Mafia #7 -- The Play

[ZSandmann]

The only thing I ever noticed about Sway's posting was her saying she bought a convenience store (50), and then saying she apparently inherited a convenience store (88),,,that is the only thing I saw a little peculiar about her postings...

and when someone is accused of being Mafia and they know they aren't, they tend to very defensive, I know when I was Mafia in game 4 and the game prior to this, I really didn't defend myself very well.. and maybe her multilple posts was just ranting...

My vote still stays on Jo, for the reasons I had posted earlier.....

MeeMee stops by Sway's house to see how she is holding up, and Sway looks scared for some reason, MeeMee brings her some of her eclairs and it seems to put a smile back on Sway's face....Don't worry Sway, meemee says, Me and Chi will look after your goldfish, if you have to leave town so suddenly...

Yup I pointed out the story inconsistency yesterday but no one even replied to my post, glad to see others are finally looking at her like I am.

 

[Swayde]

Eh, the convenience store was not my idea. It was suggested to be my role if I chose to roleplay. So I guess in the future I'll just stick to my house and goldfish.

 

[IceH2O]

I am thinking of changing my vote to Ice because of all the hooplah on the whole train on sway issue. There was the one post in regards to defending himself before anyone thought that maybe Sway is in fact innocent. Then, persists on explaining his reasons for not wanting a train to ensue.

I'm going out on a limb, I realize it's close to time but I am switching my vote. I just don't feel as strongly for Sway as I do for Ice. I unvote Sway and vote to lynch Ice

Eh, I've already explained why I posted numerous times. If you don't understand it by now nothing else I say will convince you.

Its not the normal mafia game, there are 8 possible people to get a train going. All they need is a couple of people to vote for someone they know is innocent then they can all jump on. If everyone votes for Sway there isn't a reason for them to have to hide or distribute their votes.

 

[wataugachicken]

Going to vote today Wata?

Yeah, eventually. Not sure if i want to go with Swayde, or JL. *Someone* still continues to lurk around, and yet has offered absolutely nothing to the town, except stating what everyone already knows based on past Mafia games. No new thoughts, no suspects, just a useless defense that I still think is a ploy.

I agree that Ice's back peddling is something of a concern.

I know that people do not agree, but this first day we are all pretty much in the dark. If we get a mafia, then great, the odds are in our favor to get one.

At this point, I do not see any glaring signs that Swayde is any more mafia than anyone else. It really seems these first few days we lynch the vocal ones.

While I am not against lynching Swayde, because we will learn something from it, I am not sure if I like the idea of so many people voting the same way on the first day.

Also, the person starting the train is not always the one leading the train.

If Swayde is innocent, then I think we should look into Ice.

If Swayde is mafia, then we should look at those that did not vote for her or voted late. I do not think the mafia would vote for their own on the first day.

There is nothing new here, just a regurgitation of common information, masquerading as deep thoughts.

I Vote for JohnLarson

 

[IceH2O]

I guess we all need to be careful, a vote no longer means lets discuss. It seems to be a train starter from the start.

 

[Dangerdoll]

Eh, I've already explained why I posted numerous times. If you don't understand it by now nothing else I say will convince you.

Its not the normal mafia game, there are 8 possible people to get a train going. All they need is a couple of people to vote for someone they know is innocent then they can all jump on. If everyone votes for Sway there isn't a reason for them to have to hide or distribute their votes.

I completely understand them on the posts you posted your explanations in. No need to do it again, I understood them all perfectly well but thanks for the mention.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Swayde is sad that she never really got to know anyone in her new town. She tried to be a good neighbor and tried to run an honest business. I guess in a town overrun with criminals there is no room for her. She will miss her goldfish most of all, and Mee-Mee's delicious eclairs.

My vote shall remain on IceH20. He's my top suspect. I was really hoping to get to play more than this, but oh well. Must be fate telling me to stay off my computer Good luck townies. I'll be following along in my free time and cheering you guys on in spirit. Please, avenge my death, don't make my die in vain.

If you're Innocent then I think we really need to look hard at those that voted for you later and especially in a cluster (Mad 144 DD 145 Jo 149 DC 152) and those that removed their votes. No vote KOTD? I'm not convinced of your innocence or guilt, but if mafia cool. If not, you're death won't be in vain.

Please refer to this if I am hit tonight (happens alot ).

 

[Swayde]

I guess we all need to be careful, a vote no longer means lets discuss. It seems to be a train starter from the start.

You are the one who brought up the whole train starting topic when you decided to shift the blame onto someone else.

 

[IceH2O]

You are the one who brought up the whole train starting topic when you decided to shift the blame onto someone else.

The train happened last night after I went to bed, thats why I posted that I wasn't the one to start it. I wanted to make sure no one looked seen my vote 1st and automatically assumed.

It was the 1st vote of the game, besides Jls vote for role play which no one takes seriously.

Someone had to vote, I just didn't want everyone to follow like that without good reasons of their own.

I don't like the I agree I vote approach.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Yeah, eventually. Not sure if i want to go with Swayde, or JL. *Someone* still continues to lurk around, and yet has offered absolutely nothing to the town, except stating what everyone already knows based on past Mafia games. No new thoughts, no suspects, just a useless defense that I still think is a ploy.
I Vote for JohnLarson

I agree that he's beginning to look suspicious, but do you have a list of any other suspects? We need to all post our thoughts so that we can have something to compare to. We almost lost the last game, because the townies (Patriots) couldn't get enough info out there to focus on the most likely overall suspects. I've "parked" my vote on Jo, because he's my highest suspect, t's day 1, and I am really not happy with how quickly everyone voted on Swayde (my #2). We need to do more discussing and less quick voting IMO.