Mafia #7 -- The Play

i have a person in mind for investigation, i have a list i'd like to go by for now, until someone on it is innocent, so far my top 2 have turned out mafia, ice and z.

MP would be a waste to investigate as already pointed out, but i also think lynching him right now would not be smart, we don't know what his role is, we don't know if he is for the town..i would wait until we have more information on him to just get rid of him.

right now, i like HN and sploke as targets..sploke was named on Ice's list, but i dont trust that list all that much, and JL has brought up some very interesting points concerning HN and the whole swayde thing.
what powers would the mystery player have??? i assume he has none after joining late, the worst case he is the thief since we know he can't be the kidnapper. But its more likely he/she has no powers at all. They can't be the Doc or you would be dead already.
 
what powers would the mystery player have??? i assume he has none after joining late, the worst case he is the thief since we know he can't be the kidnapper. But its more likely he/she has no powers at all. They can't be the Doc or you would be dead already.

i dont know, i just don't like the idea of lynching him so early
 
Mystery Player understands the days are short and the nights are long.

Really, the days are long and the nights are short.

Unless you are mafia, that work at night.

I guess this was role playing. Another reason to vote you out. What is your character, Homeless Person?
 
i dont know, i just don't like the idea of lynching him so early

Nor do I. People who are willing to just lynch MP on no evidence are acting a little anti-town IMO. It's really no different than Ice suggesting we toss DD from the game 'just because'.

MP may be mafia, but they may be innocent. People claiming that RB is using the MP to 'shore up' the mafia need to re-read RB's description of the Mystery Player.

The Mystery Person...they join the game after the events of game night #2. They will show innocent on any investigation. A random generator will decide if an Innocent or a Mafia, and what team they may be on.

RB says a random number generator will decide if the MP is with the town or mafia. I feel pretty secure in saying that RB is not lying about this....he's not 'shoring up' any side.

It would probably be in the town's best interest to let the MP prove themself (or hang themself) before just lynching them.
 
thru post 815....

to lynch....

joan (1) by hook

MP (2) by charlie 761 jl66 753

hook (1) by MP


A little over 18 hrs to nightfall, which is 12 Noon, Sunday, 09/02...

Should I throw in some comments to wake you folks up? (or lies ;) )
 
Jo- I still suspect him. Was very quiet since I replied to why I was “calling him out”. Then last night got defensive again, but quickly backed off when I answered him. If no one else thinks he looks suspicious (still), I'll move my vote so that it isn't a waste again.

Sploke- His posts have been “off” from just about the start of the game. He also played “confused”, but quickly figured things out once Plant & DD clarified things for him.


DC- See posts below. Unfortunately, there’s not a lot to go on since he’s only posted 14 times total.

Jpappy- I’d post quotes but 95% of them are just meaningless “chit-chat”. I don’t mind “chit chat” type posts necessarily, but he has been of no help to the town IMO. The other 5% of his posts are simply following others.

Mystery Player- No clue how to read him / her yet. I am concerned that they will always show innocent, but I don’t like the idea of just lynching them to remove an unknown variable.

KOTD- please investigate me if you have no better options.



If it’s good enough for folks to want to lynch me… This is the same case pretty much with a recalled vote. I really don’t see anyone else that strikes me as suspicious overall, but there do seem to be a lot of people being very quiet.

Ok, got home from work and read up...I do agree with the vote for Swayde...Ice has good instincts about things....Dunno if I trust him yet, but he always notices good stuff....

I also suspect:
JL - kind of defensive but "has nothing to add," is he laying low for any particular reason?

Mad & chicken - very quiet, mad's pointed out little things but often is just agreeing with thing....chicken has mostly roleplayed...loud enough to be noticed, quiet enough to stay under the radar

I always suspect CS, Ice, ZSand, and DD but mostly because they're so good at the game that it takes forever to get ANY bead on them and usually I'm wrong....lol


Then immediately follows with

Oops, forgot to vote while analyzing
I vote for Swayde.


Recalls his vote off of Swayde

Ok, I thought it out....while I'm not 100% certain Swayde is mafia I have already expressed serious concerns about chicken (the person, not the food)....I feel more comfortable voting for someone who I feel is mafia rather than someone who I've been convinced MIGHT be mafia...I may end up out on my own with this vote, but I'm ok with that...

I unvote Swayde and recast my vote for watachicken.




Recalls his vote off of Swayde

Ok, I thought it out....while I'm not 100% certain Swayde is mafia I have already expressed serious concerns about chicken (the person, not the food)....I feel more comfortable voting for someone who I feel is mafia rather than someone who I've been convinced MIGHT be mafia...I may end up out on my own with this vote, but I'm ok with that...

I unvote Swayde and recast my vote for watachicken.



Continues distancing himself from the vote

I originally thought that the logic behind sway was decent, but started considering things after she had posted for a bit....At that point I decided to go after a suspect I had come up with on my own...In the end, wata seemed like a better choice in my opinion...I wasn't going to be around during the day to post, but was hoping my vote would get some decent discussion....As CS has told me in previous games I'm supposed to help to bang on some doors, I'm trying to do my part in that regard...

 
Really, the days are long and the nights are short.

Unless you are mafia, that work at night.

I guess this was role playing. Another reason to vote you out. What is your character, Homeless Person?
Again misunderstanding, maybe the Innocent can't sleep at night because the mafia are after them, your reasoning astounds me,...
 
what powers would the mystery player have??? i assume he has none after joining late, the worst case he is the thief since we know he can't be the kidnapper. But its more likely he/she has no powers at all. They can't be the Doc or you would be dead already.
This is why i was wondering how you could vote me out before i made a real post, but you are convinced i'm mafia, and have said so.
 
Again misunderstanding, maybe the Innocent can't sleep at night because the mafia are after them, your reasoning astounds me,...

what does this have to do with the post you quoted?
 
AquariaCentral.com