my head. I know you came right back and said it would be a bad idea, but to even put it out there...

And wider...

Comments in bold are mine.

Not that casting the net wider is a bad thing but timing is everything. This has elements of looking like a rescue plan for Dag.

Do you really have a problem with him being lynched Lab Rat ?

 

[Coler]

Argh...first bit of the quoted post 'Here ya go Coler etc...' should not be in bold.

 

[Lab_Rat]

Pretty much all of it actually.

Two other quick points are that that theory doesn't accomodate JB who is also voting Dag and strikes me as innocent and that my belief is that Dag was mafia from early, and not a turn.

JB said he'd vote for Wiz or Annie as well, he was only voting for Dag because at that time it didn't look like anyone was going for those two.

In case you missed it:

I'm still 100% willing to switch to Wiz or Annie. I voted Dag because I didn't see support for the other 2.

Comments in bold are mine.

Not that casting the net wider is a bad thing but timing is everything. This has elements of looking like a rescue plan for Dag.

Do you really have a problem with him being lynched Lab Rat ?

No problem with it if he is scum...problem is, I'm not convinced he is. I'm much more convinced Wiz is scummy and Annie as well.

 

[Coler]

No I didn't miss that about JB - he also said he wouldn't be changing from Dag without some good hard evidence or words to that effect.

 

[Dagamoth]

Coler why do you not give the possibility that Annie is scum the slightest consideration?

 

[Coler]

Coler why do you not give the possibility that Annie is scum the slightest consideration?

I don't think that's entirely fair actually - I noted that the cuddling up to me made me edgy. When I've discussed Annie (actually in response mostly to other people raising them as suspects in fairness) I've always been of the view that there are better suspects.

Take for instance jpappy...could be scum but there are better suspects.

As a more acute example, Lab Rat very much remains on my suspect list. Tonight however I am voting you because you make a better suspect than her for reasons already explained.