Mafia #7 -- The Play

just thought of something. . . the snitch is a mafia (mafioso? mafium?), but does the snitch know ALL the mafia players or only the ones on his team? if ice is actually the snitch, and only knows the other players on his team, this is really an oppurtunity for the town. for example, if Ice is new mafia, and only knows his teammates, he can only give us 2 mafia names, since Lady G is already dead. he could also name himself, but i think that would be unlikely (until now, when i just posted it). So, if he is called upon to snitch tonight (if we don't end up lynching him), he'll give one name. The next time, it'll be the other name. the third time he might name himself, but if he lasts as long as a fourth time, one of the names has to be repeated. we don't have to worry about people "getting turned" like we did in the werewolf game. I think it would be perfectly fine to keep our "pocket mafia" around as long as possible. of course, Ice is likely to be taken out tonight by the mafia anyway since he has been uncovered as a liability to them. i'm not sure if we should vote for him or not, if we could be looking for other mafia-people. Whether or not Ice is the snitch, it is impossible for anyone to prove it until he is dead, and now that the seed of doubt has been planted his mafia brethren aren't going to tolerate him for very long.
 
This isn't the same type of game DD, there are more mafia to train. More people to point fingers at me and get a train going.

Its tons easier for them to manipulate a vote with 2 teams.
 
JL and Jo have both fallen off of the map. . . . i guess if they don't feel like they have to defend themselves, it's not worth posting or trying to help the town. once everyone focused on ice and KOTD, they just kinda snuck away.
 
he still counts as mafia, snitch or not

with the doctors protection i will be able to find the other 7, and as soon as i find out, so will you guys..so we really dont need the snitch.

So you will be safe as long as there are only hits on you and not lynches...

Here is one thing I am concerned about though, as far as New and Old go,...like RB said, whoever has the most left on their team wins, like 3 Old to 2 New and 4 Innocents...then the Old win...

And us Townies win when we get every last one of the New and Old...


was it a wise thing to come out so early as the Detective...maybe maybe not
 
JL and Jo have both fallen off of the map. . . . i guess if they don't feel like they have to defend themselves, it's not worth posting or trying to help the town. once everyone focused on ice and KOTD, they just kinda snuck away.

TY, I've been trying to get discussion going to no avail. Seems as though everyone is content with just 2 possibilities. KOTD seems on the up and up, but there are a few things that seem "over the top" to me (including the avatar change) so I can't be sure. Right now it might not matter, but I think I've got my vote on mafia. If we can get a good list of suspects with rational if/thens we can put ourselves in good shape.

So to all the townies... IF the Ice / KOTD thing weren't ongoing and attracting all the attention, who would you suspect and why?
 
JL and Jo have both fallen off of the map. . . . i guess if they don't feel like they have to defend themselves, it's not worth posting or trying to help the town. once everyone focused on ice and KOTD, they just kinda snuck away.

What map?

Why should I defend myself, maybe you missed my post earlier.

Also we should focus on Ice and KOTD.

I was almost convinced of Ice being Innocent.

vote change

I vote to lynch IceH2O


If this is a bluff from KOTD we will all know and we will lynch him.

I hope the Doctor knows this and will protect KOTD.
 
oh look, your name was mentioned and then you suddenly appear. . . .
 
What map?

Why should I defend myself, maybe you missed my post earlier.

Also we should focus on Ice and KOTD.

I was almost convinced of Ice being Innocent.

vote change

I vote to lynch IceH2O


If this is a bluff from KOTD we will all know and we will lynch him.

I hope the Doctor knows this and will protect KOTD.

Because your gut is telling you I am, follow that gut feeling because its right.

No one finds it suspicious that KOTD comes out when the heat is on him and posts not only that I'm a mafia but also the snitch?

He had no time to vote last night but had enough time to send in an investigation?

Sorry doesn't add up to me and not because I'm on the hot seat. I wouldn't believe it if he picked anyone.
 
AquariaCentral.com