yes the three that have posted suspicion of him happen to be the same three on his list...interesting...
Mafia #7 -- The Play
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
johnlarson66
These Pandas Rock
How did DD get on mp's list?
Here she said welcomed them to the thread. btw, mp did not respond, but did respond to plantling's welcome.
Then Dangerdoll puts together a list. OMG it includes the mystery player!
So that is how the three of us have ended up on mp's list.
I think the above list is a good start. I would like to have some others input. I think any of the three listed would be good to lynch.
Here she said welcomed them to the thread. btw, mp did not respond, but did respond to plantling's welcome.
Then Dangerdoll puts together a list. OMG it includes the mystery player!
So that is how the three of us have ended up on mp's list.
I think the above list is a good start. I would like to have some others input. I think any of the three listed would be good to lynch.
I would vote for any of these, pappy was eager to get his vote parked somewhere early in the game, sploke i have been watching seems scummy to me, HN until recently was flying under my radar but seems a little scummy too. Sploke is on more lists than the others.
johnlarson66
These Pandas Rock
While the mystery player has me annoyed.
There is still this list, is it a snitch list from the other snitch. Is this saying that either plantling, charlie or sploke is mafia?
The bad thing with the mystery player is that even if KOTD investigates them, they come up innocent. I think on the next investigation, KOTD should investigate one of these three. My choice is sploke.
I will keep my vote on mystery player.
can i ask you to elaborate on your list?? If you have made a list of people that think it might be possible you would be assigned a mafia role because they are losing, this doesn't seem to be very pro-town. Are you saying your suspects are gonna to be anyone that looks at you??? The idea of the game is to kick in peoples doors and uproot any scum you may find. How carefully have you been following along, my hairy friend??? If DD, JL and I hadn't posted our suspicions of you, who would have been on your list then???
I understand why I'm on the list and you are right about me not being able to contribute as much this game. The reasons for that are unrelated to the game. I've got today all to myself so I'll try to go back through everything and get what I can posted. Even if I'm lynched or hit, I want to see the town's winning streak extended.
This reason alone is enough to earn me a spot on the snitch list. Charlie, you know how it works. Rb asks for a list with x number of mafia, so you choose the least suspected mafia players and the most suspected innocents (or in this case possibly oppositce mafia team) to throw attention toward them. Unless the mafia is already in dire straits, it makes no sense for the snitch to name other mafia that are already suspected...its kind of a giveaway. Also, as I recall, the first snitch list from the last time Rb was GM, there was only one mafia member on it. I'm not saying that its the case this time, but IMO there's a decent shot that Ice is the only mafia on his list...by the time he sent it in he was probably pretty sure he was getting lynched anyway, so it was an opportunity to not really give any other mafia away.
Also, apparently no one noticed this but I've been onto Z since about day 1. I voted for him both nights, but everyone was busy following the crowd that I don't think my observations got much attention.
And K, sorry I didn't just jump on and go along with it, but I was skeptical. I guess you've pretty much proven yourself at this point. Good work.
It is natural to wonder about the mystery player, but not natural to vote to lynch someone after a first post, this is what makes me wonder, taking into consideration how quick to judge you seem to be, i think your scared out of your Witt's, as for my list , it was compiled from previous post's, and HN asked for it, my list stands for now. how ever you are a growing concern.
johnlarson66
These Pandas Rock
I should be working on my scaled list.
The more I think about the mystery player, the more I want them gone.
I am all for even being the conductor of the train.
I think lynching the mp gives KOTD a chance to investigate someone else.
Mystery player has done nothing but strike back at the people who have brought up their name.
We also know that the mp is not the doctor, nor has any other power role or special abilities. The mp is only here to add to the confusion. If they came in with a little more input, then I could halfway understand keeping them around.
I think it would be best to lynch the mystery player. I see no good reason not to lynch them. If anyone could give some insight, for or against the mystery player, I would like to hear it. For now, I see no better person to lynch.
The more I think about the mystery player, the more I want them gone.
I am all for even being the conductor of the train.
I think lynching the mp gives KOTD a chance to investigate someone else.
Mystery player has done nothing but strike back at the people who have brought up their name.
We also know that the mp is not the doctor, nor has any other power role or special abilities. The mp is only here to add to the confusion. If they came in with a little more input, then I could halfway understand keeping them around.
I think it would be best to lynch the mystery player. I see no good reason not to lynch them. If anyone could give some insight, for or against the mystery player, I would like to hear it. For now, I see no better person to lynch.
