Mafia #7 -- The Play

[DeputyChiefJR]

I vote to lynch Ice.

Have to get ready for work, I woke up a bit late...My explanation is due to the fact that he's playing very defensively and seems to create more confusion than he clears up this game. Usually he's a calm guiding force, this game it's different.

 

[ZSandmann]

welp, sorry for the no vote, i would have placed it on ice but i wasn't around..

i am 100% sure ice is mafia

i vote to lynch ice

go with ice!

you wont be sorry

i said i was the detective? where?

your posts make me 100% sure, i mean..its pretty obvious your not playing like you have in past games..plus the whole thing with swayde has brought you under suspicion..and your trying your best to put the spotlight on someone else.

Did I miss something here? KOTD I can't say I like you trying to tell us who we should vote for while ever so subtly :footinmouth: implying you are Detective. Sure Ice looks like a good target. That's why it bothers me, it's like you've chosen the most likely suspect to come out with a miraculous "JM"esque vision about. Maybe Ice is Mafia, maybe he isn't, but why would you miss voting then show up right after Day 2 begins and run a rail on someone?

 

[Madcrawdad]

Gonna be another hot one today. Madcrawdad decides to spend some time at the beach. If he's going to wear that Speedo, though, he'd better stop by the salon for that free bikini wax that Chas mentions in his all of his advertisements ...

 

[ZSandmann]

Day One is just guessing in the dark.

All of this "looks mafia" stuff is complete BS.

If there are people that think I am mafia because of my day one voting for role playing, then I suggest that you make your move now.

Let's get to the bottom of this.

If you really think I am mafia for voting for the first role player, then by all means vote for me. If this is going to be used against me the whole game, then lets clear it up now.

In the next game, I am going to do the same.

I also know that as a group, we have decided that voting for no body on day one is bad for the town. Well, historicly our lynches have been bad for the town as far as killing an innocent.

What have we learned from last nights lynch train. Almost nothing. We all got a chance to see Ice freak out about the train. The more I think about it and the more I do not see him freaking out about the votes he has on him now makes a good case for him, as an innocent.

We really need to focus on who the mafia hit and who they did not hit.

We also need to think as if we were in the mafia, who would we want to hit. Most of us have been mafia at least once, so we should understand this. If I was mafia, I would not hit Ice, I would let the town lynch him. I have to think who would I hit.

So why did they hit Lady G? Was she onto something. Was what she onto going to put us on a wild goose chase?

vote change

I vote to lynch ZSandmann

Why ZS? The mafia did not kill hit him and he "wanted" me to vote for him on day one.

I also think voting Ice out at this time is a mistake.

I can't speak for the rest of the folks on the list but I can only say for certain that Lady didn't have it completely right. My thought on why Lady G was hit was because she was so much quieter than last round when she was a Rebel. I was even beginning to think she had a role this round. I can't say I understand why you'd vote for me for not being hit because only one person a Night can be hit and there are two teams. Mad, Charlie, Ice, yourself, DD, ... etc. etc. are also still here. And while I wouldn't say I "wanted" you to vote for me, I don't care about getting hit with your RP vote. I like to roleplay and I'll continue to do so in future rounds. BTW, I thought that when you RP in the werewolf game you were very good, I still don't see why you are so against it.

 

[ZSandmann]

i'm more inclined to go with theory A, as that doesnt look like a list of innocents. Also, during nightfall, i kept refreshing and instead of checking the posts, i was checking the users viewing the thread. CONSTANTLY. I had an interesting result. Each time it said 14 users viewing thread, with only one name appearing, JohnLarson. I literaly keep checking over and over. No change. Until a moment came when two names where appearing, but the total amount of people viewing hadn't changed. Still only 14. It suggested to me that the name now appearing had switched from invisible mode. Is this a reach?? Yep, and i am reluctant to disclose who that was until there is some discussion because it does seem to be reaching a bit. But the name is on that list of 4 so its worth discussion methinks

That would be sploke, and yes I noticed it too.

 

[plantling]

JL i agree that it is very important to consider who was not hit. When there is one team, i fully expect certain players will be dead (Coler or Mad as examples) come morning and when they are not, i become suspicious that they are mafia. With two teams it's far more difficult. For all i know the "New School" was trying to kill a skilled player but got an investigation instead.
We must look into why they killed Lady G. I look at her post and see 4 names that i can be fairly certain she isn't aligned with.
Ice
Sploke
ZSandman
Wata.
So, the Old School Gang, who would of believed Lady was innocent methinks, either killed her because:
A. She has named at least two of them. In the past when she was an innocent, she has proven herself a skillfull investigator. They cannot let her ruin their plans.
B. She has named a list of innocents. Thinking she was innocent, they wanted us to follow her list.

I'm inclined to believe A also, Chaz. I believe she named at least two and here's another copy and paste of the list I made if anyone wants to discuss the 2 possiblilities.

post 168-She lists KOTD, Sploke, Z
170-Wata
172-JL, HN, mee-mee (She suspects 3 pple not voting Swayde as being on Swayde's team)
173-Sploke, Wata, Swayde (She states these have not voted)
200-Sploke
208-Ice
209-Ice
211-She apologizes to Sploke
213-jokes w/Ice about being God

At the moment Ice is still high on my list, but KOTD who was also on my list and who is urging for ppl to vote Ice is now ranking pretty high, too.

 

[wataugachicken]

i retract my vote for swayde

something tells me she's innocent..

Something. . . like what?

sorry guys..got a little mixed up here..i went to bed thinking the day game was today..its actually tomorrow..good thing i checked.

so i'll be around today to check in from time to time

So you're actually around all day. . . . but you never check in at all - no more discussion of other suspects, or reasoning as to why you retracted your vote, or any attempt to pin suspicion on anyone.

welp, sorry for the no vote, i would have placed it on ice but i wasn't around..

i am 100% sure ice is mafia

i vote to lynch ice

First of all, KOTD has played in most, if not all, of the games. He's been around enough to understand how it works, and know when nightfall is. Even if he wasn't around at nightfall, he had at least 8 hours all day to check in and cast a vote, and completely neglected the game. That tells me he absolutely doesn't care about the town.

I think the non-vote was a command from higher up to A. distance himself from the Swayde vote and B. give KOTD a clear shot at going after Ice. Might be better if he had some reasoning, or even pulled quotes over from other people to explain the way he feels so sure, but nothing. Saying "100%" really makes me nervous, no one in this game is 100% anything, not until they're dead.

go with ice!

you wont be sorry

Why? What makes you so sure, except that he's not on your team?

i said i was the detective? where?

your posts make me 100% sure, i mean..its pretty obvious your not playing like you have in past games..plus the whole thing with swayde has brought you under suspicion..and your trying your best to put the spotlight on someone else.

The whole thing with swayde has brought YOU under suspicion. This is like watching the pot talk to the kettle. . .

already explained it

lynch me if you want

No, no, you really haven't explained anything new. I think you have just been looking for an opportunity to jump on Ice and you took it. Your attitude is very flippant, again makes me think that you are working against the interests of the town. Your confidence makes me very suspicious, because the only thing you could possibly know about Ice is if he is on your team. if he is not on your team, he is the enemy, and since he a good player generally, it's best to get rid of him asap for whatever reason possible.

I think KOTD is OLD MAFIA. After taking out Lady G, who has quickly become a formidable player and investigator after only two full games, they are turning their attention to the next most dangerous player, Ice.

 

[wataugachicken]

Also, last time when KOTD was innocent and got lynched, he acted very sulky and got a huge attitude, though he didn't do much in the way of defense. This time people are looking at him, and he's acting like it's no big deal, "ha ha, lynch me if you want".

I want.

I vote for KOTD

 

[DeputyChiefJR]

Gonna be another hot one today. Madcrawdad decides to spend some time at the beach. If he's going to wear that Speedo, though, he'd better stop by the salon for that free bikini wax that Chas mentions in his all of his advertisements ...

Shudders...I so wish I hadn't decided to check this thread on the way out the door.

 

[Dangerdoll]

Gonna be another hot one today. Madcrawdad decides to spend some time at the beach. If he's going to wear that Speedo, though, he'd better stop by the salon for that free bikini wax that Chas mentions in his all of his advertisements ...

:hypnotized: oh Charlie, I hope you have help for your shop....


:rofl: