Mafia #67 - 50/50 -- The Play

when Ice and Wiz started after me I really was starting to doubt things. You all had me going!
 
dirtydawg10 said:
I know...I had the same dilemma myself. That SB role was a nice curve ball but it needs some modification. I was going to call it a draw but I guess technically by the SB win rule I had JB ended the game with his bomb. If you guys had lynched Rich you would have had JL, DD and Noods vs JPap and JB and you would have won. I dunno...it was a tough one to mod and the Kash and Wiz dropout definitely threw a curve ball at the CI's.
Click to expand...

We hit jpap. JB is dead. DD and I were not killed, it is only the last 2 (noods and rich).

I really must be dense, but I don't see how DD and I lost. At least all of the innocents are dead.
 
johnlarson66 said:
Yes, I really thought FF was innocent. I am sure jpap did also. I am suprised your team did not tell you to back off a bit.
Click to expand...
We all thought FF was scum, never thought an innocent would ever ask scum to investigate them. That's why I went at him so hard. And each trap I set to confirm he was scum he fell into...especially when I asked if he was claiming CI and he said yes. After doing something like that I was sure he was evil.

johnlarson66 said:
Who was the hit going to be before Ice jumped in there?
Click to expand...
We went back and forth but we were going to wait until our results from the investigation.

Dawg, what was up with making it look like the scum hit Annie?
 
johnlarson66 said:
We hit jpap. JB is dead. DD and I were not killed, it is only the last 2 (noods and rich).

I really must be dense, but I don't see how DD and I lost. At least all of the innocents are dead.
Click to expand...

I think you guys lost because Jb ended the game. That was one of the requirements for the SB to win. He caused the mafia to win, and therefore won by his standards. IF that makes any sense...
 
johnlarson66 said:
So Ice saved rich from a lynch...

Plus outed himself as mafia and got hit.

Yes, you really should have waited until after nightfall, or just waited.
Click to expand...


I figured I was going to be that nights hit so I wanted to try and cause confusion and out the 2 players I thought were CIs.I also thought Rich was the SB and figured if I could atleat get DD and Noods off him we could still get Dag killed along with Kash. I did think kash was mafia at that time though so since she was online hoped she'd move. When she made the big stink I knew she wasn't so as if Rich died we still got 2 innocents killed with him.

Kash was wrong, I never outed my role. I could have been anyone. So I hope that is not what made them pull out.
 
Lab_Rat said:
We all thought FF was scum, never thought an innocent would ever ask scum to investigate them. That's why I went at him so hard. And each trap I set to confirm he was scum he fell into...especially when I asked if he was claiming CI and he said yes. After doing something like that I was sure he was evil.

We went back and forth but we were going to wait until our results from the investigation.

Dawg, what was up with making it look like the scum hit Annie?
Click to expand...


OMG! I told you, that was meant for BOTH teams! Sheesh...
 
johnlarson66 said:
We hit jpap. JB is dead. DD and I were not killed, it is only the last 2 (noods and rich).

I really must be dense, but I don't see how DD and I lost. At least all of the innocents are dead.
Click to expand...

Because his bomb ended the game and that's what he had to do to win according to the rules. I agree that you and DD didn't lose, you played a great game...but you didn't win either ;)

Maybe we should put this to a mafia poll. Draw or JB win...lol.

Just think...If DD had voted a few minutes earlier it would have turned out a bit different too.
 
Lab_Rat said:
We all thought FF was scum, never thought an innocent would ever ask scum to investigate them. That's why I went at him so hard. And each trap I set to confirm he was scum he fell into...especially when I asked if he was claiming CI and he said yes. After doing something like that I was sure he was evil.

We went back and forth but we were going to wait until our results from the investigation.

Dawg, what was up with making it look like the scum hit Annie?
Click to expand...

Probably worked out better for you to have the town think that. NCMs had to be more cautious.
 
so, how long should i wait b4 setting up the sign up thread for next game?
 
JB did a great job being the SB, good thing rich saved him.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom