Mafia #67 - 50/50 -- The Play

[Lab_Rat]

That was in response to Ice.

 

[Fishfriend1]

Sorry FF, my intent wasn't to insult you, or any of the other ruint ones that may be reading along.

I do however, find this post alarming. Seems like a contrived excuse to me.

I have a couple questions.

What do you mean by you were "out of it"?

Have you been out in Sonova Beach raiding my marijuana crop? Perhaps making a move on my dearly sainted sister AndiesNotOK? You're a tricksy hobbit.

Or are you by this claiming to have been drunk when you made last nights posts? Aren't you 15 or 16 years old and live with your father?

I was exhausted (very busy day, and my sister's calico issue, and the party, and the supermarket, and the cat trying to eat a marble incident, and the garden digging, and the spring cleaning, and...)
The second part, i live with my mom and dad on interchanging weeks. Last week i was with my dad this week with my mom, and on Monday i will be going back to my dads house.

Sorry to make it seem like i was drunk, didnt mean in that way, just remembered the party first. Although you could say i was sugar drunk, i drank way to much soda there (about 6 bottles lol).

 

[IceH2O]

I don't know if I can overlook this.



Especially after this post. Looks like its time to run back to the den for advice.


If FF hadn't already screwed himself I'd vote him.



The suicide bomber should die,would in my game.

1st of all I never said I wouldn't vote FF. I said I think there isn't a reason to since he painted a big target on his own back

Almost? Okay, perhaps it does on the surface. But if you think it through, your suggestion doesn't make sense. Also...if we're both mafia together and communicating (otherwise I wouldn't know it yet)... I'm fairly sure I'd kill him off early. I suspect JB has a lot more patience dealing with him as a teammate than I would have. Besides, in that scenario we'd have a communicating board I could use to ask him to STFU directly. Thus, no need to post that here.

Even if we're innocent communicating, I'd still be tempted to kill him off because his nonsense posts are distracting. I agree with Mad (and those already voting him)........ FF is being unhelpful.

If we're non-communicating good and non-communicating evil...then I wouldn't know he's even a teammate. Same is true if one of us is communicating and the other is non-communicating (either being town or scum).

Think that covers each of the options available.

Ice, how exactly does my comment almost seem like mafia advising mafia? I'm not seeing your logic there.



DD, same question for you...

How exactly does my comment almost seem like mafia advising mafia? I'm not seeing your logic there (either).

That said, I also believe FF is the safest Day 1 vote in town if you're someone looking to vote someone for a defensible reason AND not worry too much that your vote will be held against you later on if he flips innocent.

I don't believe you that if you were on a comm team with FF that you'd sacrifice him. You'd be weakening your team which is totally opposite of what you need to do especially if you were comm innocents so that is absurd.

Pappy, I'm concerned about FF too. But I'm also concerned about what looks to be a runaway train forming on one person... day 1. Also the fact that both Mad and Ice named him as scummy (or something like that) but withheld their votes.

Also, after going after Noodles so fast and so hard last game (which wasn't any fun)... I'm relucant to pick someone to vote early on with so little else going on yet in this game. While I agree with most of what was said and that it seems scummy as heck... I also wonder if this is an approach the mafia wants the town to take.

I explained why I hadn't voted FF like 30 posts before this post.


Its pretty obvious that if FF is mafia he is non comm.

Thats the beauty of putting out there that the innocents should invest him. If he is innocent then he joins them and can be protected and only took out via hit.
If he is mafia then the innocents don't need to waste a hit on him and can get him lynched. If the SB they can get on early and hope that mafia are the last 2 on him.

 

[Fishfriend1]

I'd forgotten that the nights that town or scum can investigate are different, so what you're saying makes a bit more sense now. I still don't see why I shouldn't vote for who I feel is the scummiest. Maybe someone will do something more scummy before nightfall and I'll change, but you gotta admit, what FF has done is quite scummy for day 1. I doubt there will be much better to go on today.

You say you have no one over anyone at this point...do you expect to see something really scummy before nightfall? If you are against voting out FF, how will you decide who gets your vote?

i can understand how i seem scummy. I also dont see how being an idiot gets me lynched, and misunderstanding/reading posts.

 

[IceH2O]

I'd forgotten that the nights that town or scum can investigate are different, so what you're saying makes a bit more sense now. I still don't see why I shouldn't vote for who I feel is the scummiest. Maybe someone will do something more scummy before nightfall and I'll change, but you gotta admit, what FF has done is quite scummy for day 1. I doubt there will be much better to go on today.

You say you have no one over anyone at this point...do you expect to see something really scummy before nightfall? If you are against voting out FF, how will you decide who gets your vote?

Sorry this quote should have been in my last post which I answered with a quote of my own which states I'm not against voting FF.


There are still 32 hours for someone to seem scummy. I'm not sure enough of anyone to place a vote so being Day 1 I'm going to be a bit more cautious especially under the win rules of this game.

 

[Fishfriend1]

hey dawg, when i die can you pm the players names and roles? I just want to know lol. I have also resigned myself to the lynch, and dont think Lab is evil, that was just an OMUGSy vote. I retract my vote on lab.

 

[Madcrawdad]

1st of all I never said I wouldn't vote FF. I said I think there isn't a reason to since he painted a big target on his own back.

Actually Ice, you did say that you wouldn't vote FF...

I've said why I won't vote FF. He is already marked. The innocents invest tonight. They can invest him and if he is mafia then they can either hit him or somehow wait for a few votes to fall his way. If he is innocent they don't need to do anything and it will be up to the mafia to decide if they want to hit him or not.

FF if mafia will continue to screw up, I'm in the mindset that I'd rather watch FF for a few days and see what transpires from the comm teams.

 

[johnlarson66]

My head hurts!

Why must FF be the center of attention? I really thought we were past this. I guess old habbits are hard to berak.

 

[Fishfriend1]

annie, y r u lurking?

 

[johnlarson66]

I vote to lynch Lab_Rat.

Being the third vote on FF just seems to easy of a place to hide. Plus she is trying to make sense out of what FF posts. Also FF did not get OMGUSy on Lab, FF voted on Lab before Lab voted. Dag voted for FF and so did DD, but FF did not get all freaked out.

Who knows what FF is? Can anyone really tell by how he is playing? Is a team really going to investigate him or hit him? FF is once again the center of attention. Trying to make sense out of FF or building a case against FF is a joke.