Mafia #69: Ghost Hunters Game Thread

[the wizard]

:jaw:I did not see this coming! Got any reasons, other then low posting?

This question was put to you Bio, and unless I am just blind, I don't recall you answering as to your vote switch.

 

[Kashta]

BTW, my last post was in response to this quote.

What more do you want to know Kash?

Still think it would've been easier for you to answer the questions as they were asked previously. Oh well..

 

[BioHazard]

I believe the "jumping" and "dart throwing" you are referring to is called bush kicking.

Unless I am mistaken that is how you gain suspects, by seeing how they respond or not to your questions.

You seem to have taken the bush kicking very hard, does it make you nervous?

What I dont like about your bush kicking is that there does not seem to be a whole lot of logic behind it. Other people have offered decent reasons for their votes (except ILM). You don't seem to be doing anything except grasping at thin air. Your reason for voting against me was that I had supposedly made contradictory statements. My statements were not, in fact, contradictory. The fact that you are running after me based on faulty logic, logic which Lady, who had not said much of anything, suddenly jumped on, makes me suspicious.
I feel like you are not so much kicking bushes with a purpose, but simply flailing about to direct attention at anyone but yourself.

 

[Madcrawdad]

Dawg, While I can agree with you voting for someone you think to be scummy, I did the same, with night approaching are you comfortable with leaving yours as a lone vote?

Actually I would ask this of all the players with a lone vote out there. Are any of you willing, with night approaching and three players with multiple votes, to make it a race?

Or do you all feel more comfortable with your "safe" votes?

I don't consider a singleton vote, especially on D1, a 'safe' vote. Townies should vote for who they think is scum, not necessarily for someone who has other votes on them.

Not saying it's scummy, but it always bugs me when people call a singleton vote on D1 a 'wasted' or 'safe' vote. Voting with the masses doesn't guarantee lynching scum.

IMO voting with the masses can be as equally 'safe' on D1.

From the few games I have played, it has been brought to my attention by veteran players that a lone vote is often considered a "safe" vote.

Maybe by some, but not me. I can think of multiple occasions, where as town, I sat all alone on a player D1, who later flipped scum. Not saying that it's often, but it's happened.

 

[captaincaveman9]

From the few games I have played, it has been brought to my attention by veteran players that a lone vote is often considered a "safe" vote.

What are your thoughts on the other three?

I am not saying JL is innocent as I have asked a few questions of him, but what are your thoughts on Bio, Ice or FF?

I don't think FF is innocent at all, just he's learning how to play the game. His last few posts he seems more relaxed. However, I still get a scummy vibe from him.

Ice has his sights on 7 people. And, he seems to point his finger readily at anyone. I'm not 100% sure he's scum, but I don't trust him either.

Bio, I'm not really sure what to think of her yet. I do think she cast her vote pretty early on, and her latest switch of her vote seems more of a safe vote.

I still think JL is top of my list of suspected scum.

 

[the wizard]

I still need a good reason to lynch bio, other then to save myself.

Can we have a vote list plz?

This post shows one of two things, 1) either an innocent with integrity or 2) a great coaching job in the scum den.

Since I have not seen any thing in FF's posts like when JB was able to reel him in a couple of games back, I would have to say I lean more towards 1.

 

[BioHazard]

This question was put to you Bio, and unless I am just blind, I don't recall you answering as to your vote switch.

Ah, I didn't get that one.
And the snarky comment is really not necessary.

Anyway, FF, I voted for ILM because
-Despite being asked several times, they never explained WHY they voted for you
-They have not posted anything constructive. And no, Wiz, I am not saying that every thing I write down should be bound into a novel, but I HAVE made constructive posts.
-Despite being on the site (I saw him in chat for quite a while), they have not posted anything or responded to my questions or the questions of others

 

[the wizard]

I don't think FF is innocent at all, just he's learning how to play the game. His last few posts he seems more relaxed. However, I still get a scummy vibe from him.

Ice has his sights on 7 people. And, he seems to point his finger readily at anyone. I'm not 100% sure he's scum, but I don't trust him either.

Bio, I'm not really sure what to think of her yet. I do think she cast her vote pretty early on, and her latest switch of her vote seems more of a safe vote.

I still think JL is top of my list of suspected scum.

Fair enough and thank you for answering my questions instead of ducking them like some players do.

 

[IceH2O]

I don't think FF is innocent at all, just he's learning how to play the game. His last few posts he seems more relaxed. However, I still get a scummy vibe from him.

Ice has his sights on 7 people. And, he seems to point his finger readily at anyone. I'm not 100% sure he's scum, but I don't trust him either.

Bio, I'm not really sure what to think of her yet. I do think she cast her vote pretty early on, and her latest switch of her vote seems more of a safe vote.

I still think JL is top of my list of suspected scum.

So if you think FF is scummy I am scummy and JL is scummy and only 2 of us have a chance at being lynched then why vote the 3rd person who has no chance of getting lynched?
If you want to send scum packing you need to place a vote where it counts and since 2 of your suspects have votes and you aren't voting on either makes me wonder why that is.

 

[Kashta]

Vote count I've updated...

Day 1

(4) FF - JL (19) JRR (87) CCM (145) Annie (155) Rich (216) ILM (332)
(1) CCM - Madcrawdad (109) the Wiz (164)
(1) Maelstrom - DD (140)
(4) Ice - Lab (180) Kashta (188) Bio (194) Mael (287) Noods (347) FF (363)
(1) Noods - Ice (238)
(4) Bio - Wizard (239) Lady G (265) Kashta (361) Mad (383)
(1) Lab - Annie (335)
(1) Annie - Dawg (342)
(1) ILM - Bio (377)
(1) JL - CCM (449)

No votes: All have voted.