Mafia #67 - 50/50 -- The Play

[rich311k]

I vote to lynch jb.

Just about to head home and I want to be sure to have my vote in. In the odd case I don't get back on the computer.

 

[Kashta]

and ya'll talk about me being non committal? Care to take a stance Kash?

That's pretty funny, Noods. I posted a paragraph on more than a few names where most folks just make them one-liners.

I believe this the first time you've ever asked me to elaborate. lmao. :laugh:

 

[Madcrawdad]

As Mad tells us this 50/50 format is more about the numbers and individuals revealing their alignment in this game (either directly or in more subtle ways)... I believe it would be most helpful if other players would also post a full list of players and share comments about them.

I disagree. With scum in the lead, any complete lists done by innocents, that are actually truthful, will only help communicating scum with determining targets.

In an effort to help protect suspected same-aligned teammates, I don't really expect anyone's list to be completely truthful anyway.

FYI, as I said earlier, my strongest suspects for scum alignment are Ice, Wiz and JB.

 

[Kashta]

Here's a short list. Some just leaning as mafia for right now (as in Mad's case) and others I've suspected the first day but gone back and forth on.

Annie, Dag, Jpappy, Lab Rat, Mad, Noods, Rich, Tank.

^^ Alphabetical order since I don't yet know which way to rank them.

Think it'll be interesting to see which of these people end up voting together (again) just on JB this time, as they were similarly aligned in the majority vote against FF on Day 1.

I vote to lynch Lab Rat for now.

Subject to change as more votes get placed, switched, or whatever.

 

[Fishfriend1]

opcorn: opcorn: opcorn: opcorn: opcorn: opcorn:

 

[IceH2O]

Not arguing about known scum...arguing about your contention that even as scum, FF should be kept around. But I think you know that...



Not protecting anyone. Just pointing out your early morning back-track on D2.

According to your post, Lab was not much more scummy, but that she was ALSO scum, along with FF... You NEVER moved the kid to innocent as you're now claiming to have done, UNTIL HE FLIPPED TOWN. Really convenient.

Awesome job there Mad. You pulled a post from the middle of day 1 where I entertained the thought that Lab might be mafia along with FF. If the players would like to go back through and read they can make their own interpretation by how hard I was after Lab if I had FF leaning more innocent.


After reading last nights posts and todays posts I was thinking of maybe moving my vote.

The person I would move to would be Noods.

I'm not sure how Noods can think Lab is mafia when she used Labs reasoning to vote FF out. This is making me wonder if Lab wasn't an overzealous innocent.
Can't vote Dag because my only real thought on him at this time is protection of Lab and vice versa.

I can see the thoughts on JB and I have floundered some on him.But I don't like that Annie and Rich are there.

While Lab might be mafia she could also be an overzealous innocent. I promised to be open minded and there are still parts of posts and and misinterpretations of posts that I find to be a problem. Not only FF but others.

Ok, I just caught this...how do you know SB is a he??? As far as I know, Kash, Noods, DD, and I are not he's.

I'm not sure what she is trying here to implicate me with except that maybe I am a comm and invested the SB and slipped. Truth be told I always refer to a PR as he. I'd like to hear from her what the implication was.




I still don't trust Lab, but I'm not liking Noods much either. Always bothers me when someone uses the same reason as another to get someone lynched but then says such and such is mafia. If you came to the same conclusion and you think Lab is scum then you must be also.

 

[jbradt]

I guess the only choice I have... I vote to lynch Lab_Rat.

 

[Lab_Rat]

I'm not sure what she is trying here to implicate me with except that maybe I am a comm and invested the SB and slipped. Truth be told I always refer to a PR as he. I'd like to hear from her what the implication was.

I've been trying to figure out who SB is (in addition to the scum, particularly communicating scum) so I was interested to why you referred to SB as a he. But if that's how you refer to all PRs then that's understandable.

 

[Dangerdoll]

ok, sorry I was gone all day guys... had a really busy day at work... going off the cuff, I would say that my vote would be between Laggy and Dag for being the most suspicious but I have to catch up with reading... in order for me not to UD, I am going with the vote on Labby.... I will post as I read through if there are questions for me or if I have concerns... for now I vote to lynch Labby

 

[Lab_Rat]

ok, sorry I was gone all day guys... had a really busy day at work... going off the cuff, I would say that my vote would be between Laggy and Dag for being the most suspicious but I have to catch up with reading... in order for me not to UD, I am going with the vote on Labby.... I will post as I read through if there are questions for me or if I have concerns... for now I vote to lynch Labby

So what's so suspicious about me that makes you want to lynch me? I expected the votes from the others, are you simply aligning yourself with your scummy teammates to vote me out?