Mafia #69: Ghost Hunters Game Thread

[noodles62]

Noods, this post bothers me. If you believed Dawg about Mael, why would you need a consensus to vote Mael?



Here, no consensus yet, but 1 minute after Ice switches you followed.

This looks a little fishy to me.

reading real quick while I have my coffee -

my statement was in referecne to the fact that there was discussion of splitting the votes between Mael and Bio. I was not sure at the time if that was the case or to just lynch Mael outright. I decided to go ahead and place my vote as i was on the way out the door and wanted to get my vote done.

 

[noodles62]

a few things, Could someone please tell me how I am scummy?

Sorry I haven't had the time this weekend to devote to the game, but real world issues this weekend have not been kind.

I guess I'm still not seeing how Bio is scummy. The way it looks to me, and this is just a generalizations, because I'm exhausted after today, and don't have the patience to find every old post, but it appears to me that ice and wiz have been the ring leaders getting others to jump on board without conclusive reasoning to get the townies to lynch innocent people. I wouldn't even put it past them to vote for their own kind to divert suspicion. AND, why would they need to place a hit out on any of us when they can just have the townies do it for them?

I'm still not going to vote Bio, just to jump on the bio bandwagon, I can't say for sure she's innocent, but I'm sure all of you will think this is one evil trying to save another. We've seen how following the mighty ice and Wiz has done us SOOO well. It took Dawg getting real info to get the last scum lynched. My biggest question right now is, why did he wait so long and put us all at risk longer before presenting this info?

this post bothers me. first of all I am not 100% positive that you and Bio are scum but you are the most suspicious in my mind at that moment. I do not agree that Ice and Wiz are ring leaders and everyone is just following them. I have my own brain and have voted for my own reasons with the exception of Mael which was pretty much a no brainer. not sure how Dawg waiting to put out his info put anyone at risk??? it is not always an easy decision to come out and reveal your role or info that you have received.
The townies made the decision to lynch Labby which was a good choice and we made the decision to beleive Dawg and got another scum... I am not seeing how we are being led around ignorantly and erroneuously. sounds like grasping at straws and you are blatantly protecting Bio in the process....

gotta get ready for work now....ttfn

 

[IceH2O]

Honestly Wiz I'm starting to think you are evil. The questions you just asked of Noods and myself are strange. I could see DDs questions being somewhat relevant.
What part of my explanation didn't you understand? What good was it going to be to move to Mael if we didn't have enough votes to oust him and the evils were able to jump to JRR who already had 2 votes and kill him because we were spread out on Mael and Bio.

I've felt Bio has been evil since she voted me then switched to a worthless vote on ILM. Could she be innocent,sure but her and CCM have the worst looking cases and we have controlling numbers so a mistake or 2 won't hurt us.

You do make a good point about Maels post though. Only other person I'd switch to at this time is CCM.

 

[AnniesNotOK]

I vote to lynch BIO.

JRR that was a fine display of poor sportsmanship.

Sorry I wasn't here to switch to Mael. I fully intended to spend some time yesterday reviewing the thread, and didn't. I am overwhelmed in RL.

I was the kill vote on Lab and have been voting for Bio since Lab was lynched. Mael was blowing smoke my way for some time now. I think it should stand to reason I am not on a team with them.

Darn, innocent again.

 

[BioHazard]

I vote to lynch BIO.

JRR that was a fine display of poor sportsmanship.

Sorry I wasn't here to switch to Mael. I fully intended to spend some time yesterday reviewing the thread, and didn't. I am overwhelmed in RL.

I was the kill vote on Lab and have been voting for Bio since Lab was lynched. Mael was blowing smoke my way for some time now. I think it should stand to reason I am not on a team with them.

Darn, innocent again.

It's just a game.
JRR has a real life too, and her JUST got a new job. You can't plan stuff like that coming up.
I think he was doing what he honestly thought was best. It sucks, yeah, but we can deal with it.

 

[BioHazard]

the reason I was quiet Bio was because my husband played this weekend for my b'day, and I have been pretty much celebrating until today when I had to tend to the stuff I didn't do all weekend.

I vote to lynch Bio

Bah, sorry. I keep forgetting!

 

[dirtydawg10]

a few things, Could someone please tell me how I am scummy?

Sorry I haven't had the time this weekend to devote to the game, but real world issues this weekend have not been kind.

I guess I'm still not seeing how Bio is scummy. The way it looks to me, and this is just a generalizations, because I'm exhausted after today, and don't have the patience to find every old post, but it appears to me that ice and wiz have been the ring leaders getting others to jump on board without conclusive reasoning to get the townies to lynch innocent people. I wouldn't even put it past them to vote for their own kind to divert suspicion. AND, why would they need to place a hit out on any of us when they can just have the townies do it for them?

I'm still not going to vote Bio, just to jump on the bio bandwagon, I can't say for sure she's innocent, but I'm sure all of you will think this is one evil trying to save another. We've seen how following the mighty ice and Wiz has done us SOOO well. It took Dawg getting real info to get the last scum lynched. My biggest question right now is, why did he wait so long and put us all at risk longer before presenting this info?

I guess you chose to skim my post where I came out with the info on Mael and described why I waited. I was hoping Mael would give us more clues with their posting before I outed them. It seems like a very good choice to me because as soon as I posted that Mael was scum he never made another post. What do you think of that? I think you are scum and just showed your cards even more. The only reason for you to skim my post on Mael is if you already knew what he was. You also decided to not change your vote to Mael like the rest of the Town. I'm almost more willing to vote for you than Bio at this point.

 

[dirtydawg10]

Bio, who do you plan to vote for? Would you be willing to vote for CCM?


JRR while I can understand your frustrations with people coming after you as being scum that is all part of the game. Don't take it personally. Often times PR's get confused with scum...it just happens. I wish you had stuck around to provide your protections for future hits but unfortunately you decided not to. Hopefully next time you will think twice about quitting on the Town. Sorry to see you go.

 

[the wizard]

Honestly Wiz I'm starting to think you are evil. The questions you just asked of Noods and myself are strange. I could see DDs questions being somewhat relevant.
What part of my explanation didn't you understand? What good was it going to be to move to Mael if we didn't have enough votes to oust him and the evils were able to jump to JRR who already had 2 votes and kill him because we were spread out on Mael and Bio.

I've felt Bio has been evil since she voted me then switched to a worthless vote on ILM. Could she be innocent,sure but her and CCM have the worst looking cases and we have controlling numbers so a mistake or 2 won't hurt us.

You do make a good point about Maels post though. Only other person I'd switch to at this time is CCM.

I did not say that I didn't understand your post, only that it didn't sit well with me.

I too was suspicious of Bio an voted her twice. However, after being up most the night reading old posts and trying to pull some thoughts together to make sure we keep getting scum, I saw where the contradiction I originally jumped on her for wasn't really a contradiction.

combined with the post that Mael used to get us looking at her, and the fact that he took that part of the post out of context, I am not comfortable voting where a known scum wanted us to vote.

I pulled the entire post of LR's last night so everyone could read it again, in context.

With what I read from old posts, I am not ready or comfortable voting just yet. I will take my laptop with me so if it looks like I won't get home in time I can find an unsecured wireless network somewhere so I can vote and not UD.

 

[dirtydawg10]

I retract my vote on Bio and vote to lynch CCM

I think we need to make this a 2 or 3 horse race at this point. If we are wrong or scum move around to save their own at least we get more information than everyone piling on one suspect. The odds are definitely with us but we need to get info from the lynches from here on out because I have a hard time believeing the EVP is going to help any more and we have no psychic or doc.